Reviews Athenian Garden

Zomato
Bkause73
+4
Love this place family owned great authentic Greek food only place I'll go around here byob warm friendly atmosphere the lamb and moussaka are excellent
Aug 05, 2017
Zomato
Chefboy
+4.5
Stopped in AG for lunch.  Our greeter / server was the owner who was pleasant and attentive.  We enjoyed hummus with pita.  Although yummy not the best I've had in a Greek restaurant. The spinach pie however, was one of the better ones I've had.  My Chicken souvlaki wrapped in a pita with all the typical accompaniments was delicious.
Feb 07, 2016
Zomato
Foodie SJ
+4.5
Food is awesome! Great gyro!
Aug 19, 2013
5
Jeremy Gayle
+5
Very glad I finally checked this place out . The food was great ! Really enjoyed the space ! Great friendly staff . Can definitely tell it’s family run which is nice to see .. the food was fresh . Made to order . I did not mind waiting one bit . Nice to have the food made to order. Will definitely be going back often to try the other items on the menu .
5
ashh
+5
They had the nicest staff here and everything was made fresh to order!! Im pretty sure it was family run so it was a nice place to stop at for dinner and I would definitely recommend coming here for large portions!!!
5
Ava H
+5
So fresh and delicious! The chicken kebob was flavorful and came with the perfect amount of food. The tzatziki was the best I’ve ever had!
5
Betsy Galarza
+5
Beyond delicious. So grateful for this place. Fresh, tasty, delicious & healthy. Rula the lady of the house sweetheart & amazing energy. Thank you for cooking amazing meals for us and for your wonderful hospitality and energy. Maria & Betsy.
4
Patti Dybdahl
+4
Service was good. Food was good. Menu, which I wished I would have took a photo of since I couldn’t find one in the photos, had options you would expect to find at a Greek establishment such as gyro and Greek salads, platters, falafel, baklava, etc. platters with pork & chicken pictured. Pita was good but didn’t take a photo. They also had Greek fries on the menu — French fries with feta and tzatziki which sounded really good, but we didn’t try this time.
5
Thanassis Veggos
+5
My wife and I absolutely loved the food and how lovingly it was prepared. We found the atmosphere nice but the decor inside a bit dated. For a real Greek decor (We are Greek btw) I would recommend the walls be painted white and the wood trim blue (Greek blue) the curtains and the light fixtures are gorgeous. The floor doesn't need any change at all it would go beautifully with the scheme I am proposing. Finally we noticed there is an nice outdoor seating area which if revamped with new tables, chairs and umbrellas would be stunning with a few more of the beautiful potted plants you already have. All in all we enjoyed our experience immensely and would highly recommend for anyone looking for delicious home cooking and family atmosphere
5
Ktina C.
+5
The food is AMAZING!! we live right around the corner and order takeout frequently. I will say they are not the friendliest people and have terrible bedside manners but the food is delicious which is why we still continue to support this business. I actually have never sat in the restaurant for service so maybe it would be different. The gyros and hummus are too die for, my fiancé is obsessed with the Lamb - Kleftiko.
5
Kathryn Tomlinson
+5
I have been ordering out ( dining in) as well for a few years. I absolutely love Greek food! I would have to say that this is my favorite Greek restaurant. They are a Mom and Pop restaurant. They are so friendly, and dedicated to their customers and go above and beyond. Food is always fresh and hot. Katie loves you guys thank you!! Give them a try! This is why I keep coming back.
5
Emily Reineberg
+5
A true hidden gem not far from the shore and worth the short drive. Everything was made to order and it showed - the bass and gyro were fabulous, as was the mezze triò. Cozy atmosphere, fresh and authentic Greek food, and BYOB is always a plus!
5
Corey Boone
+5
The appetizer we had (egg plant and 2 Greek dips) were fresh and tasted excellent. I got the gyro platter, so fresh and also tasted soooooo good. My wife got the lamb platter the lamb was to die for. It was really that good.
5
Steve Basdekis
+5
Thank you Nick Psounos & Roula Psounos for the delicious Greek Salad. The marinated chicken skewer was cooked perfectly. Loved the warm pita bread and the dressing was spot on. 😃🇬🇷🥗
5
Sam Duklewski
+5
I’m giving this place 5 stars since the food was outstanding. My mother’s family was all Greek and I grew up with Greek food and this place reminded me of my grandmother’s cooking. Very authentic and very good.
5
Dmitry Leiderman
+5
The best tasting food in the South Jersey area. Very fresh, natural flavors. The wait is appropriate - not long, because it takes some time to prepare a real flavorful food while you can enjoy great appetizers. My favorite! THANK YOU!
5
Meredith Szymanski
+5
I ordered through Doordash and typically expect an okay experience after food is picked up and delivered. This exceeded my expectations and may have been the best Doordash order I’ve ever gotten. Even after a bit of a drive the food was phenomenal. Huge portions and absolutely delicious. I’ll definitely be making this a regular spot and look forward to trying it fresh at the restaurant!
4
Adam Jones
+4
Very impressed with my lunch order today. I ordered a Gyro & Chicken Avgolmono soup.Everything was delicious. I will be returning here in the near future.Nothing Skimpy about their servings.Im stuffed like duck