Friends took me to Piero's for Mother's Day dinner 5 years ago and it was love at first bite. Best pasta house in Ashtabula county where every entree is reasonably priced and created fresh for you using only best quality ingredients. I've never ordered a dish I didn't like, the challenge is deciding which one to order! Not only is the pasta absolutely delish, the bread is abundant and fresh and the service is exceptionally friendly and fast. As soon as you walk through the doors you're greeted by JP and Cindy's very friendly smiles. A must restaurant to eat if your ever in GOTL!
WOW!!! Our first time back since they opened May 12th. We were greeted immediately at the door by Piero and his lovely wife Cindy. They are like family. He prepared the best seafood pasta dish and mussels (amazing). He surprised out daughter with cheese /spinach manicotti. She cleaned her plate. It was Eugene's birthday and he was treated like a King. Bottle of white wine and a piece of tira mi su with a candle. Truly a night to remember. MILLE GRAZIE
Not the best looking place, not the best cutlery but a really good and actual Italian food
Unique place, like out of an old movie. Owner comes to table ,takes your order & cooks for you. No menus, on a board above the open kitchen. Very dark & small inside, no AC just fans. The mushroom ravioli in cream sauce was phenomenal. The owners wine selection was perfect great Pinot. We shared mussels & fresh mozzarella to start. The guests with me had meat sauce, meatballs & sausage & really enjoyed it. Glad we finally made it here & not some sterile hotel restaurant or chain. Cash only.
My friends and I tried this place for the first time last night. We were beyond impressed. Our party of 9 was easily accommodated, and everyone loved their meal. Bonus- open kitchen where you can watch talented cooks prepare your meals. We will be back!
A cozy, laid-back vibe with many delicious options from spaghetti & meatballs to great salmon and specials. You feel like you are in JP & Cindy's kitchen and if you go often enough, you become family! Very attentive staff and fun Italian music playing! One of my happy places!
We've been coming to GOTL for years..never miss out on coming to Piero's.. wonderful food. .love the chef..best lobster ravioli ever.if you love fresh made Italian cuisine. .don't miss a stop here..
Delicious Italian food made fresh in front of your eyes. Recommend the mussels, fresh mozzarella with roasted red peppers, pasta with matriciano red sauce and the salmon with the lobster reduction sauce. Unique atmosphere, friendly staff. Chef is amazing!
Barbara DiRienzo-Little
+5
Had dinner last night at Piero’s! Can’t say enough about its owners JP and Cindy! Great food, great atmosphere, and great service! Fantastic food!!!
The bread is outstanding especially when it's dipped in the pasta sauces period I recommend the wild mushroom ravioli
Great food, great people! I had the sword fish and my wife had the 5 cheese ravioli. Everything was perfect and it made me think I was back in a Trattoria Italiana.
Do yourself a favor when you visit Geneva-On-The-Lake and plan on dinner at Piero's. The best authentic Italian food in the area prepared with only fresh pasta, fish, meats and vegetables. My favorite is the Ravioli Aurora.. the sauce is outstanding. Try it and find your favorite. You won't be disappointed.
Excellent alfredo. It's all about the food here and you won't be disappointed. Don't mind the plates and closely spaced tables. Wait staff is nice. Can't wait to visit again in the summer.
I feel blessed. This is that one stop, that one meal that will be talked about everytime Geneva is mentioned. A truly special meal, such a talented chef. I drifted off to the Italian roots of my wife, remembering amazing people and meals. The meal literally moved me. It was that good. Thank you Piero, thank you. You are a master!
We stopped here on a whim. The owner met us at the door, seated us. Asked us what we liked. And prepared an amazing meal in no time flat, dont let the size of the building fool you, or the plastic plates the food on them is nothing short of amazing, it took me right back to my grandmother's kitchens. And the owner and his wife both sat and talked with us. Great atmosphere and food. We loved it so much we went back the very next night
There is one chef who prepares everything. You eat this food the way he believes it should be made. He’s right. Excellent menu and wine. CASH only!
This place has been the same for years. Great food made right in front of you. Best place to eat in Geneva
The food was delicious and pipping hot. I loved how the owner/cook took you dinner order and that it was made as the front of the restaurant, right out in the open. Prices start at around $12 and they only take cash. It's a must! Pictures of the food, don't do it justice.
Everyone was very nice. The food was absolutely delicious 😋
Simply SPECTACULAR. There is ABSOLUTELY no better pasta in the USA. If you can go here you MUST go here...
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes