My husband and I have become regulars. The food is consistently delicious. Always made to order! The slices are generous in size and fresh. We always get great service. The owner treats us like family. This has become one of our favorite places. Great food at great prices!
This place is a local favorite. If you het a chance eat in and enjoy the blues music and take in the memoribilia on the walls. No waiter service to speak of but you order at the counter, grab a table and wait for the staff to bring your order to you. No public bathroom.
.. very nice "Blues themed Pizza spot, very cozy, no complaints.. Pizza is great !
The pizzeria has a large variety of Italian food. Ranging from artichokes, rice balls and home made sopresata, all with the true Italian flavor created by Mrs. Theresa.
Best food ever love uncle franco and mama!! Miss u guys
Best pizzeria & restaurant on Long Island by far !!!!!
Awesome atmosphere! Wish I could bring those pepperoni cheese garlic knots back to Jersey with me for when I get the urge for them.
Excellent pizza, delicious regular plain slice!!! And an amazing assortment of Italian meats and foods. And the atmosphere sets this place apart. So cool. It's classic rock all over, on the walls and in the air.
I've been coming here for over 25 years. Best pizza around. Great pasta dishes and rolls. rice balls. See the pictures. Threasa, Frank and Rocco have poured their heart ans soul into this place. Offer homemade bread. Try the sesame crust on the pizza. It makes it extra special. Jazz music and New Orleans decor.
Good food! Everything tasted great!
Love the pepperoni cheese garlic knots.
Simply the best - how can you beat it - excellent Chicken Ceasar salad and the Blues! Oh yeah those cheese knots...
Had 2 Gma slices.... PHENOMENAL Took a pannini to work and ate it the NEXT day..... HANDS DOWN BEST PIZZA IN NASSAU COUNTY
I have eaten pizza at Atlantic since I was a little kid. I was back in town recently and made a stop to have a slice, and I was not disappointed. Yummy as always. π
Oh my goodness. It's like coming home. My husband and I haven't been here in a few years. We picked up a Pie and a Shrimp Parmesan Hero - The food is just as good as we remember! The ambience is great and so was the service. We will be back ππ
Wonderful selection. Clean and pleasant. My only complaints are that the booths need to be rebuilt and you need to bring your own Napkins. The only napkins available are brown paper I usually see in a gas station bathroom. The kind you have to press the handle and rip off a sheet.
Not bad this pizza place regular slice was better then the sicilian both had great crispyness and the sauce was pretty good as well as the stuffed pepperoni garlic knots definitely want to come back to try the Chicago style pizza as well
![5]( "Recensione")
To all Italian Food lovers, my name is Kith and I love Italian food especially Pizza and Pizzerias I truly believe that small mamas and papas Italian food places are heart of True Italian Cooking. I have been to hundreds of places and I have seen good and bad places but I need to share this place with you .. Atlantic Pizzeria located on Atlantic avenue in Freeport is like taking a step back in time like how Pizzerias in Brooklyn, Manhattan and the Bronx use to look like. I never seen a counter display like this pizzeria.From 6 different stuffed garlic nut to about 7 to 8 different Rice balls to stuff Mushrooms, Peppers, Zucchini and Eggplant . The amount of specialty pizza and rolls they had was overwhelming, I had a 3 layer Eggplant slice and sausage roll the first thing I noticed was how crispy the crust was then how good the sauce tasted. I know I have found my new pizza place. I can't wait to come back and try something else.If you are in the neighborhood you should check this Pizzeria out, I forgot to mention how cool the place looks like and the great music they play. You should definitely check this place out.
oceanbreeze oceanbreeze
+5
That food is very good the only thing I didn't like is if you eat in there they charge you 15% gratuity
I've lived in Freeport for 10 years, but have never eaten here until this weekend. Best pizza I've had in the whole area, and the Stevie Ray Vaughan decor is the icing on the cake.
Old school Italian pizzeria. When I need my stuffed artichokes, no better place to get them. Haven't had a disappointing meal there yet. Been going for 4+ years
everything is really good except the spinish roll was too old and could not eat was bad by
Ive eaten most pizzas within a 10 minute drive of me and this is my absolute top pick pizza. I cant wait to eat this pizza again.
Edit- It can be crazy inconsistent when getting slices. Too salty, bread is to thin so it tears easy, REHEATED pizza from the night before. Do yourself a favor and just get a fresh pie, I haven't had a problem with that yet. Still some of my favorite pizza even knowing that.
I moved to Freeport in June of 2022. I have tried other pizzerias, and there is no comparison. This place IA awesome!!!!! They treat you like they have known you a lifetime time. The pasta dishes are unbelievably good. The pizza reminds me of what I used to get in litter Italy in the city. The garlic knots are delicious regular and cheese stuffed. The Stromboli blew my mind. This place is a few blocks from my house and it's my goto for everything Italian. I give them 4 stars and 10 hearts π
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes