We have been talking about trying this restaurant for quite a while... now I wish we had tried it much sooner! We caught the last day of the April special when 16" specialty pizzas were just $11. We ordered two specialty pizzas (a meat lovers and a Sis) and three "drums".
The crust of the pizza is a thin crust, which I don't usually like, but this one was wonderful. It has good flavor. texture, and held up well to folding in true New York style. The toppings were plentiful on both pizzas and the flavors mixed well.
The "drums" were equally delicious, and cooked to perfection. The skin had just a hint of crispiness and the meat was juicy and tender. The best part however was the sauce. We tried the Mango-Habenero which was an amazing blend of the two flavors that created a hot, but sweet combination that we all agreed was fantastic.
In short, we will be returning to Elmo's a lot in the future, and with all the varieties of pizza and sandwiches available, I can't wait to try them all!
Tried there pizza for the first time tonight. It was great. Can't wait to try more of their extensive menu.
1st try tonight….we will definitely be back. Ordered straight up cheese n pepperoni with our favorite toppings … can’t wait to try specialty pizzas. Mango habanero wings were perfect.
Wings are bangin. Pizza is Jamestown style which is to say like other pizza joints, but done well. Great price.
Great food and great people! Love their veggie calzone!!! Get it every chance I have when I'm in NY
One of, if not, the best pizza in town. Great food, great prices and great service. The trifecta!
Reheats really well for multiple meals.
Don't sleep on the manicotti, really good...as is everything.
Arguably the best pizza place in town. Cannot say enough good things about this place.
Went to Elmo’s for the first time. The owner and the staff were very friendly and accommodating. Being from Jamestown, I’ve had pizza and wings from most places in town, and after that experience I have a new favorite pizza place. Can’t say enough about the crispy crust. The pizza is a perfectly cooked thin crust and comes with many varieties of toppings and styles to choose from. I had the meatlovers and also ordered the garlic parmesan wings. They were crispy, saucy and packed with flavor. Very satisfied with the food and the service. Thank you Elmo’s!!!
I have ordered from Elmo's 4 times now and have not been disappointed. This place is great. Great prices and good food.
Everything we've ordered has been delicious, but their pizza is amazing(especially the Milano)!!! My son also loves their manicotti. Really glad we found this hidden gem. Hands down, best pizza in the area.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Jamestown
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes