an amazing pizza - supa dupa crisp & crunchy crust but with enough tooth that each slice is NOT a floppy sloppy triangle. perfect cheese to sauce ratio. the signature house pie is a tastebud pleaser. solid pizza by the slice & even better piping hot calzones made to order!
A Slice of New York has really good New York Pizza Pie!!! I love it.....
The pizza is consistently good. The crust is delightfully crisp. The Margherita is a winner too.
*************
House Signature was on point today; very much on par with great slices I’ve had in Manhattan. The Hawaiian as well; ample pineapple and quality Canadian bacon. My only remaining ask would be that they add a Sicilian to the menu.
Wow! The BBQ Chicken is great. Definitely upping to 4+!
*****************
They are upping their game. Pizza was perfect today. Crust was flexibly crisp. Toppings and sauces were quality. Even without a Sicilian, I am giving them 5 stars.
Fantastic gluten free pizza, probably the best I’ve ever eaten out! Had the Margherita and the pepperoni! And what a treat to have gluten free by the slice available! Run don’t walk to this place! So good!
Great pizza in a real slice of New York. Friendly owner. It's in a small mall and it's not visible from the parking lot. However, it's worth the search. BTW, I'm a NYer.
Best pizza in California by far. Highly recommend not only is it great value the customer experience is superb. Keyon did a great job at taking care of me and the food was delicious. Can’t wait for my next time in California to have another slice!
Best New York Pizza in town. Close to the Seal Beach pier. Piz za crust is crispy. Tried the pepperoni and sausage slice as well as the tomato and basil. Super delicious. Got to get yourself some to believe it.
Really yummy New York style thin crust pizza. We had regular cheese and Hawaiian pizzas along with a margherita with gluten free crust and all of them were super delicious!
Best pizza I’ve had in a while.
And what a Yankee shrine.
The pizza and the place are both works of art.
Great pizza at a decent price. I come here when I’m feeling like getting some pizza in the Huntington Beach area.
They have a good amount of outside seating, the workers are really friendly, and they have good deals if you buy a few slices with a drink.
I recommend the pizza here! It’s delicious!
Awesome pizza and awesome atmosphere. Pizza by the slice had the perfect crust.
It's a cozy little hole-in-the-wall, mom n' pop kind of place. No bar, but the do have alcoholic beverages available. The pizza is awesome! Very tasty, and of course they have many other items like wings and more, that you'd expect to find at any pizza joint. The service is great, and the staff is friendly.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Huntington Beach
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes