Review Bayside Gourmet - Islamorada

Okay... This might take a second.. from all the places we've visited in the upper keys and lower to be honest, this one had the audacity to feed us super delicious food with great service and reasonable prices. The amount of food you get is out of this world, the owner came up to our table, and we shared our unhappiness about having to now always come back for the next key lime pie ever.. I know a lot of people say that they've had the best everywhere... But hear me out.. I don't like key lime pie, had it in every must have place down here... And I tried one last time. This place was it. Oh and I almost forgot.. the lobster bisque is absolutely fabulous 🤩 Kids: they have arcades all over and most are free to play. This is a true "where the locals eat" as everyone around us what just that. Great place, we will return, and can't wait tbh. It's a little hard to see from the road, but if you pay attention, it will definitely be a great time for you and whomever you bring.

Stopped at this gem on our way to our vacation site after traveling all day. Little bit of a wait if we wanted to dine in or immediate seating if we wanted to dine outside. Food was absolutely delicious. Chicken parm was definitely enough for two people. This is a must stop place!

This is a very cool place. Walk in and you see a bunch of retro arcade games and a very warm atmosphere. I was by myself and ordered the bruschetta appetizer and it was a huge portion size and very good. I usually expect cold bruschetta and this was warm and more tomato sauce than chopped tomatoes. Regardless it was good. The appetizer was so big I didn’t have room for a sandwich. I’ll try that next time as I will return

Visiting in town and went and had beers and cocktails at a local place and decided to stop here for some food. Everything in these places here are all fried this fried that so we were looking for something not fried. What a excellent choice it was. Sat down right when we arrived and had Eddie as our waiter. Best service we have had since visiting the key's. He was so kind, and checked in when needed and so stinking cute. In fact I went to the owner and let her know as well. We saw on the table next to us they had a meat lover's pizza. We ordered this and it was amazing. The crust is so yummy that you don't need any ranch or dipping sauce for it. Cooked to perfection and pretty generous on the toppings too. Highly recommend this place as others were complimenting as well.

We got a large size works pizza, and it's enough for at least three probably four adults. Very homemade ingredients, unique homemade tasting sausage, and just loaded. The brownie also is the best we've ever had. And they have some amazing looking pies that we will try next time. We are going back there because it's a great value and truly gourmet food. It does taste like a chef put the flavors together. A breath of fresh air to feel like you received more and higher quality than what you expected or paid for.

Always love coming here. I've tried tons of their dishes and I have yet to find soenthing that I didn't like. Their pasta dish portions are absolutely huge and are so flavorful. Always worth it. Their pizza is crisp, thin crusted. Service is always fabulous. Inside and outside dinning avaliable. Inside is always nice and cold. Great way to cool off.

This place was the best place we have eaten while on vacation. The food is amazing!! The fun little outside courtyard is a great place to share a meal and enjoy the outdoors. Our waitress was very sweet. We really enjoyed her. My husband loved the lobster bisque soup. We also shared the Shrimp Francese. We have never had anything as good as this dish. We found out the owners are generations of Italians. We have traveled all over Italy and this dish, hands down incredible!! We also had a cannoli, which is spot on!! And we also shared Chocolate Mousse Pie. This pie melted in our mouth. Fabulous Mousse Pie. If you are traveling through the Keys, do not pass through Islamorada without stopping at Bayside Gourmet. I promise you’ll absolutely love it. The only down side for us is we are leaving and can’t come back again. But, this will be a stop we make anytime we come to Southern Florida. Thank you for your amazing service and food!! If you want to open a store in the middle of Nebraska…… 😉

We were tired of cooking so we read the reviews and decided to place a take out order for pizza and the key lime pie. The pizza was very good. We ordered the margherita, saltimbocca and 4 formaggio and added meatballs. The key lime pie was good but I personally like it a little more tart.

Came in from out of town and went here because of the great reviews, it did not disappoint. Loved the atmosphere, really great vibe, very kind welcoming management and delicious food. We had salads, sandwiches and pizza and great beer. Very satisfied!

Listen, i have travelled around the world with my family and I can tell you that this place does it right for a family pizza night. The pizza is excellent as advertised, good sauce, good crust, the whole deal. We were greeted so warmly and the minute we sat down the 2 young bus boys had menus in our hand and coloring materials in front of my daughter. There is a really fun games room for while you wait for your food, but in our case, we were in the restaurant and completely fed and full within 40 mins. Nice ambiance, hard working team, great establishment. Good job