Great place. Great staff. Great food. We had a wonderful experience. And the cannolis were great. I have been looking for some place that has a cannoli and I found it.
Thank you Maggie's for the wonderful experience my family had. We will be back!
It was seriously such delicious pizza. I got the special which had sweet corn and bacon as the toppings! Our server was amazing and we wanted for nothing. I will definitely frequent this place! Great food!
I'm rating Maggie's five stars for a number of reasons. Food, drinks, atmosphere; all five stars without a doubt. However, the majority of my five stars comes from the experience and hospitality of the staff. Apparently because of some confusing shuffling, our table was ignored for a decent length of time when we first sat down. This was a little frustrating, but throughout our meal the staff more than made up for their mistake, which makes any good restaurant, a great one. Five stars all the way around.
Kathy Kramer Villhauer
+5
Upon entrance we were greeted by everyone that was employed there as we were shown to our table. Our waitress was very kind and helpful when we asked questions. Our pizza was very, very good...loved the taste of the pizza sauce on the pizza!!!! Great food....fantastic employees!!!
Went there for dinner last night for the first time. Suffice it to say, we will be repeat customers! The burrata was the best I've had anywhere in a long time. The staff was gracious and friendly and the atmosphere was perfect. I was able to have a conversation with my wife without feeling like I was yelling at her. And then, the pizza. Wow! The sauce on the pizza we had was absolutely outstanding. Everything from start to finish was wonderful! We had been putting off going there because it is so close to where we live and figured we could just go anytime. Well, that was my mistake. I wish we had been there sooner, but we will return much sooner rather than later! Thanks for being in the neighborhood!!
My husband said the gluten free pizza at Maggie's is the best he's ever tasted (and he's been gluten free since 1977)! I don't know for sure, but it didn't look or taste anything like the pull-out-of-the-freezer gluten free crusts that you get at most pizza places (and which we are often grateful for).
We both loved the Melrose salad - the combination of tastes and textures plus the lemony dressing was outstanding.
I already knew the gluten pizza was delicious. I couldn't believe that I ate the entire thing, but it was so tasty I couldn't stop myself.
Super charming, classy, yet "hole-in-the-wall" vibe with fabulous food and chill service. I tried the Fungi and loved the spring flavors. My friend was able to do a custom order and wasn't charged an arm and a leg like other establishments. Pizza crust was spot-on as was our server. We were able to sneak in early, but definitely call ahead for reservations. We're looking forward to returning soon!
Best pizza in Iowa City! Has quality ingredients and perfect consistency. Also great wine and gelato! Highly recommend.
I've been a customer and fan of Maggie's pizza for a while now. I stopped by the new Iowa City location today and was not disappointed. The restaurant is beautiful, pizza amazing, the chocolate gelato delicious, and the staff and owners super people. I look forward to trying some of their other new menu items on subsequent visits.
Best wood-fired pizza I've had! (And I've tried a lot of pizza)!!
The new space in Iowa City is beautiful!
Shout out to Maggie's for being such a hospitable restaurant! I did not actually eat here... but I got stuck in the rain during a run and they let me sit inside to wait it out. The gentlemen who invited me inside even gave me a water while I waited. None of the wait staff seemed to mind that I was soaking wet and looked out of place, just went on with their business. Unfortunately I did not have any money on me to leave a tip, but this just means I need to go back again in the future for pizza! If this was not a true example of "Iowa nice," I don't know what is.
Dinner on Thursday night with a friend, amazing from the word "go", Sara S wined and dined us, all while showing the ropes to a coworker. Food, staff and atmosphere all over the top. I'll be back with friends.
This place is a must try if you haven't already! We absolutely enjoyed our first experience! We got a plate of Chicken Wings to start, a Maggie's Margherita Pizza, a Funghi Pizza, a Pesto Pasta, and an Italian Choc Mousse. Everything tasted authentic and perfect! Love the fact that everything was made fresh with their own unique ingredients, even the pasta is handmade! We will definitely come back again!
It was moderately busy even on a Tuesday! The restaurant also has a cozy atmosphere to compliment the food! Great place for celebratory occasions or social gatherings!
The food is just too good. Highly recommend their chicken wings! The best wings I have eaten in town.. I also tried their funghi pizza, shrimp scampi and iced tea. Everything was made to perfection.. service was quick and people were warm.. we sat outside and We loved it!!!
Our most favorite pizza and chicken wings in Iowa. There are so many options to choose from and each options is the right one. There pasta is great as well. We always hear about cooking pasta 'al dente', in cooking shows but we actually experienced what that means at Maggie's.
Briana Fortenbach Titus
+5
The food here is fresh and delicious. The salads are large and well-proportioned. The pizza crust is deliciously simple with a great wood-fired flavor and texture. The toppings and cheese were balanced just right. The burrata was a highlight--so fresh and with just the right delicate seasoning! The service was excellent. Everyone was kind, helpful, and outgoing. I have food allergies, and they bent over backward to help me find something and to make sure it all came out correctly. I'd eat here on a daily basis if I could!
Great experience. Very unique offering of neapolitan style pizzas in the Iowa City area.
Delicious pizza - and this is coming from someone (me) who has worked in a certified Neapolitan pizzeria for 9 months in the past.
Would like to see them have a happy hour with better drink specials - would create a more relaxed atmosphere. Without any specials, the prices are a bit high ($$) - giving it a sense of a special occasion before I would make it here.
Also would like to see better arrangement of server stations - we had one next to our table (near the street) which was a little distracting and weird.
Maria Houser Conzemius
+5
I ordered the spaghetti con broccoli, which was very good. Our friends ordered a "small" salad for the four of us to share. It's the best salad I've ever eaten. My husband and our friends ordered pizza and we were all thoroughly satisfied. I ordered a gin-and-tonic and they made one, even though it wasn't on the menu. Our waitress was superb and I tipped her over 20%.
Had an amazing dining experience after a very long day! My sister, niece, and I enjoyed the atmosphere and food immensely. My sister said this is the closest she’s come to authentic Italian pizza since she was in Italy. It was honestly the best pizza I’ve ever had.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes