Sluurpy
Reset

There are 9 restaurants

Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Hampton Bays

There are 9 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Villa Paul
94/100 (331 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Fried calamari
Avocado Feta Cheese
Red Cabbage
NY Strip Steak
Seafood Fra Diavolo
Eggplant
Escargot
Pasta
Baked Clams
Almond Joy Sundae
Clams
Roast Long Island Duckling
Chicken Sasure
Duck
Oysters Rockefeller and Oysters Casino
Glasses of Cianti and Malbec
Smoked Pork Chop w Beer Brautwurst
Meatballs
Short Rib Risotto
Pesto
Chicken or Veal Caprina
Fish
Homemade Bread Pudding Seasonal Flavors
Red wine
Mussels in Garlic White Wine
Chicken parmigiana
Apple Strudel w Chocolate Ice Cream 2nd Butter Brickell Cheesecake
Sit down
Italian
American
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Full Bar
Takeout
Private Dining
Dinner
Mid-range
"With the fireplace and wood paneling this resturant's dining room is amazingly beautiful. Our fish specials were delicious as were the vegetables. We..."
Michael Tillman
"We ate there a year ago for my Birthday. Amazing food and service. I had the fish special of the night, it was..."
Susan Messina
"I used to eat here many years ago. (Many). We found ourselves in the neighborhood and had to go in. Our waiter was Frank and he was so friendly and..."
Lorraine Mareno
"We had a great experience here. Very old school , and the older woman who was on the floor was a little overbearing. Our service was great and they..."
Brittany McElhiney
"Really nice place. Very cozy atmosphere. A little older crowd. Friendly attentive staff. Drinks were very good. Food was delicious. No pics of..."
Hatchman
"This place has history, dating way back to 1804. Villa Paul is old school and takes me back decades. Super cozy, wonderful staff, and excellent food...."
Frank Morgano
"Had a private party of 50 and they opened just for us. They did an outstanding job. I'd love to go for dinner when I'm back in Hampton Bays. ..."
Scott Rispaud
"We unexpectedly found ourselves at Villa Paul this rainy afternoon. The service was beyond commendable, from our waiter to the bussers, we were doted..."
Andrea Conyngham
"Nicole was the best waitress today! She was excellent, spot on and cheerful pleasant and very attentive. My brother Brooklyn Parks Commisioner and I..."
Miamaher lofland
"This was my first time at Villa Paul in Hampton Bays. It was surprisingly full on Friday night in January, out of season. Calamari was great to..."
Kadir Ozbek
Scotto's Pork Store
88/100 (407 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Deli
Pizza
Deli
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Lunch
Dinner
Sandwiches
Pasta
Salad
Focaccia
Pesto
Pork
Fast food
Pizza
Italian
Deli
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Parking Available
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"I've been going to Scott's for 30 yrs but surprisingly I never had one of their pizzas. Last wk I ordered the Chicken Marsala Pizza. It was the best..."
G G
"We love Scottos. They have everything my Italian Mom made for us,25yrs.wonderful Sullivan Street Bread from Brooklyn,on weekends. Great breads made..."
Judian Johnson - Cooney
"I ordered a personal pie and absolutely loved it! They have a tasty selection of foods and ready to eat meals as..."
Denisse DePaz
"Always a great meal. If I am on my deathbed bring me the Chicken Francese and some Garlic..."
Michael Nappo
"Tasty food, friendly staff and comfortable space to eat in or..."
JDJ
"Love this place. Pizza and meat cuts are really..."
Andy Seaman
"Food is so fresh and delicious i recommend..."
A A
"This is an unexpected find. It offers fresh frozen pasta, antipasti and a selection of cheese for purchase. There is also pizza and Italian..."
Christopher Magyar
"Delicious, authentic Italian experience. The owner personally took care of us for a portion of our meal, and really made us feel welcome. Whether..."
Travis Gear
"This review is two years old 2020. Their food used to be first rate. Lately I've been disappointed with every single order so much that I don't go..."
Sir Poochala
"We recently ordered in from Scotto’s for a party, and the food was outstanding. The pasta salad (bowtie with mozzarella), sandwiches, salad, and..."
Alan Blank
"Our go to spot for 20 years ! Best marinara sauce which makes everything delicious . Pizza , panini sandwiches , the mile high lasagne, eggplant..."
Lauren Machin
"It is clear that high quality ingredients are used in the food here. Their Venetian pasta salad is one of the best foods on this Earth. I also have..."
Marc Titus
"Pizza was just about the best tasting pizza we had in a very long time. Crispy, delicious, perfectly cooked, amazing sauce, yummy real mozzarella..."
Mazzie
"Just took home 4 amazing different slices. Teenage son and I loved them. Great flavor! Then got a nice cut of tiramisu freshly cut and recommended..."
Paul Berge
"Great take out and best lunches. Nice European sit down bar for a drink or an espresso/ cappuccino. Both prepared menu as well as made to order...."
Al Daddio
Edgewater Restaurant
87/100 (1450 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Italian
Italian
Vegan Options
Seafood
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Brunch
Drinks
Risotto
Chicken Parmesan
Mussels
Fried Ravioli
Tuna
Lobster Eggs Benedict
Calamares
Filet Mignon and Shrimp and Mushroom
Salmon
Shrimp
Shrimp Oreganata & Risotto
Zappa Di Pesce on Top
Mussels Appetizer
Cockis and Creamos Cheesecake
Crab Cake
Lobster
Edgewater Crab Cakes
Steak and Eggs
Braised Short Ribs over Polenta
Mussels Marinara
Cod
Pasta
Lobster Pasta
Salad
Blueberry Waffle
Tiramisú
Pesto
Crab
French Toast
Fish
Scallops
Lamb Chops
Chicken Cutlet
Fried calamari
Calamari
Frutti Di Mare
Sit down
Seafood
Italian
American
Takeout
Television
Live Music
Reservations
Waterfront
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Drinks
Brunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"This place is in my option one of the best places to eat on the east end of Long Island. The food is delisious, The service is fast and efficient ..."
Michael Mosolino
"In all the years we have been going I’ve never had a bad meal or experience. During the summer the wait can be long but always worth it. Had..."
Pete Pedone
"Our favorite restaurant! Have never had a disappointing meal, as everything is always delicious! Always the first restaurant we recommend to family..."
Kristy Lyn
"I am never disappointed when leaving the restaurant! The food is perfect every time, the staff is great and the ambiance make you feel like your at a..."
Sabastian Wallace
"Absolutely love this restaurant. Definitely one of my new favorites around the area. We went for my HB birthday with no reservation and they sat us..."
M P
"I ordered the lobster pasta, a 16oz ribeye and almond creme cake with a couple of cocktails. It was one of my favorite meals I've ever had. The staff..."
S Clark
"Loved this restaurant! I am always looking for good food on the water and this place was lovely! We called memorial day weekend on Sunday and..."
Nicole Pellegrino
"Great restaurant, went on a random Wednesday in the middle of July and it was packed. They had a wait for outdoor dining however they were able to..."
Anthony Fontana
"Food here was just alright. The homemade pasta was very doughy, the frutti di mare sauce was way too watery, and the fried calamari wasn't very good..."
Daniel Antoniazzi
"Place was great. Not too pricey, considering the location, with great food and..."
Chuck Watson
"We had a great time at the Edgewater restaurant. 4 of us were very happy with our meals. One was not the hostess and waitress went out if their way..."
Richard Heiles
"We are staying at the Bay Breeze Retreat (name of home on AirBnB) in Hampton Bays and this is 10 mins away. Perfect spot for brunch and more. We..."
Sree Sreenivasan
"Hands down Brittany is a fantastic waitress, you should all be so lucky to have Brittany for your server. Now let's talk about the food, my wife had..."
Scott Orban
"Nice neighborhood restaurant. Nothing fancy or exciting on the menu but some decent food in a laid back atmosphere. Portions are larger than..."
Alison Lee
"Nice location across the street from the bay. Outdoor seating is nice, but only one round table. It can get pretty chilly indoors in the summer, so..."
Ellen Botwin
"Fast service, super friendly staff and delicious food, the atmosphere was also really nice. We got there around 7:30 on a Sunday night and were..."
Andrea Asencio
"Truly a hidden gem! Never knew this place was here and always see it packed inside and out! Decided to try it tonight and we were blown away. Prices..."
Michelle Rebhun
"Such a cute atmosphere here - service was great and they had an outdoor seating area with heating. Food was delicious, the margarita and rum punch..."
Alona Kornberg
"The view is nice and the staff is very friendly. Rachel was my waitress and although it was crazy busy she tried her best to be attentive to our..."
Pahola Tene
"Nice dinner with a nice atmosphere. Perfect outdoor summer..."
Ricky Reda
"A bit pricey but everything tastes great while looking out at a million dollar view. The lobster pasta is a $37 dish but the taste justifies the..."
Patricia McEnery
Gemelli Gelato Of Hampton Bays
85/100 (454 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Italian
Italian
American
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Brunch
Drinks
Breakfast
Ice Cream
Café
Italian
American
Parking Available
Delivery
Playgrounds
Seating
Lunch
Late Night
Drinks
Brunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Mid-range
"Cute place and the gelato was delicious. I got the coconut and banana Nutella in a coconut waffle cone. My husband got the lemon cookie and canolli..."
Julie Lanty
"Stopped by last year but couldn't get anything bc we didn't realize it was cash only. Finally got to stop here again this summer and on a weekday so..."
Chinh Chinh
"One of the best gelato’s we have had in New York/Hamptons (all 6 of us agree).The texture is so smooth and creamy. We came here twice on a weekend..."
saroasha engineer
"Came here with my wife all the way from Cali (that's another story) to see the beautiful sights of Long Island . A little lobster 🦞 on the beach,..."
Darth Crÿst
"Cash only, but ATM inside! Absolutely frigging delicious! Prices are a touch elevated - Hamptons in the summer, but 100% worth the little extra for..."
Steven Wilson
"Super friendly service and delicious gelato! I have had the pistachio, espresso, banana nutella all of which were phenomenal! Cute little set up..."
Emily Schiller
"We stopped by Gemelli after lunch in the Bays and thoroughly enjoyed some of the best gelato in the area on a beautifully maintained lawn dotted with..."
David Yoo
"We had Gemelli Gelato come to our Wedding to surprise our guests! They all raved about the gelato (which I knew they would, being a Gemelli Gelato..."
Christina Ferruggia
"Amazing gelato and custom service. The front lawn is so charming and picturesque. A must visit if you're in the..."
Khaleesi Targaryen
"Cash only, and well worth the stop. The owner is friendly and each scoop is served with a side of good cheer. The Gelato is not too creamy, not too..."
Mike Anderson
"Lovely little place! Flavors you're not gonna find at many other places, and an absolute beautiful location. Amazing place to sit down and relax on a..."
Spark
"It was our first time at Gemelli Gelato. The Gelato is fresh and delicious and very creamy too. I had the cookies and cream along with the UFO. My..."
Steven Tringali
"Best Gelato on Long Island. The spacious outdoor seating makes it a perfect spot for any occasion. Friendly staff and delicious flavors! I recommend..."
Crew Froebel
"The place is very small but if your into Gelato this is the place to go. They have certain flavors that are always available and then every day there..."
Robert Papp
"The gelato was amazing with so many flavors to choose! The atmosphere is beautiful, enabling everyone to sit outside with many different types of..."
Antoinette Merges
Francescas
82/100 (1509 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Pizza
Italian
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Lunch
Dinner
Pizza Kit
Grandma Pizza
Regular Slice
Buffalo Chicken Slice
Pepperoni Bites
Pinwheel and Pizza
Pasta
Baked Ziti Pizza
Vodka Sauce Pizza
Salad
Gorgonzola Slice of Pizza
Sausage Pepperoni Calzone
Zeppoli
Broccoli and Cheese Roll
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Ice Cream
Pesto
Garlic Knots with Vodka Sauce
Mexican Pizza
Ensalada
Panini
Pizza with Meatballs
Pepperoni Roll
Cheese Slice
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Delivery
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"Yummy pizza by the slice in a laid-back atmosphere. Great place to grab a quick..."
Brooke
"Yumm. Francesa's is the best pizza in Hampton Bays! The owner Mark is such a great guy!! Their other items on the menu are also very..."
Karen
"Good mix of classic and new toppings... Reasonably priced... popular with the..."
Jerry Jr.
"My family recently visited the Hamptons and ate at Francesca's. We had the best gluten-free pizza! We had a choice of two gluten-free crusts and..."
Daniella Fiorilli
"Wow have not been here in several years and the expansion is beautiful and the selection of slices of pizza is overwhelming. Pizza is..."
Jeffrey Anthony
"I’m up in NY visiting my bf, and he said you must have a Grandma Slice! He even explained the history of it being created by Sicilian immigrants..."
Joanne Jarvis
"Ok I am def a pizza connoisseur and this is FOR SURE THE BEST PIZZERIA in Nassau or Suffolk county.. the garlic knots are the BEST IN NY, PROBABLY..."
Ben Ericsson
"Absolutely love this place. It epitomizes the great local atmosphere you expect from a Long Island pizza place with the widest variety of specialty..."
James Houghton
"Best selection of pizza around. this place should be renamed Willy Wonka's Pizza factory. never in my life have I seen such a collection of unique..."
moses burdon
"Now, one thing that I need to write: being often to Italy, this is not your Italian typical pizza. Not at all, with thick dough and plenty toppings, ..."
Maya Stanislawska
"Love the food but love the service even more. They have 3 great young girls at the counter every Sunday when I come in and they are all a pleasure to..."
Tervell Turner
"I have been going here for 30 years! The pizza has never changed! It's amazing, my favorite ever. They have grown big and offer a ton of different..."
Thomas Trelease
"Delicious pizza and pasta. Try Grandma’s pizza and the vodka sauce. Sautéed veggies were also great. Staff was super friendly. Atmosphere is what..."
Susan D.
"They have the best pizza in the Hampton bay/ East quogue area. Upside-down slice is my favorite. They have a nice fish..."
Jeffrey Peterson
"What a great place!! Pizza was delicious. Staff super friendly. My little man got a spiderman action figure!!! The ice cream shop in the same place,..."
Jocelyn Mirabella
"One of my favorite pizza places in the area. Causal, order at the counter dining. They have booths for eating in or you can do takeout. Very good..."
Rachel Gonzalez
"Neighborhood favorite, particularly for take out dishes. Excellent if pricy pizzas. Dining in requires ordering at counter, pre-paying and then food..."
Len Dest
Centro Trattoria & Bar
82/100 (731 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Drinks
Dinner
Pasta
Salad
Calamari
Calamares
Meatballs
Pesto
Sit down
Italian
Television
Reservations
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Seating
Accepts American Express
Table Service
Street Parking
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts Discover
Validated Parking
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Dinner
Drinks
Mid-range
"This was my first visit to Centro but won't be my last! It was a very busy Friday evening and unfortunately there was confusion with the waitstaff as..."
Deborah Olson
"Best food, best service top notch love the Ny Strip that's just one of ny favorites amazing staff & amazing owner and amazing chef best food..."
Stefanie Ferrantello
"Amazing food especially the Pescatore pasta dish. Great staff always around and knowledgeable. Great hostess who sat us right away for our..."
Jessica Paige
"I LOVE this place. Beautifully decorated and delicious food. Been twice for restaurant week, once for brunch, and another time for price fixe..."
Jordan Federico
"We went last week and loved it! The waitresses, bus staff, and hostesses are all wonderful. Great atmosphere, great selection of wine, and delicious..."
Colleen Kolb
"Attended a private party last night at Centro and drinks, food, service and atmosphere was amazing! Variety of passed hors d'oeuvres, top shelf bar,..."
Christina Marie
"Centro Trattoria & Bar has a delightful ambiance. The food is terrific- with a nice selection to choose from and the staff is fantastic. I highly..."
Erin Lynn
"Amazing place! People, food, staff... everything on point! Will be back!!..."
Nancy St John
"Nonna's Meatballs are a must! Absolutely delicious tender Meatballs in a fresh sauce. To die for! We also got the lamb chop special, they were..."
Kimberly Piazza
"Love this place. Food and ambience great ! We did not have a reservation because we thought it would be quiet at 6 pm. All tables were already..."
Donna Thiele
"Out meal last night, which was during restauarnat week and a packed house, was one ine of the beat meals we have ever had. Definitely in our top 5..."
Rochelle Diamond
"Just got back from my first visit to Centro and it was excellent from start to finish. Everything from the appetizers to dessert was superb. Can't..."
Janet Cassidy
"talented, friendly, warm, chef and staff amazing food, atmosphere, and family oriented.....Best by far! Job well..."
MaryAnn DiGregorio Arcati
"Great food, atmosphere, staff and management. Always a family favorite for dinner. Thank you for making our son's 7th birthday dinner..."
Vickie Anne Weidner-Single
"Went for a birthday dinner with a group of 6. The service was A1. Very nice and helpful. The table was also a horseshoe shape that was nice for the..."
John Goleski
"This is a very nice Italian restaurant with great service and good food. For an appetizer, we ordered the antipasto for two and shared it with three..."
Carol Cooper
"Fantastic food and service at this Hampton Bays italian restaurant. Stand alone venue with its own parking lot outside of town. You can valet or..."
John “JV”
"was looking for a nice happy hour deal. Paid 10 dollars each for a full size order of ,eatballs, baked clams and a pizza, also 10 dollars each for..."
Gary
"We hosted a rehearsal dinner at Centro last night for 30 guests. I can’t stress enough how amazing it was. The food was phenomenal and the service..."
Carly Barron
"If you enjoy Italian Cusine this restaurant stands out in the crowd. From the wine selection to the scrumptious meatball appetizer along with cozy..."
John Guma
"Centro is a delightful experience!!! The Christmas decorations were beautiful. The food was very delicious,..."
Derryl Baumer
"This is one of my goto happy hour spots when I'm visiting friends in Hampton Bays! What the location lacks in ambiance (on route 27) it makes up for..."
LR
"The food presentation was beautiful & tasted just as great My sister and I went out to celebrate my 21st birthday and this was the perfect..."
Denisse H
"Place is lovely. Friendly staff, good service, food was delicious and drinks..."
Rossy Ureña
"Our evening at centro was just wonderful. From the start, we spent about an hour at the bar with Chris our bartender who was great with his service..."
Steven Tringali
"New Years midnight toast 2022 was great. Eggplant parmigiana, burrata, calamari salad are fabulous. Caring waitstaff and..."
Caitlin Quinn
"What an enjoyable dinner again with live music, great atmosphere as always. Big compliment to the chef, the food is delicious!! Thank you Centro..."
M Tozoglu
"We have been here quite a few times for dinners and family affairs. The food, service and atmosphere have always been fantastic!! I also must say..."
Danny S
"Excellent hospitality and service, Dinner is always outstanding with a great rotating list of specials. Will continue to visit here on a regular..."
Chris Sujeski
"Centro is the best place to host a private event. The food, the service, and the attention to detail are top..."
Melissa Murphy Pavone
"Delicious food, the carbonara is absolutely outstanding but you can't go wrong with really any of the options. The service is very friendly, and the..."
Oliver Willis
Uncle Joe's Pizza & Parlour - The Hamptons Institution Since 1968
80/100 (353 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Lunch
Dinner
Shrimp Francese
Fried Calamari & Red Sauce
Chicken & Orzo Soup
Buffalo Wings with Celery and Blue Cheese
Shrimp
Clam Sauce with White Wine Sauce
Kid's Penne Alla Vodka
Steamed Spinach
Ceaser Salad
Eggplant
House Salad
Pizza Slice
Seafood Marinara
Spaghetti
Bread
Shrimp Cocktail
Chicken parmigiana
Italian Cheesecake
Garlic Knots
Chicken Francese
Cannoli
Eggplant
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Television
Seating
Accepts Mastercard
Table Service
Accepts Visa
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts American Express
Street Parking
Accepts Discover
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Digital Payments
Accepts Credit Cards
Family style
Non-smoking restaurants
Reservations
Delivery
Takeout
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"It was my first time coming here and I arrived around opening with my mom. Not only was everyone so attentive and nice, especially the owner himself..."
Mary Ayers
"Uncle Joes is one of the best places to just sit and have pizza or dine in, in my opinion. the service is great, the employees are all great and..."
Veronica Marin
"Welcome to my review of Uncle Joe's in Hampton Bays. I will start by saying that I have read the prior reviews and will now give you my straight up..."
Steven Tringali
"Best slice I’ve ever had. The penne alla vodka. Friendly service..."
Chris Forrler
"Before I even order, you have hands down, the most customer friendly ordering menu of any I have looked at! Start with not having to sign in before..."
carol valk
"Its not your typical Italian restaurant... the pizza is the best and the pasta dishes are delicious. Anything you choose from the menu will be..."
Cinderella
"Place had very few customers when we arrived but our food took over 1/2 or more to come. Waitress was attentive giving us more bread etc. (which was..."
Rita Del Rey
"Great pizza, awesome service and I love what they are doing with this place.. check out the new back room..."
Joseph Rincon
"I just had dinner here, Tortellini with meatballs was delicious. The Tortellini tasted like it was homemade pasta. Very nice music in the background..."
David
"We went on Monday evening as a party of 8. Everything was amazing! The food was delicious, service was great, and it's a really nice place! The bread..."
Christine Dodaro
"Someone just asked me where I would like to go to dinner for my birthday 10/21/23 and I replied Uncle Joe's in Hampton Bays! Only one problem...I..."
Fiona Molloy Lepperd
"The food is delicious, there is both seating for the restaurant part and a seating area for when you just need a quick bite. The lunch special of two..."
STROKEMEFASTR
"Uncle Joes is one of the best food experiences of my life! The Pizza is off the hook and the food is beyond delicious. And I mean everythin! ..."
Boston Hayworth
"The food is delicious and the restaurant is cute. But the true gem is Joe himself. He is SO sweet. Please go visit this cutie and enjoy his..."
Danielle DellaRagione
"First off... Ashley is the best waitress Ever !! The pizza is amazing. The crust, the cheese... everything you could possibly ask for in a perfect..."
Linda Silverstein
"Great pizza and Ceasars salad. Chicken orzo soup is amazing! Love uncle..."
Tanya Layburn