The Courthouse Deli & Whit's Frozen Custard menù, Key West
The Courthouse Deli & Whit's Frozen Custard Key West - Menu
Popular Items
Turkey Avocado Club
Top menu item. Our best seller! Boar's head oven gold turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, fresh avocado, and herbed mayo on toasted white or multi-grain pepperidge farm bread (two pieces of bread, but three if you specify in instructions).
12.95 $
Cuban Mix Sandwich
The classic Cuban mix known to many as The Courthouse Deli's signature sandwich! Boar's head tavern ham, roast pork, dill pickles, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, swiss cheese, mayo, and mustard on freshly-baked Cuban bread from croissants de France. Pressed hot.
10.95 $
Roast Beef Au Jus Sandwich
Boar's head sliced eye of round beef roast, horseradish spread, red onion, provolone cheese, and au jus on Cuban bread from croissants de France. Served with container of au jus and pressed hot.
11.95 $
Fire Roasted Chicken Sandwich
New! This delicious new addition to our sandwich family has oven roasted chicken breast topped with roasted red peppers, banana peppers, pepper jack cheese, onion, lettuce, and herbed mayo served warm on a toasted focaccia roll.
11.95 $
Potato Salad
1 lb of roasted potato salad - a local favorite. Roasted red skin potatoes, celery, onion, pickle baron key lime bread, and butter pickle relish and mayo dressing. De-lish!
6.99 $
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Made fresh daily from boar's head ever roast all white meat chicken and served on your choice of pepperidge farm's white, multi-grain or rye or a flaky buttery croissant.
10.95 $
Chicken Salad
1 lb of chicken salad. A simple classic with tender all white meat boar's head oven gold chicken seasoned to perfection with crunchy celery, onion and creamy mayo dressing. The owner's favorite snack.
8.99 $
Hot Pastrami Sandwich
Pastrami with Swiss cheese and sauerkraut on toasted rye bread.
12.95 $
Pasta Salad
1 lb of pasta salad. Classic elbow pasta, red onions, celery, pickle baron key lime pickles, egg, and a touch of red pepper. Perfect for a picnic at the beach.
7.99 $
Reuben
Boar's head corned beef piled high with swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and French style dressing on toasted rye bread.
12.95 $
Breakfast
Breakfast Sandwich
Top menu item. Bacon or sausage, two eggs, and American cheese on Cuban bread served pressed/warm.
8.95 $
Egg & Avocado Breakfast Sandwich
Top menu item. Avocado, egg, and American cheese on a freshly made croissant.
9.95 $
Cuban Cheesy Toast Breakfast
Cuban toast with your choice of cheese.
3 $
Bagel
Plain, everything or garlic bagel made fresh locally every day served toasted with butter or cream cheese.
2.5 $
Snacks
Loaf of Pepperidge White Bread
4.69 $
Loaf of Pepperidge Farm Multi Grain Bread
4.99 $
Deli Dressing
Made with a traditional blend of extra virgin olive oil and red wine vinegar, this tasty sandwich dressing is seasoned to perfection with herbs and spices. Boar's head deli dressing is a flavorful finishing touch.
3.99 $
Yellow Mustard
Boar's head premium yellow mustard.
3.09 $
Dirty Chips
1.49 $
Wicked Hot Pickles - Pickle Baron of Key West
8.5 $
Dil-Liscious Pickles - Pickle Baron of Key West
Terrific local pickles - crunchy and full of flavor. Add a little pickle juice to your bloody mary and it's a party!
8.5 $
Salads
Potato Salad
1 lb of roasted potato salad - a local favorite. Roasted red skin potatoes, celery, onion, pickle baron key lime bread, and butter pickle relish and mayo dressing. De-lish!
6.99 $
Chicken Salad
1 lb of chicken salad. A simple classic with tender all white meat boar's head oven gold chicken seasoned to perfection with crunchy celery, onion and creamy mayo dressing. The owner's favorite snack.
8.99 $
Pasta Salad
1 lb of pasta salad. Classic elbow pasta, red onions, celery, pickle baron key lime pickles, egg, and a touch of red pepper. Perfect for a picnic at the beach.
7.99 $
Egg Salad
1 lb of egg salad. Just like home. Eggs, mayo, salt, and pepper. No frills awesomeness!
5.99 $
Tuna Salad
1 lb of tuna salad. White albacore tuna prepared simply with herbed mayo, relish, onions, and celery.
8.99 $
Sandwiches
Fire Roasted Chicken Sandwich
New! This delicious new addition to our sandwich family has oven roasted chicken breast topped with roasted red peppers, banana peppers, pepper jack cheese, onion, lettuce, and herbed mayo served warm on a toasted focaccia roll.
11.95 $
Cuban Mix Sandwich
The classic Cuban mix known to many as The Courthouse Deli's signature sandwich! Boar's head tavern ham, roast pork, dill pickles, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, swiss cheese, mayo, and mustard on freshly-baked Cuban bread from croissants de France. Pressed hot.
10.95 $
Turkey Avocado Club
Top menu item. Our best seller! Boar's head oven gold turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, fresh avocado, and herbed mayo on toasted white or multi-grain pepperidge farm bread (two pieces of bread, but three if you specify in instructions).
12.95 $
Caprese Salad Sandwich
This is a summer time smash. Light and healthy! Fresh ovaline mozzarella, basil pesto, and tomato slices with a balsamic glaze served on a crunchy focaccia roll.
10.95 $
Roast Beef Au Jus Sandwich
Boar's head sliced eye of round beef roast, horseradish spread, red onion, provolone cheese, and au jus on Cuban bread from croissants de France. Served with container of au jus and pressed hot.
11.95 $
Jeff's Italian Sandwich
Boar's head tavern ham, roast beef, and salami, red onions, roasted red peppers, provolone cheese, olive tapenade spread, olive oil, and glazed balsamic reduction on Cuban bread from croissants de France.
12.95 $
Reuben
Boar's head corned beef piled high with swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and French style dressing on toasted rye bread.
12.95 $
Hot Pastrami Sandwich
Pastrami with Swiss cheese and sauerkraut on toasted rye bread.
12.95 $
Ham & Swiss Sandwich
Boar's head tavern ham, swiss cheese, and spicy mustard served on a flaky buttery croissant.
10.95 $
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Made fresh daily from boar's head ever roast all white meat chicken and served on your choice of pepperidge farm's white, multi-grain or rye or a flaky buttery croissant.
10.95 $
Egg Salad Sandwich
Made fresh daily and served on your choice of pepperidge farm breads, baguettes or Cuban bread from croissants de France or bagels from Goldman's Deli.
9.95 $
Tuna Salad Sandwich
Made fresh daily and served on your choice of pepperidge farm breads, baguettes or Cuban bread from croissants de France or bagels from Goldman's Deli.
9.95 $
Coffee
Latte
Cafe con leche. Cuban coffee with steamed milk.
3.45 $
Cortadito
A strong con leche. Double Cuban espresso with cane sugar, topped with steamed milk.