I think they offer the best bagels in the city. A nice exterior with just the right amount of crunch and a beautiful chew inside. The whole package is outstanding. And the aroma while they toast is magnificent. I went there Saturday to buy a dozen,of various varieties. I must say 10 bucks is a great price. The young man packaged the onion and garlic separately from the others,which I thought was very considerate. I have nothing to add but this. If you like bagels this is the place.
The best bagels in town. Bring cash, no credit.
Best bagels in Indy.. Simply put, the best bagels in the Indianapolis area. Sundays they have bialys- highly recommended. They don't take credit cards, so make sure you have some cash handy.
I have had bagels in Chicago, New York, and in Italy. The only bagels I'd ever eat is bagel fair. Bagel fair is fresh and made in front of you. There not made in a factory, there made with love, by wonderful people. I Love Them!
YUM!!!. The only bagels i will eat are from bagel fair!! They are so so so so so good!
Reasonable prices, quick courteous service. Had variety of bagels, consistent soft yet chewy texture. Flavor mild, not excessive. Bagel size medium. Also had bagel egg and cheese tasty and filling. Coffee under $2! Place is busy. Would buy again.
Can't wait for the new store just 3 doors down. Love how they are so friendly and remember my favorite bagel order. Mike is always makes me feel like a VIP and starts my day with with pleasant smile and chat! He even remembers things about my family which makes the connection even better! It's the best place for bagels in Indpls.
RealtorClaireAnne Aikman
+5
It is a bagel shop, plain and unassuming on the outside, that delivers the perfect bagels on the inside (nice color, great exterior tap, not a fluffy interior but perfectly dense without feeling heavy). They've got all the savory (plain, onion, everything) the sweet (cinnamon, seasonal flavors, etc) and then you can get schmears too. Always a fast stop. usually a small line. always friendly service. If you're an East Coast transplant you will appreciate this place!
The freshest bagels, made ready to enjoy every morning. The simplistic style of this quick in and out bagel shop has a wonderful vibe and friendly energy about it.
The Everything style bagel is my go to, and I genuinely enjoy the flavors of their fresh ingredients, either toasted or room temperature.
Susan and the staff are a wonderful bunch, who take the time to ensure your food is prepared with care, tastes great, and that your experience is seamless and enjoyable.
Thank you so much for your kindness, great food, and awesome vibes.
See you next time ✌️
I had egg and cheese on a bagel with jalapeño spread, and it was pretty good!
STU da Peppahead (Stoic)
+5
Best in town! Get there early as those of us who know know that the small, super fresh batches dont last. Sooooo glad I discovered this tiny place. $14 for a bakers dozen!!!
These gents are top notch. Toasted or untoasted, these are the best bagels in central Indiana. Authentic NY style bagel shop. Make a pilgrimage when you’re in town, from Chicago or anywhere else! Love that Jalapeño Cayenne.
The best bagels and cream cheese! Been craving them since coming back from New York and this is as close as it gets. Jalepeno cayenne with jalepeno cheddar cream cheese is so good. Classic everything with scallion is also delicious!
Genuine people -the best bagels in Indy hands down! Nothing compares always that New York style Icompromised every time…”Drop the Mic” Bagel Steve Weinberg, Carmel, IN
I get the same thing every single time and it’s my favorite bagel and cream cheese ever! Everything bagel with jalapeno cheddar cream cheese. I’m also pregnant so this is starting to become a daily thing. Sooo worth it!!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Indianapolis
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes