Reviews Hightstown Hot Bagels

My only complaint is that they (like all other bagel joints) aren't open all day. These bagels are always fresh and delicious. Last time we went, the girl who took my fiance's order seemed a little confused, and even after he told her 3x she still swapped our cream cheese choices...but whatever. Fixable and still tasted good!

Hands Down the BEST Bagels in NJ!!! 30 years ago I visited this place when I lived in the area...I made a weekly stop for bagels for the week. Years passed and I left the area, not only did I leave the area but I moved 1500 miles away. Now when I am back in NJ I go out of my way (seriously I do) to stop at Hightstown for a bakers dozen of the bagels. This last trip out a couple weeks ago i picked up bagel to take to my family in Virginia! Yep its a special request. This is a family owned and operated bagel shop. There is no indoor seating to eat, its a grab your bagels and go enjoy. They make the bagels for the day...and then close once all are sold. They sell out about 10am so if you are planning on stopping...then get there early cause you will miss out for sure if your later. They make sandwiches, will toast the bagels and top with your choice. I find it wonderful to see the same staff everytime I am there and even if they don't really remember me, I remember them but they always say they recognize me and my once a year visit. Awesome place and I wish them decades more success on this business. I haven't taken any photos of the bagel but they have roughly 18 varieties of bagels and all are large fat and wonderful. Do yourself and your family a favor and discover all I say is true for yourself!

Got a classic bacon egg and cheese, on an egg everything bagel and it was real good. Pretty quick too!

A warm good smelling welcome was quickly followed by a helpful and smiling staff. Bagels are fresh and delicious. The dozen we order came with whipped butter and cream cheese, plasticware and plenty of napkins. Easy to get up and worth the trip