The best Gelato in Hayward | Sluurpy updated in May

Farmstead Creamery

93/100 (176 ratings)

Dessert

Pizza

Cafe

European

American

Brunch

Drinks

Breakfast

Dinner

Lunch

Salad

Ice Cream

Gelato

Lamb

Sit down

Parking Available

Free off-street parking

Free Wifi

Accepts Credit Cards

Takeout

Accepts Mastercard

Accepts Visa

Accepts American Express

Street Parking

Accepts Discover

Wheelchair Accessible

Gift Cards Available

Mid-range

"We had an amazing time at the pizza farm at Farmstead Creamery. We were very impressed with their sustainability model - the food tasted fresh and..."

Nadine Babu

"A neat place hidden in the forest of northern Wisconsin. Loved it. Had a good lunch with friends, very good food. If you are into knitting or..."

Beverly Sedlock Vadnais

"The food was awesome and the waitresses were great and very friendly. The Gelletto was out of this..."

Patricia Ann Dudley

"A great add to the community, they have plenty of events to interest..."

Drema Trisdale

"I think they should make a room fragrance called Farmstead Creamery Pizza. Oh my gosh, they are amazing!!! What a delightful place to stop for a..."

Andrea Marple Wittwer

"The freshest food possible and the nicest people. Not to mention the best sheep's milk gelato I've ever..."

Barbara Hillestad

"Amazing how everything works..."

Judy Woller

"The prices are high, but the quality, atmosphere and service is high, High, HIGH, as well. When in the area, you have to stop..."

Conway Reese

"Just had a great time at this neat little eatery. Food was excellent and owners very sweet and attentive. Our 2 year old loved seeing the chickens,..."

Janice Peterson

"Wonderful family. Delicious food. I think my son ate 6 pints of gelato in our 2 weeks on the Tiger Cat Flowage! Can't wait to come..."

Sara Grigsby

"Nice farm to table lunch and breakfast..."

Terri Ziem

"This is truly my favorite place to relax and eat wonderful food. The owners are..."

Shivawn LaBarre

"So delicious and great atmosphere ...people so..."

Brenda Ehlert

"Just had a delicious & fresh Valentines dinner paired with beautiful..."

Corey Belken

"Really good waffles, a bit on the high. Otherwise I ordered savory option which was very delicious, freshly grown vegetables sauteed on top of my..."

Cocobella

"Fun little place. Great gelato. A few friends..."

Clark Becker

"We went Sunday morning for their Bismarks (fluffy crepes). The food and coffee was delicious. Everything is either from their farm or locally..."

Krista F

"This our favorite place to eat at when we are in the area. The kale they sell is superb compared to what we can buy elsewhere. Wish we lived locally,..."

Greg C

"I stopped in while on a bike ride this morning and it was wonderful! The coffee and bakery were superb and the outdoor seating was plentiful. I wish..."

Ken Graetz

"The food...Delicious! The homespun and dyed yarn plus art and music...beautiful! The gelato...Oh, my! The Farmstead Creamery Family...Adopt me! Farm..."

Reset

There is only one restaurant

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Gelato in Hayward

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters