Sluurpy
Reset

There are 4 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Florida Keys

There are 4 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Jersey Boardwalk Pizza
83/100 (254 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
"We thoroughly enjoyed our Stromboli with steak for two! The crust was perfect and tasty, there was lots of delicious cheese and vegetables, the steak..."
Leslie Reiner
"Pizza was cooked great! Crispy, a little browned on the cheese. Excellent pizza, garlic knots were amazing. Will order..."
SugarloafKid
"Enjoyed my cheese pizza. Not sure why the bad reviews, mine is a good one. The cheese pizza was really good , it had a good amount of sauce and the..."
Gina Martinez
"Pizza here is very good and the crust is perfectly crispy. Service is good. It is a strip mall so the atmosphere is fair, but they do have..."
Ingrid Sebastian
"Delicious food, customer service was great even when they where slammed they still offered to serve me and my family which had been driving all day..."
Janemarie Rodriguez
"I lost 50 grand on a pizza business back in the 90s. I’ve use pizza works in big pine key. Approximately three or four times are usually come in..."
JOEY DEE
"Friendly staff and goooood pizza! It’s so good you can heat it up three days later and it’s still amazing! AND they are open on..."
Katrisha J
"Best pizza anywhere around❗️Hole in the wall looks with an old school Italian pizzeria vibe. Very consistent quality with super friendly..."
Christian Wolf
"Nice people, exceptional pizza. Cheaper than the competition, and they LOAD on the toppings! Definitely our new go to for pizza and..."
Ariah James
"We visit the keys yearly and always stop in for pizza before we drive around and try and spot the key deer. Pizza is always great, best pizza we have..."
CarlosAmanda Garcia
"Pizza cook was rude. Hated everyone and everything in the place, good thing he knows how to make a good pizza. Waitress was awesome considering the..."
Henry Kokenzie
"Mozzarella sticks so good that I can't help but leave a review. I never get sick of..."
Velocirock
Paradise Pizza
79/100 (745 ratings)
Quick Bites
Pizza
Italian
Fast Food
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Sandwiches
Pasta
Salad
Wings
New York Style Pizza
"4.2/5 Stars The staff are extremely friendly and get the order correct. The pizza it's self wasn't my favorite. We ordered 3 pizzas and all of them..."
Yalc Kcin
"It felt like pizza night, everyone needs a pizza night. From Cudjoe there’s a few choices just north, Summerland, Big Pine or No Name. We went..."
Bob Strempek
"Absolutely adore this place. Food was amazing (WAY BETTER THAN BEFORE SERIOUSLY) Now that someone else runs it. Y'all are doing amazing and flipped..."
MJ Knowles
"Great pizza! I mean the cheese and sauce is delicious. But the chicken they have is very aggressive scared my German shepherd. But I would recommend..."
Joseph Wantland
"We ordered a hand tossed pizza with extra sauce and pepperoni, and some Keylime pie for delivery on our first night in Cudjoe Key. It was absolutely..."
mary jette
"We ordered two 12" thin crust pizzas, a bbq chicken and a meat lovers both were phenomenal perfect crust and a huge amount of toppings. We also..."
Jessica Hargrove
"Pizza is great, definitely a local’s spot. I’ll definitely order again and will try the thin crust next time, I also ordered the chicken fingers..."
Stephanie Carvajal
"Probably the best pizza in the lower keys, best service..."
John Kachurick
"So glad slice is under new ownership and restored back to its old self! So nice to have another delivery..."
Molly Vosburgh
"We ordered the meat pizza. This was the best pizza we ever had. OMG..."
David Anderson
"Excellent service, fast friendly delivery and countless delicious fresh items on the menu. We order sometimes twice a..."
Michael Gonzalez
"Awesome food. Meatlovers with jalapeños is my favorite! Addendum 8/14/23 is this place even open anymore? I call all i get is the busy message...."
Zachary Lee
Panini Schamini
75/100 (1093 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Healthy
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Lunch
Brunch
Breakfast
Sandwiches
Roast Beef
Juice & Smoothies
Prosciutto
Key lime pie
Cuban Sandwich
Pasta
Salad
Tuna
Curry
"Nice place for paninis, wraps and smoothies in the southern side of Duval St. The paninis were made with cuban bread, hot pressed and with fresh..."
Balaji Ganapathy
"Excellent food with great service. Only improvement would be to add two salad dressings...."
Wayne Marsh
"As soon as we walked in the woman behind the counter (the owner?) greeted us and waited patiently for us to order. The food is as close to “just..."
Chris Glade
"I ordered the Smoked Salmon Panini with a Mango Pineapple Papaya smoothie and it came out right away and it was SO DELICIOUS!! It came with a little..."
Mackenzie Craner
"Went to Key West for a week-long vacation. We found Panini Schamini and have ate there three times because they are fantastic. On our entire vacation..."
michael bark
"Excellent, fresh food at a reasonable price. Portions were maybe a bit large for us seniors, but just right for our adult children. We each had..."
G Patte
"There are not enough stars for this restaurant. AMAZING and our favorite every time we are in Key West! Be sure to try the juices.. beyond fresh and..."
Katie Lamonica
"First time here, excellent food, we had the spicy chicken panini and the Mediterranean wrap with the grilled chicken upgrade. Both were delicious and..."
Paul K
"The actual name of the place is Panini Panini. It might be hard to spot from the street. Don't let the interior design deter you. It's very small..."
Denys Thomson
"This place is recommended in the 2016 Key West Food Enthusiast guide, and for good reason. We had their special of the day, which was a chicken..."
A Bee
"We were in Key West for a day. It was extremely hot and we looked for a place where we could take a break and grab a bite, but we hardly knew where..."
Elena M.
"I enjoy the healthy choices 😉 of different types of sandwiches & wraps, salads and even fresh micro-greens. Another fantastic couple of treats..."
Vicki Carter
"If you can't believe reviews where people are groaning with pleasure over paninis in a small sandwich shop, visit them. I read the online menu..."
Barry Rocklin
"This place has a wide variety of delicious sandwiches, juices, and desserts! They also offer gluten-free bread (which is very tasty and didn’t fall..."
Katie Hart
"The roasted turkey panini was excellent - the wife and i returned three times while on our honeymoon. There may not be much seating inside, but..."
Nick Lemen
Mr. Z's Newtown
74/100 (439 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Beef
Salad
Cheesesteak
Philly Cheesesteak
Hoagie
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use