My husband has been several times but it was my first time there and I can't say enough great things. Excellent, friendly, attentive service. Meal was perfect (chicken with sun-dried tomato cream sauce, garlic mashed potatoes, and spinach...hubby had Porterhouse steak with roasted garlic and Brussel sprouts, daughter - 5 - had chicken and maccoroni). Bread was a nice touch before the meal, and the wedge salad was very fresh and crisp. My only "complaint" would be that a kids side of maccoroni should not cost $10 considering it was supposed to be a small add on to her main meal. I can see if that's all she ordered as there is a minimum per meal threshold I'm sure, and I'm sure most people just pay it, but I felt kinda taken advantage of on that part since we didn't worry about asking what a kids side of noodles was. The rest of the meal was worth every penny and we will be back, but definitely won't order the kids side of maccoroni next time.
The best veal chop I’ve ever had. Oysters above expectations. Tuna tataki took my breath away too. Amazing experience, not to mention exceptional service.
I had a phenomenal experience. My server was Ales and I appreciate his excellent service. My husband felt sick in the middle of the meal and everyone was very friendly and helpful in everything. I would like to have more photos of what I ate but since my husband wasn't feeling well I didn't take them. 100% recommended, excellent food and excellent service🙏
My server Pavel was very attentive and pleasant. Best crab cake I ever ate in my life and I done had had my share of crab cakes including chick & Ruth in MD. The steak was cooked and seasoned to perfection! The max and cheese was different due to a Smokey flavor. The conch chowder was alright. Wish there was larger pieces of conch and I was expecting New England style. The bread and whipped honey butter was awesome. The mashed potatoes was plain. The creamed spinach was perfect. Best key lime pie I ever ate. Best birthday dinner I ever had! Definitely will be back if I’m ever in Key West again!
Top notch. Wait staff friendly. Good amazing. Cooked to perfection. Easily shareable sides. Large portions. Beautiful presentation. Accomodating to dietary restrictions. Not so easy to find...must walk past pool up stairs
Enjoyed dinner here for my big 30th birthday. Sucks how the steaks do not come with sides but was amazing! Spent about $200 on 2 steaks and 2 sides. Moses was our server and he was amazing!!!
EXCEPTIONAL.. Literally EVERYTHING was exceptional.
The sourdough bread with sweet butter, the coconut mojito, the Jumbo Lump Crab Cake, the Surf & Turf, the Delmonico the sides... Truffled Macaroni & Smoked Gouda, Sautéed Broccoli with Garlic. The deserts... Key Lime Pie & Bread Pudding. Above all the SERVICE. Mike was the absolute best. Will definitely be coming back.
Prime 951 is one of Key West's best restaurants. My wife and I ate here right after we got engaged in 2021 and it was a very pleasant and romantic experience. I highly recommend you check it out for yourself because my pictures do not do it justice!
Wow! Seriously one of the best steaks I've ever had. The Delmonico steak was prepared better than almost every steakhouse I've been to. I think I've been to maybe 3 dozen of them maybe more. The smoked Gouda Mac and cheese was smokier than I expected but great.
Such an amazing dinner. The steaks were so good and cooked perfectly. Side dishes were also great, shout out to the fries! And the escargot was outstanding!
We had such a lovely evening at Prime Steakhouse celebrating our 1st anniversary. Our table was off in a little alcove, which gave a sweet romantic feel. The waiter was topnotch and brought us a delicious slice of key lime pie that had an awesome candle in it. He even took a bunch of photos for us, so we were bound to get a few that we loved!!
Excellent food the waiter was so nice but the place need some face lift highly recommended I think I had the best ever pork chops
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Key West
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes