Papa Johns Pizza
435 Franklin Street - Ithaca
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2021
#167 of 179 restaurants in Ithaca
Updated on
€€€
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
59/100
Data Completeness
67/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
🌳
Outdoor seating
🚚
Delivery
🥡
Takeout
🍽️
Dine-in
📅
Reservations
♿
Wheelchair accessible
♿
Accessible restroom
😊
Casual
📊 Popular Times
Not busy
Moderate
Very busy
📷 Photos (7)
Photo 1 / 7
100%
Google Reviews
373
Google reviews
Quick Work Lunch 8" pizza takeout review! Thank you Papa John's Pizza Family Run owners! You made my day by reassuring me that I can order a mini pizza with no cheese and tons of tasty veggies without being overcharged or being given a hard time. It is also very appreciate that our family members with gluten free allergies can eat at your place because you make your own pizzas and do not cross contaminate. This is great customer service! And I was greeted the moment I walked in the door. What a treat! Thank all of you.
Read more
Google
Value is my biggest reason to keep buying more pizza from here. The Shaq er oni pizza is fantastic and full of cheese and pepperoni.
Google
Great pizza. Only thing is that they run out of dollar slice pizza on tuesday earlier than posted(9pm).
Google
Lately all I've encountered here are friendly and personable workers. Foods always great.
Google
Helped us to provide good veggie pizzas and the preparation was excellent. Even the dough was eggless. Highly recommended for vegetarians...must visit place !!!!
Google
Only tried a few items but it's worth the five stars so far. The papa bites oreo bites are to get! Or get two, they're worth it. The papa bites chicken parm bites are also great, almost like eating a cut up calzone but I think two marinara sauces will be better than one. And the pizza is also good here, same for the new papadias which I'd prefer to get over the pizza. Not a big fan of wings but I decided try theirs, garlic parm well done, and it's the best I've tasted. Better than any other place, will defiantly order more of those. Delivery workers are kind and great, other workers in the store were kind and helpful as well. Delivery time is accurate, second delivery was 5 minutes early. It's easy to place an order and save up to $15 in discounts, and daily deals.
Read more
Google
Papa John's is my favorite pizza! I love how nice the Staff was, and how they helped me bring My pizza to my car even though they were smashed with customers. They are the only pizza place I will go to in the Ithaca area!
Google
I've never gotten someone else's order or an uncut pie here. Can't say that about 75% of other pizza shops. Staff are always nice. Greeted upon entering every time.
Google
This is a pretty good location. It’s your typical Papa John’s, so nothing terribly different here.
Food usually comes out on time and correct. A little on the expensive side (especially drinks—$4 for a 2 liter soda?) but otherwise OK.
Tuesdays are incredibly busy because of their special ($1 slices I think?). Did you know there’s a dining room? Off to the right when you walk in. Blink and you’ll miss it.
Read more
Google
Cheap pizza but depending who makes it they always have different cheese consistency. Too much and it make it so greasy there is a shiny circle where the pizza laid in the box. Usually ready pretty quick and one of the only places that delivers to my road.
Google
Explore more in Ithaca
Help improve this page: