Reviews Pizza Shack

4
Richard Parker
+4
Subs were good.. price was great and comparable to other places around. Conversation was pleasant. I would 100% go back again.
4
jessica parker
+4
Food and conversation was great. Prices were good. Customer service was great. Will go back again.
5
Jenn Lauler
+5
Absolutely LOVE their pizza. Not a fan of the sheet pizza 's dough though but a large ...remarkable. best pizza in hamlin!
5
David Knapp
+5
Great place with great food! The owners are great people that care about their food and their customers. They're hours are very accommodating. Prices are reasonable as is the speed of service. Keep up the great work!
5
Joe Heerkens
+5
We have lived in Hamlin just over 2yrs and tonight was the first time we went there for the buffet. There was plenty to choose from and looked delicious and fresh. I'm on keto,so it was wings for me. Let me tell you...they were fantastic and the people were nice. Overall a great atmosphere and experience....
5
MG Graham
+5
Still the best pizza in Hamlin! Great crust, sauce, plenty of cheese and they don't skimp on toppings either. Delish!
5
Monsieur Shapeau
+5
Super pizza and wings delivered super fast!! Love these guys
5
Daniel Mawn
+5
Absolutely perfect pizza and amazing fast service on football Saturday!
5
Kathleen Crandon
+5
I was drawn into this restaurant by a post on Facebook about a buffet. It was a very reasonably priced buffet with great, fresh options. The staff was very friendly and attentive. I would definitely eat here again 😋
5
Tanya Gang
+5
We love the Thursday night buffet. Whether the place is packed or we are the only family in here the food is fresh and hot at all times. The owner comes to check in on you throughout your meal and recognizes familiar faces.
5
Master Oreily
+5
Traveling from NYC TO Chicago this is by far the best pizza place I have gotten a taste of, especially when you ask for the pizza well done. The store offers generous portion sizes and toppings galore, there are no shortcuts taken here. Highly recommend if your looking for some amazing pizza, with a great tasting sauce, real pizza toppings, and amazing tasting pizza bread!
5
John Doe
+5
We went to another pizza joint down the road with a nicer storefront/environment. Their customer service was horrible so we ended up coming to the Pizza Shack. Well we were not disappointed, we ordered a basic sheet pizza and I'll tell you it was amazing! I loved the cuomo stickers on the floor as well, great to see a local company standing up for what is right. They will have my business anytime I am in the neighborhood.
5
Devan Caswell
+5
Best pizza I found out this way yet.