Always great pizza. We get the medium house special, minus pepperoni. It's always good and we love it better the next day 😊 They were busy tonight so the wait was a bit longer than norm. But still worth it!
Best pizza i had in a while. We visited this place unexpectedly.but amazed by food quality and quantity for the price.
I ordered a pizza for dinner when my son and his wife came from the UP. To visit it was one of the best pizzas we have had. We will definitely keep going and getting dinner there.
Enjoyed our pizza very much. Staff did a great job 👍
The pizza has always been awesome, but the last pizza we got was flat and didn't look very inviting. And I'm pretty disappointed about it, because in Ithaca we don't have many food choices, and don't get any deliveries here either, so make us a yum yum pizza like you usually do. God Bless
If a little cheese was put on the top to help hold toppings that would help. Pizza tasted fine, bread sticks were good, salad was delicious. Remember cash or local checks only. The actual store could use updates & repairs. I don't know if it's ever had a facelift.
Great pizza!!!! First time visiting Main Street in Ithaca. Good selection on their menu. Different choices than Carson City. Will definitely try them again. Tried calling Carson City to order and nobody would answer the phone. So it was Ithaca's lucky day. Will definitely return to this location!
The pizza here is some of the best I've ever had! The toppings are high-quality and the crust isn't something you will want to throw away. There is a small area for dining in. The dining area is relatively clean, but in serious need of maintenance or even a complete remodel.
I fully recommend trying the blt pizza!
One more great pizza from main street pizza!!😁👍
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Ithaca
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes