We have tried a variety of pizza restaurants on the island and have found that New York City Pizza is the best around and the most consistent. Having been in NY and having had their pizza on multiple occasions, I can honestly say that this is as close as it gets. Every time we visit the island, we always order a pizza from NYCP.
Not sure about the recent reviews, but don’t listen to them! Dominick provided wonderful service and great conversation while we dined in. We had the deep dish and the cheese was awesome! Great stringy-ness to dough ratio. Our daughter is picky about pizza cheese and loved it. The deep dish had a great crust, crispy bottom and fluffy top so we had the best of both worlds. Would definitely come again and order take out if we were local. The prices match a local joint and not a huge chain. Don’t listen to the Karens and enjoy a great little place while you are vacationing. Bonus…right next to a Publix and ABC ☺️
Food is great. Atmosphere is okay but I ordered online 30 minutes prior to arrival and waited another 45 minutes after I arrived for two pizzas. That needs to be fixed.
Pizza was very good and actually New York style. Skip the " Smash Burger", not very good. Meatball sandwich was outstanding. Very good, friendly service
New York City Pizza never disappoints. Whether we are ordering pizza, wings, subs or one of its fabulous dinner entrees, we know we will be having a fabulous meal. When we have friends over to watch a game or movie, NY City pizza is our go to place for takeout - especially since one our friends is gluten-free. Just as important as the quality of the food, the service is just as high quality.
I had been craving Pizza for the prior 2 days, and had already purchased food when I noticed this restaurant on the way back to the truck.
Yes, I went in for a slice, and it was worth it!
Staff was friendly, helpful and efficient.
Environment was welcoming.
Kids were making their own pizza which was adorable.
Indoor and outdoor seating as well as an indoor and outdoor bar.
Definitely a relaxed spot to enjoy a bite!
This place is amazing!! The waiter was a sweetheart and chatted with us about different types of pasta and how they go with different wines! Did not expect it from a local restaurant, felt like I am back in Naples! Strongly recommend paying them a visit!
Jessica Atanasova (Hitokiri NekoHime)
+5
YO THIS PLACE WAS BOMB. We're on vacation in Hilton Head from Florida and I have to say this is the best pizza I have had in many many a year. Great place, friendly staff, delicious food! I might make it a point to come back to Hilton Head just to have dinner at this place again. ❤️
This pizza did not disappoint! It smells delicious and tastes even better! The staff here were great too. I couldn’t recommend NYCP highly enough - I’ll be back soon with some friends and family members!
My kids love going there on weekends, they have nice staff members and amazing pizza! We were able to relax, and spend some quality time enjoying pizza and salads. Definitely our newest go-to place!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes