Fenimore's Pub

We dined in the quiet, toasty igloo. The experience was even better than we expected- and we had high expectations. We enjoyed friendly attentive service, and the food was superb. We shared a hot and flavorful pretzel with a crunchy outside and soft light doughy inside. All 4 entrees were equally excellent, steak and salad, two burger selections and the short rib sandwich. We weren’t planning to eat dessert, but we didn’t want to be awake all night with regret so we made the good choice and finished the meal with salted caramel apple cheesecakes and warm chocolate fondant cakes. If you’re deciding where to eat- just eat here!

My date and I both got the prime rib special this past Christmas Eve (2021). And I'm fairly sure the prime rib was so undercooked that my date got food poisoning. His looked redder than mine, plus I avoided the really red part of mine. Unrelated, the women's room was beautiful but not in the restaurant, and I had to ask for directions to find it.

Ordered their signature burger without mushrooms and it came to me without mushrooms but as it was also suppose to come with grilled onions, I could hardly tell that the grilled onions were there. Additionally, I ordered medium doneness and it came more well done. On the plus side, the black garlic aoili on the burger was delicious. The service was good as the waiter comped the burger.

We attended a celebration of life reception in the Warren Room, following a funeral for a beloved family member who'd passed away. While coffee and tea along with a couple of "soft beverages" were served with the very nice buffet of sandwich preparations and salads, as the afternoon progressed, a few of us began to wander over to the pub to get a cocktail, beer or soft drink. Once the gathering came to a close, those of us who were still there shifted over to the pub to reminisce and visit for the next few hours. The bartenders and wait staff were friendly, kind and professional and they truly helped to make a long overdue reunion of local and out of town family and friends, a warm and enjoyable experience.