The best Crab Soup in Islamorada | Sluurpy updated in May

Islamorada Shrimp Shack

83/100 (3288 ratings)

Restaurants

Seafood

American

Gluten Free Options

Vegetarian Friendly

Gluten Free Options

Vegetarian Friendly

Dinner

Lunch

Brunch

Salad

Fried shrimp

Mac and cheese

Jambalaya

Key lime pie

Crab

Shrimp and Grits

Oyster

Po' Boys

Crab Soup

Calamari

Pesto

Tuna

Fish

Calamares

Sandwiches

Burger

Chowder

Tapas

Shrimp

Fish Taco

Tacos

Ribs

Fish Sandwich

Pasta

Sit down

American

Seafood

Accepts Discover

Serves Alcohol

Wine and Beer

Parking Available

Free off-street parking

Highchairs Available

Full Bar

Accepts Credit Cards

Takeout

Television

Seating

Accepts Mastercard

Table Service

Accepts Visa

Accepts American Express

Wheelchair Accessible

Lunch

Brunch

Dinner

Mid-range

"Service was outstanding and the food was even better. Conch po’ boy was tender and well-portioned. My wife had the soft-shell crab and it was in..."

Ben Nesler

"The food is awesome. Hogfish senator or continental style, she crab bisque and the shrimp fritters are the best you can get anywhere. We drive down..."

John Yanik

"The shrimp fritters and bacon wrapped shrimp are a must! The key line pie martini is also a winner. If you're in Islamorada you HAVE to stop in for..."

Courtney Walker

"We spend quite a bit of time each year in Islamorada. I can honestly say, we eat at Shrimp Shack again and again and again because simply no other..."

Wendy Goelz Kopasz

"Islamorada Shrimp Shack...our second time here...last year we swung by for appetizers. This year we stopped in for an actual dinner and the snapper..."

Gene Hinders

"A must stop in the Florida Keys. I'd split a meal with your significant other. So much food and then there would be room for..."

Greg McCloud

"Great place food is good ,and at a great price . One of the Keys hidden..."

Debbie Ann Levins

"Amazing food and amazing service! Very impressed! Definitely..."

Carly Seyfried

"Delightful meal, loved it! Wonderful server Angela, made our dinner..."

Justine Fine

"Omg so good!! Our friend recommended this place on our visit and boy was he right! This place is a hidden..."

Jenn Dery

"The shack is all new go check it out!! Awesome staff and even better kitchen!! Try the senator style fish! So yummy or the shrimp n grits which are..."

Jackie Alpers

"Service was beyond fabulous. Food was excellent and reasonably priced. Portion size was great. Can't wait to go back.Highly recommend shrimp..."

Sally Johnson

"We stayed in Islamorada for 2 nights. And in one day we ate at The Shrimp Shack twice. It's delicious!!! We ate some shrimp wrapped in bacon and..."

Christy Hayes

"Service was great and served up generously with great big smiles. My boyfriend had the alligator and it was fantastic, I had the Shrimp basket done..."

Val Gabert

"We were seated immediately without a reservation. We had appetizers and entrees. The calamari was very good and ckams were also good (we knew they..."

Traveling Gopher

"I came here for a early supper with my parents I got a couple apps and the shrimp and grits. One app I got was the Gator bites and they were awesome..."

Michael Buchanan

"We ordered Sweet Teas, Calimari, Big Shrimper, and the Hog Fish Special. Enjoyed it all. I couldn't finish the BIG shrimper. Looking forward to..."

Manuel Ferro Jr

"Great Food, Good Service. This is a great place to eat, the food is delicious, service is always prompt and friendly and best of all, it's very..."

Hillaryh24

"Improving. The first time I went to the Shrimp Shack we said never again... Well, I went there again for happy hour and ended up getting food; it was..."

CS

"Shrimp Shack Yum. I was almost dissuaded from even going here after reading all the reviews, but decided to give ita try to see for myself. I am..."

Pie_in_the_sky

"Plan, Stop, or Turn Around and Go Back - Just Get There!. We had people literally flying in from all over the world for a wedding, and we were lucky..."

Doug

"Wonderful Place!. My wife and I were in the area for a week celebrating our 23rd anniversary, we discovered the Islamorada Shrimp Shack on our second..."

Mike

"Friendly & funny staff. Food was fast, fresh and delicious. Got the cajun rock shrimp basket. Very good! Even liked the sides - hushpuppies, fries..."

Kattle32

"Great Food. Welcome back to the neighborhood, my fish sandwich was tasty and the shrimp was perfect! Heading back tonight for the chicken wings..."

RL

"Went there last night for dinner, the food was great. The only issue that we encountered was the extended wait for the server to greet us and take..."

Valerie Fairnington

""fantastico". Stopped in hungry, thirsty, and tired for lunch. by the time Jill and Trinity got done with us we were full, quenched, and ready to..."

Mark

"Outstanding food..everything was great! Shrimp and grits were a favorite at our table! Service was a little slow..but they're new. We will be..."

Steph F

"Shrimp Shacks in Islamorada, FL. Shrimp Shack has excellent food! Had shrimp basket and also fish basket, was fresh and crispy and food was hot when..."

Chickadd52

"Great food great prices. We saw a couple of negative reviews and almost did't try this place but WOW we are glad we did. I don't know where the..."

Bunnyhoney1943

"Fresh Shrimp & Fish. We had a great dinner at the shrimp shack, the staff was very friendly. We just had a shrimp basket and a fish basket, but both..."

Bob R.

"Wow! Tried this restaurant out a month ago and have been back over a dozen times! My husband and I are always greeted by name and with a smile when..."

Morgan

"Great all around!!!. Not only great shrimp, but best ribs in town and no one, I mean no one tops the key lime cake!! Rolls are homemade for dinner..."

Alsgirl88

"This place is so good! The shrimp and grits are the best thing i have ever eaten. I come here a lot and have always had excellent meals. Great prices..."

Wes

"Awesome Shrimp awesome mac and cheese and great people. Have a good time everytime I..."

Ambaa

"Parking is easy. Once you enter, the server will seat you in the bar or the restaurant. My friend ordered a margarita, the shrimp platter with 4..."

Beverly Varshovi

"The freshest fish fare! So clean and tasty! Very impressed. Featured on Diners, Drive ins, and Dives. Try the captain's platter!..."

Joules

"Large selection of entrees for takeout. No outdoor seating and decor lives up to its name. Both shrimp dishes were mighty tasty, and the Morgan Salad..."

Joy May

"This is a must place to stop in the keys! It was a delicious hole in the wall stop. I had the continental shrimp served over rice and it was the most..."

Jessica Thompson

"This was a cool spot. I got the captain’s combo platter. Everything was good! I would go back to try a different..."

Martin V.

"We had a fried shrimp and a fried mahi basket at lunch (until 4 pm. Dinner, more expensive ) It was delicious! Huge helpings. You have a choice of..."

Chris Yust LaClaire

"I can’t believe I haven’t eaten here sooner. Absolutely incredible food and fantastic staff. Highly recommend!! Footnote: The road construction..."

Joe St

"Great little place for good food and great people!! Sam was amazing and took very good care of me for dinner!! Highly recommend trying this place...."

Barry Pierce

"First time ever being here and we loved it. The staff was amazing. Everyone was friendly, and welcoming, our waitress was knowledgeable of the menu..."

AfterLyfe_Streamz

"Well, we were taking about purchasing a home in the keys but this place made me re think that! Primarily because this restaurant is family owned and..."