Cicis Pizza
1580 Wesel Blvd, 21740 - Hagerstown
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2025
2024
2021
#120 of 211 restaurants in Hagerstown
Updated on
Pizza
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
48/100
Data Completeness
61/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
📷 Photos (11+)
+3
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 11
100%
Google Reviews
740
Google reviews
Last 2 times I've been here and it has been absolutely horrible! They don't keep enough pizza or desserts fresh on the hot bar. Have had only 1 person making pizza with at least 10-15 customers in the store. Don't even try to take special requests for pizza anymore. If the pizza is on the bar it stays there until it's gone which looks like a dried up piece of cardboard. Walked out and didn't even get full or desert both times. Guaranteed to be a horrible experience unless this place changes sometime in the future. Don't waste your money, what little it does cost to eat here even.
Read more
Google
There’s a reason this place is empty. Actually too many to mention in this post. Pretty sure pizza 🍕 is supposed to have tomato sauce on it. I am not exaggerating when I say that the pizzas
had NO SAUCE at all. I don’t mean “little sauce” a literally mean “NO SAUCE.” The. macaroni was cold and dry. When we told them about it they said “Our machine isn’t working.” What machine? The microwave? Is that the machine they are talking about? 12 slices of pizza spread out over 8 pans. I will stop there. Don’t waste your money. That explains an empty dining room on a Sunday afternoon.
Read more
Google
The Food is usually decent quality. Although, the soda machines are never cleaned very well. Staff is usually pleasant. The kids love the little arcade to play around in and keep busy. They were very helpful when my son had a pretty severe behavior episode s few years back. On average the food quality remains what I would call "decent". Good place for large groups to dine in. Its definitely a good place for a cheap quick dinner idea to bring the kids and/or grandkids.
They offer fundraising for schools and such places.
Read more
Google
My Dad and I eat here frequently and the establishment has improved greatly since Jay has taken over! The pizza tastes excellent and there’s always a selection at the buffet. Since the new owner, I’ve been impressed by the cleanliness and friendliness of the staff.
Google
okay! i liked it. the cinnamon rolls were good. salad was fresh. pasta was a bit cold and the Alfredo looked like water. the screw to the toilet had only 1/2 screws on it. so i went flying to the left. i liked it though. i want them to add water to the drinks. only sugar drinks. but not bad i was expecting worse.
Read more
Google
This place is horrible!!!! $26 for two adults when their tomatoes for the salad were rotten, pizza they was very few selections and only 2 were were fresh the whole time we were there. The rest were rock hard!!! Even the bread sticks and pasta were hard from sitting all day. My boyfriend took his concerns to the manager and he just brushed it off like it was nothing pretty much and walked away. Service horrible!!! I do not recommend at all!! I will never go back.
Read more
Google
i would give 3.5 stars. pizza was good, salad bar was fresh and had lots of toppings, and the cinnamon rolls were amazing. the only downsides were it was a very dirty in there, the brownies tasted like Clorox, and the floor was wet. would recommend though
Google
Service was amazing!! Thanks Vijay for making my moms day so Special!! Place was super clean and the best part Pizza was made to your liking and order at the moment. People complain about no having pizza but when they do still complain it’s cold but when you order at the moment it’s better!! HOT and FRESH!!!!! Again!! 10 stars thanks to Jay
Read more
Google
Explore more in Hagerstown
By cuisine
By specialty
Recommended pages
Help improve this page: