Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

Not going to lie , I had posted a " karenish" review but these guys have totally redeemed themselves. Grabbed that Salvatore's supreme sheet and had em light cook that bad boy and OMG ... I don't care after tip and delivery fee and a 2.00 (2) liter it was 65 ish .... 🔥 Call the 🚒...I know pizza and they did really well .. Sunday night Jan 23rd 2023 whoever was there you did a fantastic job...keep it up...

WowWow this was our first visit to this Pizzeria. We didn't really know what to buy. The girl behind the counter Suggested to try one of their subs And let me tell you it was not a disappointment we had the Buffalo chicken sub and the blue cheese burger. Both were AWESOME. The portions were enormous, enough for 2 meals,at a fair price WELL DONE FOLKS!!! Ed & Debbie Bishop Grove City, Ohio 43123

I have been ordering from the Honeoye Falls Salvatore’s since we moved to this area last summer and have been impressed almost every time. I order food from them pretty regularly - wraps, subs, salads, sandwiches, pizza, wings, and other appetizers - and I have never been disappointed. It’s always great and is usually delivered super fast. Sometimes my lunch order is delivered within 15-20 minutes… and they are always super friendly!! Tonight’s experience was so good that I just HAD to leave a review. My husband and I, after exhausting a bunch of other dinner options, decided to give Salvatore’s Entrees a shot. We ordered the Chicken Parmesan, Stuffed Shells, a Greek Salad, and Garlic Bread….. and OH MY GOODNESS.!!! We were blown away. We were expecting the food to be decent, but what we got was high-quality Italian deliciousness!! This place is not just a pizza joint, it’s an extremely versatile restaurant that conveniently delivers great food right to your door. I highly recommend giving them your business. You won’t regret it!!!

I used to think of Salvatore’s as a simple Pizza place… I loved their pizza, wings, pizza logs, and subs. It wasn’t until ordering Chicken Parmesan and stuffed shells, that I realized Salvatore’s is a much higher quality restaurant than I gave credit. Thus, I am required to promote Salvatore’s position on my list of ‘quality eateries’! They no longer belong in the “Pizza Delivery” category… Instead, they now reside in the “Quality Dinner Served to my House” category!! A much more elegant and sophisticated, palette-pleasing experience!

Have been to Salvatore's (Hon. Fls.) for lunch several times over the last 4 years or so. We usually eat-in for lunch. Have ordered take-out for dinner a few times too. Good stuff. My daughter especially likes the boneless wings. The people there are crazy friendly. Prices are good. Dining area is cramped with only three tables crammed into space for one.

Salvatore's is a small town hole in the wall pizzeria that serves delicious, quality pizza. I popped in a couple of times while working at the PGA Championship in Rochester. I stayed locally and needed some quick food right after work and this joint was more than happy to oblige. They make all of their pizza fresh and their toppings are quality and delicious. I ordered their supreme and another (which I can't quite remember the name) that used a delicious Alfredo sauce as it's base and was topped with chicken, red peppers, and mozzarella cheese. The locale feels like the type of place where you would work if you were 15 but had a good head on your shoulders. The staff was young, but polite and professional. They took my order, cooked it, boxed it up, and I took it back to where I was staying. Overall, quite an enjoyable experience. This pizzeria is a bit more pricey than your Dominoes or Pizza Hut but you can taste the quality in the pizza. They also offer wings (which I had and were pretty decent), salads (huge and covered in some delicious toppings, the dressing was pretty good too), and sandwiches (I have nothing to say about the sandwiches, but they were on the menu). It's worth popping in and enjoying a slice.