"This is, hands down, the best place in the Elmira-Horseheads area for ice cream and Italian ice, actually it's the best place to get ice cream,..."
Renee Petrillo
"Best customer service! It seems to me a good ice cream/ Italian ice place for the area! Highly recommend it for everyone looking for a treat!..."
Jeffrey Roblyer
"Yummy sweets and happy staff ��Very helpful at choosing new flavor combinations. Popular spot on Sunday afternoon! Would love one in our..."
Michelle Sowers Maddocks
"I’m sure we will venture many visits these couple weeks since son had tonsils removed! Rita’s makes everything better...."
Karen Osterhout
"I’m the hood. Cash only and the serving size isn’t exact to the posted size chart that they claim but... it’s worth the money and risk of being..."
Skyler Weislogel
"My buddy had the Italian Ice and I had the frozen custard - both were totally delicious!! The place was bright and clean, we even sat outside, under..."
Jennifer Sekella
"My kids love going there and ask to go for " ice cream" when we drive by!..."
Ashley Miller
"Love Rita's so much! There is always something for..."
Jennifer Materne Dacey
"Great ice..."
Rosalva Olave
"Great..."
Tanya Reeve Reudgen
"Very Good been going to Rita's since it's opening. Love the mango and..."
Jerry Larrabee
"Delicious!!
Frozen custard is an amazing treat- richer than ice cream and frozen yogurt.
Many flavors of Italian ice, which can also be combined..."
Charles Saunders
"What I love about Rita's is that its different from your original ice cream parlor. You can call them the "flavored shaved ice queen". So many great..."
Phillip Johnson
"friendly professional staff, very clean, and the custards have great flavor..."
Kam Phillips
"Came here for the first time after dinner with my boyfriend a few days ago. I got frozen custard and my boyfriend got the Swedish fish ice. I tried..."
Kayla Mae
"Fantastic service, exceptional custard and ices, I am an ice cream aficionado and Rita's is a must visit when anywhere near Elmira. We were greeted..."
m dean
"Stopped for a treat and had a small custard and a Blendini custard and Italian ice combo. Both were very good!!! A bit on the pricey side, but we..."
Richard Kopacko
"Delicious and the service is always good. I love to get the Gelati (a dish that layers creamy custard in between two layers of Italian Ice. There are..."
Benjamin Skinner
"One of my favorite places to get a treat. Staff is wonderful and it is always so..."
O G
"I love the sugar-free ice I just wish they had more choices for sugar..."
Andrew Schultz
"Stopped by this Rita's Italian Ice during a recent trip. I was looking for the local Dunkin Donuts and found Rita's! 🍦🍨🥨 I have to say this..."
Amy Alexander
"Rita's has both flavored ices and soft serve custards, some flavors change weekly. I love their gelati (gelato?) with layers of ice between custard...."
A Gevegy
"We love Rita's! The staff are always accommodating and helpful. They offer a great variety of flavors and options. The kids are always begging to..."
Holly Campbell
"I do not know how this place could be rated anything but 5 stars! Very fair prices and it’s DELICIOUS! All kinds of awesome flavors too chose from,..."
Buck Town
"Love Rita's! I stop by there after work over the summer and the girls are always so pleasant! The misto shake with coconut cream ice mixed with..."
Katelynd Rallo
"There's really no other place like Rita's! They have the best frozen treats. Try the Carmel Apple Concrete, real pieces of apple, and just the right..."
Stacy Smalt
"Great Ice and custard. I usually do a gelati and I love it. I guess their sundaes and shakes are great as well but I really like the ice so I haven't..."
Seth S
"The custard is so delicious! Smooth and creamy. We ordered a doggie sized custard and the nice young girl behind the counter oftered to put peanut..."
Adriane Daugherty
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes