The best New York Style Pizza in Kansas City

"A lot of the negative reviews seem oddly critical to me. This place doesn't have an ounce of pretense. It's so obviously not promising you..."

Kim Chihuahua

"I normally get a slice(huge) of pizza and a romaine salad, both items are fantastico! But today I had an Gyro and it was..."

Larry Thoele

"One fine stromboli!. First time here, tried the stromboli and it was very good. Crust was chewy but light, sausage, cheese, and mushroom were fresh..."

SBela

"Delicious!!. We had slices of the combo and cheese. They were both delicious!! The staff was very pleasant and helpful ( brought food to our table)...."

Genners02

"The pizza was ok. It wasn't great to see pizza out on the counter to choose from and then watch your slice head to the pizza oven to reheat. The menu..."

Kaitlyn Blosser

"Enjoyed my pizza, but not my meatball..."

John Bouroughs

"A New Favorite!. If you are looking for pretentious, organic, "foo-foo" pizza, this is not the place for you. This is delicious, stick-to-your-ribs..."

The Food Dude

"Best New York Style Pizza I have ever had!. Incredible pizza!!!! I have yet to find another pizza like it in New York!!!!! The owner Frank was so..."

Izzy

"I ordered the Baked Ziti and my husband ordered the Lasagne. Both portions were ample. I brought half of mine home for a second meal. I was a little..."

Debbie Atwood

"Yum!. My husband is from New York and I am from Connecticut so we know good pizza and I have to say this is pretty darn good pizza. It is definitely..."

Blythemcd

"Great Dinners!!!. Just tried the Fettucini Alfreddo.. Amazing. Had the Italian Steak Sandwich last week, ooh was it good.. I recommend the italian..."

Roberto Baggio

"Great Pizza. I took my boys to the mamma leone's up at Red Bridge. We had a great lunch for not a lot of money and really had great service. We will..."

Jan

"UHMAZING!. Wow, who would have thought that amazing pizza would be found right here in South Kansas City! The pizza is delicious. Definitely New York..."

Gedy Rivera

"Huge Pasta Dinners!!!. I loved the Chicken Parmigiana dinner! It was soooo big that I had to take the rest for lunch the next day, and everybody at..."

Megan

"Yum!!! Great Pizza. I called in a 18" pepp & cheese pizza tonight. Quick and picked it up at the drive thru window. Great taste and stringy cheese. I..."

MONICA

"Pizza By The Slice. This ain't no burned out Wendy's no more folks!! We stopped in last night and ordered the special for takeout. It consisted of 2..."

Cheezrobsta

"Like the pizza and salad-SEE UPDATE. Locally owned, friendly atmosphere across from Red Bridge shopping center. So far husband and self have only..."

Foodsnob

"We had great dinner here. Had spaghetti and meatballs, spaghetti and Chicken Parmesan, and roasted Ravioli. Wifey had a Stromboli which she liked a..."

jim stephens

"Amazing pizza with great prices! I really love how reasonably priced they were and how efficient the customer service was. I definitely plan to..."

Michael Jenkins

"Had a few great slices here! I need to try a fresh whole pizza from them, I'm certain that would bump it to a solid..."

Jon Schwartz

"We wanted GOOD pizza tonight and we got it. First time here. What a great find. Pizza was piping hot. I ordered 2 slices of cheese and had more..."

Kelli Wheeles

"Great New York Pizza! Pasta, meatballs, calzones, delicious! Lunch specials are great!Dine in, Carryout or..."

Ray R.

"Love this place. The pizza is outstanding. So is the Stromboli, lasagna, wings, gyros and desserts. The prices are affordable. Nice place to spend..."

Grannie ToTwelve

"Okay, so I discovered this wonderful place about a week and a half ago, and have now ordered 3 times 😁. Their pizzas are FANTASTIC! In my opinion,..."

Schwimby

"I am an NJ/NY transplant to KC and I’ve been complaining for over 8 years about KC pizza. Yes I’ve tried all the ones that people say are..."

Peter Mishler

"Literally the best New York style pizza in the city. Frank is a great owner and has been above and beyond with service since day..."

Erin McKinley

"That was my second time eating there. The first time I went there their pizza was amazing and it's so Bixby the slice. I absolutely loved it and then..."

Taylor Mcmahan

"I love this place. Even though my sandwich had very little love put into it this time it was still..."

Raea Guyton-Gamble-Simmons-Long

"The sit-down area is open again. The homemade tiramisu is both priced great and tastes wonderful! When we aren't hungry enough to get a full pizza,..."

Shelly Fisher

"Service is fantastic. Pizza is hot and..."

John S

"Really great guys who make very tasty pizza, my bf and I LOVE this..."

Megan Hogue

"So after looking for real New York style pizza in Missouri, I have found what is the closest to perfect as I'm going to get. Crust is what pizza is..."

Diana Williamson

"First time trying them and the pizza is fire. I will be coming back for..."

nayomi large

"Best pizza! I felt like I was eating a New York slice ova here!..."

KCNinjette

"All this time, it was waiting to be tried...finally did and I'll definitely be back! Good solid pie and really nice people! The only reason I didn't..."

Reset

There is only one restaurant

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best New York Style Pizza in Kansas City

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters