Reviews Red Barn Cafe & Pie Shop

Facebook
Carmen Shimabukuro Cortese
+5
This place is amazing the ladies were so nice and helpful. The pies are so delicious !!! And the chicken pot pie is amazingly delicious. I highly recommend this place .�
Facebook
John Quinesso Jr.
+5
Fabulous! A “must try” if you are in the Hammonton area (or even if you’re not, it’s worth the drive!). Brunch was delicious (spinach and feta quiche) and warm apple pie for dessert. The pies are out of this world in taste and beauty! Evelyn is the perfect hostess! Bon appetit!
Facebook
Teri Bortz
+5
Had lunch here today with my mom and the food was delicious! The vegetable quiche was amazing - creamy, and topped with a variety of tasty veggies - a great way to get your daily quota! It was accompanied by little red roasted potatoes, a toasted buttery croissant, and a fresh cranberry fruit salad - also as delicious as the quiche. The apple blueberry pie we took home did not disappoint! Can't wait to go back again!
Facebook
Robert Guida
+5
It is worth the 1.5 hour drive. Rather than retiring, three or four woman do all the cooking, and run this place. Make this a day trip.
Facebook
Nancy Leggoe
+5
This is hands down my favorite place for breakfast! My friend Jen treated me for my birthday. Since as usual we couldn't decide, we got the cranberry-orange pancakes & Red Barn frittata and shared! Thank you Evelyn for a wonderful meal! See you again soon!
Facebook
Sharon Carty
+5
Ricotta pies are my favorite pies. Now, knowing I can get them year round is just amazing. There are so creamy. Knowing I can get fruit on them was just too much. I was there today. I bought a chicken pot pie and several other pies. Evelyn was so nice to us giving us samples and telling me how to bake the pot pie. I will keep going back until I try them all. The prices were reasonable compared to other bakeries with pies of less quality.
Facebook
Karen Nergart
+5
The pies are the best! Try the ricotta pies! Breakfast and lunch there are our favorites! Quiches are amazing!
Facebook
Maryann Hornor Patten
+5
The apple crumb pie is the best I've ever had! Tastes like homemade. Will be back to try some of the other varieties.
Facebook
Liza Perez
+5
Always the best place to go when you visit Hammonton, NJ
Facebook
Becky Borders
+5
Stumbled upon this place 2 minutes before closing. Unfortunately there was only 1 pie left and a gentleman walked in right after me and I let him have it. It was a cherry/apple pie and it looked delicious! I bought an asparagus quiche and some beef barley soup. The woman who was there was extremely courteous and helpful. She wrote the directions down for baking the quiche. Both tasted AMAZING!!! My husband loved it too!! Can't wait to go back and try some more menu items(especially the pies)!!
Facebook
Todd Kostrub
+5
Evelyn puts true Love in to all her pies....they're made by hand and taste like heaven! I never thought I'd say it but they're as good as my Grandmom used to make....
Facebook
Kathy Enright Tyler
+5
Got the best strawberry pie today!!!
Facebook
Evy Mercado
+5
I just <3 the owner Evelyn & her staff they make you feel right at home its a cozy atmosphere <3 we always get all our holiday pies here, there just wonderful thank you RED BARN! keep up the great work :)
Facebook
Wendy Winser Pittman
+5
Delicious breakfast, exceptional service in a warm and friendly setting!
Facebook
Jessica Ruscetta
+5
The pies are so awesome! They are not only the most delicious pies I have ever tasted but they are beautiful.
5
Sally Kamprath
+5
Wow, what a gem! The pies are out of this world, so fresh with tons of fruit! Our lunch was wonderful. Smashed meatball open-face sandwich. (my husband and I shared that) with fresh cucumbers and a a fresh, tasty, cranberry, apple, orange chutney. The squash soup was also so lovely with a thick, mild spice texture. The store was decorated so nice but I wasn't sure if any of it was for sale or just decor.
5
Kim Worthington
+5
We love stopping here for the pies. The apple crumb is one of the best pies we have ever had. Evelyn is so sweet. We will literally drive over an hour just for her pies.
5
Diane Stanaway
+5
The Very Berry pie and Ricotta pies are excellent. The lady was sooo nice. So worth a ride to get one. I will take a ride to try lunch.
5
Margarita Kuilan
+5
Great little place! Went there and have breakfast before our kayaking at the pinelands. Ordered just bacon and eggs, was served with home potatoes, a delicious bread, and some fruit. Coffee was served with a piece of biscotti. Service was great and food tasted like authentic home cooked food. Went back after my kayaking for some fresh preaches, and a few pies!!! If you’re in the area, near Atsion Lake, check them out! 🤗🙌🏼🙌🏼❤️
4
Cinnamon
+4
Such a cute little spot. Food was good and the owner was super sweet.
5
Becky O'Toole
+5
Nice relax atmosphere, the food is a little pricey but very good. You can tell they take pride in the food. The service was good and the woman I'm guessing who owns the cafe was very friendly. It is cash only but they do have an ATM machine inside. Amazing pies and quince. I've always have passed this cafe and finally stopped, so happy I did. My new place to get pies .
5
Catherine Lackey
+5
Best blueberry pie! Bursting with plump berries and not too sweet, just right. Thank you for your gracious hospitality. We will be back.
5
loismar
+5
Stopped here for breakfast. Family run business. Delicious food. Limited menu, great service. Definitely would return. They are known for their pies and there was a steady flow of people buying them. I would definitely return.