Reviews Crooked Lake Ice Cream Co.

Zomato
Stacy
+4.5
Old time charm. Soda fountain type menu, decent breakfasts. A place to gather, chat and eat.
Aug 23, 2010
Zomato
Maura C.
+4.5
Muy Delicioso!!!. My grandparents live on Keuka Lake, so during the summer I like to visit them. The first thing on my mind when Im in the car ready to travel two hours to the lake is, "I wonder when Pop will take me in the boat to get ice cream in Hammondsport..." The Crooked Lake Ice Cream Parlor is by far my favorite place to go! =)
Apr 20, 2009
5
Abbey
+5
Excellent spot for breakfast in Hammondsport! Kaylee was a wonderful server, food was high quality and the prices were reasonable. My only regret is not saving room for ice cream.
5
Steve and Denise Clark
+5
Our FAV breakfast spot in Hammondsport is the Crooked Lake Ice Cream Company! A quaint place serving breakfast, lunch, delicious coffees/lattes/cappuccinos, & of course, ice cream. The service is very friendly & the omelets were always cooked to perfection! They have several other breakfast options & daily specials. Don't skip this place in Hammondsport, especially for breakfast! We were in the area for 2 months & breakfasted here numerous times.
5
Erica Matthews
+5
Breakfast, second breakfast, elevensies, ice cream (open late in summer!) - what’s not to love?? I could eat here every day, and we almost do in the summer! Love the Vegan PB ice cream - a delicious non-dairy option. Kiddos each have their own favorites, including a banana split and a root beer float.
5
Hudson Reynolds
+5
Stuffed cannoli french toast was heavenly. Kind and accomodating staff. Can't wait to go again, it was great!
5
Beth B
+5
We were desperate for coffee, and after 2 other failed locations found this place. We are soooo glad we did. I got a mocha, perfect and not too sweet, and we both decided since breakfast was done to stay for lunch. Great food. We also went back a few days later for breakfast (also fantastic) and ice cream(yum). We will be back!
5
Kara Doherty
+5
I had breakfast there in the morning. The atmosphere and food was amazing. The avocado toast was delicious as well as my omelet. I love the vibe and energy with the vintage bar stools as well as how you can order thru the window and sit outside. I came back in the evening for ice cream and it didn't disappoint!
5
Jon Lawlor
+5
Great ice cream! Everything else is secondary by a long shot but the atmosphere is also worth the trip. Get the “unicycle” portion. I’m someone who usually gets the kids portion but the “training wheels” could have been a bit bigger even for me.
5
Laura Marini
+5
Had a great breakfast, fastest man on earth or something like that: breakfast meats with homefries with over easy eggs on top. Great cold brew. Nice gals taking care of business, waiting tables.
5
MORTIZ
+5
If you're on the hunt for a charming spot that serves up scrumptious breakfast delights, heavenly coffee, and delectable ice cream treats, look no further. From the moment I stepped inside, I was met with a warm welcome from the friendly and courteous staff, setting the perfect tone for an enjoyable experience. The menu boasts a delightful array of breakfast options, ranging from classic favorites to inventive creations, ensuring there's something for every palate. Whether you're a fan of hearty omelets, fluffy pancakes, or wholesome avocado toast, you won't be disappointed. Now, let's talk about their coffee – a true coffee lover's haven! Sourced from top-quality beans, each cup is a little piece of caffeinated paradise. From a rich and velvety latte to a bold and invigorating espresso, the baristas here certainly know their craft. And as if that weren't enough, the real showstopper is their artisanal ice cream. I couldn't resist indulging in a scoop (or two!) of their creamy delights. The variety of flavors is impressive, and each spoonful is a burst of pure bliss. The only minor drawback I encountered was the limited seating inside the restaurant. However, this was quickly remedied by the option of outdoor seating. On a beautiful day, basking in the sun while savoring the delicious offerings made for a delightful experience. In conclusion, I wholeheartedly recommend this place. It's a haven for breakfast enthusiasts, coffee aficionados, and ice cream lovers alike. The welcoming atmosphere, coupled with the amiable staff, creates an inviting ambiance that's hard to resist. So, whether you're looking for a lovely breakfast spot, a perfect cup of coffee, or an ice cream treat to remember, this place is definitely worth a visit. I can't wait to return for another delightful culinary adventure!
5
Maureen Frisbie
+5
Just visited & we had a delicious lunch! Lovely outdoor seating with cool breeze on hot day. I had Turkey Club & hubby had Reuben. Fresh ingredients, delightful surroundings, wonderful service! Look forward to visiting again soon!
5
Amy Cook
+5
Stopped in for breakfast. Everything tasted delicious and the service was very good...friendly and fast. Cozy spot on the town square. Will definitely visit again when I'm in the area. Highly recommend.
5
Bob Johnson
+5
Great little place with great prices and atmosphere! The staff were polite and attentive to my questions. I would highly recommend stopping in if you’re in the area.
5
Vivian G R
+5
Do not pass this up if in town. Breakfast was so great, coffee delicious. I can only imagine the ice cream service.
5
Faisal Reza
+5
Fantastic local spot for breakfast or sweet snack in the afternoon! Ordered the French toast with a bowl of fruit. Literally melt in the mouth! Could not resist a cheeky ice cream, they have a Peanut Butter and Jelly flavour that amazingly tastes exactly like those childhood sandwiches we used to have. Good balance of sweetness, not sickly at all. Would love to come back in the summer!
5
Amanda “Amy” Wilson
+5
Typical Small town Main Street attraction for a tourist destination. Offers foods and flavors they are not typical for local community but would seem common place for individuals traveling from a more metropolitan community. As a “local” I appreciate the both the upscale flavor and the homey local vibe it offers.
5
Lindsay Parke
+5
This time of year is quiet but the food was still delicious. Long time favorite place from my childhood ❤️
4
Lynnette Paton
+4
Super cute place right in town square. Stopped in for breakfast which was simple but tasty.. It is off season right now but can't wait to come back when it is warm and try the different ice cream options.
4
TJG
+4
Only had breakfast, which was very good. You can choose your breakfast sandwich options or go with a standard from the menu. Seating is outdoor, in a heated tent. Service was quick. $$-$$$. Parking limited, with street in front closed for outdoor seating.
5
Rusty Zipper
+5
Great place for breakfast lunch and dinner. They let me order lunch even though it was only 10:30 am. While lunch was coming I had some peanut butter pie ice cream, delicious! Prices were a little higher than normal but the food and service was good. Neat town, stop at the Curtiss Museum while you’re here!