Where to begin? You already know,the pizza is awesome. We are lucky enough to have Tony and his crew in Broadripple. We had a pizza that we were not happy with and Tony went out of his way to make things right. He personally greeted us and even made our pizza. It was perfect. Great pizza,great service, great experience. If you're not eating Goodfellas,there is a void in your life.
Did exactly what I wanted for a NY style of pizza. We went in and out quickly with a slice made for us. The bread stick wad big enough for us to share. And the pizza tasted great.
This place has great pizza. The service is great the only problem is it's hard to find the place because they don't have a sign. It took me 10-20 minutes just to find the place.
Aviva Carla Mintz Tavel
+5
Best pizza ever! Wish they were in a different spot in Broad Ripple with tables, a bathroom and beer. I'd be there every day!!!
The pizza tour of Indianapolis continues and did not disappoint with Goodfella's in BroadRipple. We ordered the 16" size with half of it topped with The Don and the other half was topped with tomatoes, black olives and extra cheese. The Don had green peppers, red onions, sliced Italian sausage and pepperoni . The crust was perfectly cooked. As a NY style pizza sometimes the crust cannot support many toppings without drooping and requiring the NY fold over. In this case the crust was able to support the weight of a lot of toppings. Compared to other pizzas claiming NY style, this one was extraordinary. The crust had the requisite air pockets in the rim and a perfect chew throughout. We ordered carry out . Pulled right up , a perky wait staff rang me up and was delightfully cheerful. Highly recommend Goodfella's!
amazing pizza my favorite. great people work there.
Enjoyed my first time here. There are single slices available for a great price. You can also order pizzas and other food. I tried the calzone. Topping choices were excellent. Time I waited was definitely decent. Not too short and not too long. Calzone was completely cooked through which is difficult to find sometimes. I gave them 4 stars on food because thus wasn't my favorite tasting pizza. I definitely enjoyed the ease and quickness.
Goodfellas offers a delightful New York-style pizza experience with its delectable pies and exceptional service. Their pizza boasts a perfect crust, well-balanced sauce, and generous toppings that truly hit the mark. The attentive and friendly staff further enhance the dining experience.
The only minor drawback is the limited seating during peak hours. However, this inconvenience is easily outweighed by the delicious pizza and superb customer service. So, if you're craving an authentic New York-style pizza and warm hospitality, Goodfellas is the place to be.
The best wood fired pizza! Was in town for a track meet over the 4th of July weekend. Needed a quick bite to eat found this place and oh my god definitely worth the 10 min drive from our hotel. SOOOO GOOOD!
Great place to stop in for a quick NY style slice. Bread sticks are as big as your arm.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Indianapolis
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes