I've eaten here for as long as I have had teeth! Not only is the food the same as I remember as a child.. but also the awesome owners Dave & Angie are still running the place! Big thank you for never changing over the years and keeping the same great tastes! And ..... Still very affordable <3
If you even live close to Indy you must go to Aunt Pollys Pizza !!! 🍕 Absolutely amazing!!! Highly highly highly recommend! I Have been traveling here even from Martinsville, since i no longer live in Indy, defiantly a must have.
I've always loved Aunt Polly's Pizza the freshness the way they make their food the time they take to actually make it good. Amazing!!! The other day I got to have an awesome conversation with Mr. Dave the owner of Aunt Polly's Pizza, he was super pleasant and super nice and seems very customer-oriented he's such an amazing guy and he definitely wants the best for not only his company but the community surrounding. Thanks for being such an outstanding citizen of our community and thanks for making awesome � by the way your breadsticks rock!!! #auntpollyspizza #lifelongcustomer #communitymatters #mrDaverocks
I LOVE Aunt Polly's. The only complaint I have is they never have any cola except RC. I hate RC but I tolerate it because I love the food and staff is the best!
We go there a lot. Outside of the wonderful food and best pizza sub in town, they are all very personable and super friendly. Making this local shop a complete and fulFILLING experience! �
Update, 5/25/2023
I spoke with the owner David and he genuinely wanting to make things right with my last order. So I gave Aunt Polly's Pizza another chance.
David did not fail to impress me. He replaced my order and sent a half rack of ribs, baked beans and cookies. All of which were excellent, love the ribs!! I have attacked tonight's photos to this as well.
5/20/2023
Ordered a medium pizza with beef, pepperoni, onions with extra beef and extra cheese and an order of bread sticks. What I got was was a regular pizza with nothing extra. I called and the fellow that answered just wanted to call me a liar. And hung up. Order with caution this cost me $36
I randomly stopped in one night after midnight. The people were friendly and super nice to me. They made me the best Parmesan Garlic Wings I've ever eaten! I'll go out of my way to stop in at Aunt Pollys...
We love aunt Polly’s pizza and it’s a hit every time for every occasion! Along with great food they have amazing people there that are always there for everyone! They provided pizza for my Uncle Gary Cockrill’s Celebration of life we had for everyone and it was amazing! We appreciate it so much! My uncle worked for Aunt Polly’s for so long and they showed their love and support to us!
The food was great took me 40 plus min. On a 16in pizza an bread sticks however I've been eating this pizza since I was a kid so I'm kind of buyist.
This place is great the food is amazing and what makes it even more amazing is that they went out of there way to deliver to me even though i was a lil bit out of there delivery area my pizza was cooked to perfection and so dam good i like my pizza square cut but it was the bomb either way this is my go to for great pizza if you dont like them then your taste buds are fried
This was my first time here and I was NOT disappointed. We got a large 2 topping pizza, order of breadsticks and 2L for a VERY affordable price. I had heard many good things about Aunt Polly's but for whatever reason had not tried it yet. I'm kicking myself for not going here sooner. The staff was also extremely nice and friendly. I felt right at home as soon as I arrived. I can't say enough good things about this place. I can't wait to go back and try their other items!
Best people and food in Indy!!! God bless everyone here!!!! Thank u all sooo much for being u!!! Merry Christmas and a very Happy new Year!!! And when I hit this powerball I promise none of u will be forgotten!!!! 🤞😍😀🤩🥳
They delivered to us at midnight and the wings are hands down the best I’ve had!!! Better than Hooters and BW3!!! Breadsticks and cheese are also fire!!!
We loved your food service and everything else. Your prices are reasonable for the quality of items you have. We loved it all. We are short in money at the time but we will be back as soon as we catch up. Thanks for yummy food and sweet staff. 😊👍❤️
Me and my friend ordered pizza and Kev (Kevin) was such a great help and good person. His customer service was amazing and the communication was excellent! The food was just as amazing!! Thank you Aunt Polly's Pizza!!!
I just moved my sister and her family to the east side, I drove by this place late at night. She was blown away. They deserve a 10 for being so friendly, being open so late. Another 10 across the board for the best rak of ribs in the city. Nothing like a good late night snack from a perfect little hole in the wall.
The Bar B Cue Chicken wings are tender, juicy, sauce just right, meat came right off the Bone. It was hot, delicious and savory for a late night meal. I have no complaints!
We are originally from the Chicago area so are kinda pizza snobs and perhaps a lil judgy concerning what is considered a "good" one...but we got into town late, we were hungry and wanted pizza. We found Aunt Polly's online and ordered since they deliver past 10pm.
We definitely were NOT disappointed that we did!! Service was great, food was awesome (LOVED the sweetness of the sauce) and prices seemed reasonable.
If we were local would order again!!!!
I’ve been getting Aunt Polly for over 5-6 month’s , the food has seriously been awesome.. I’ve had sandwiches, pizza, and now I get the half rack of ribs.. they are so delish.. I call in to order and I’ve had the man and woman answer, they have both been patient and respectful, and the man was even cutting up and joking.. I’m getting ready to order again as soon as they answer.. seriously try the ribs, pizza and sandwiches. I am in a pickle trying to decide which one I want this month lol probably the tenderloin yummm or maybe ham and cheese ughhhhh hard to decide
Just tried some calzones from Aunt Polly’s for the first time. They were great! I wold definitely recommend them.
Love their food. My daughter hates ham,but will eat their ham sub. . Thanks for having great food.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes