Gabby's Pizza

Set in a very busy parking lot off a circle Gabby’s seems active. I’ve seen extra thick pizza there I wanted to try but when I went that type wasn’t ready yet . The place is small and could use a revamp. The pizza I got was Chicken parm . Decent sized slices prices average for the area I did ask for crispy which they did and I enjoyed it. The sauce was okay though I like a bit sweeter. They wouldn’t give me a glass of water rather wanted me to buy a bottle. Bottom line pizza is decent but more a take out place !

Chicken Marsala thick crust pizza. First had it at Gabby's seems like 15 years ago. It was great. Haven't seen it offered anywhere else. Stopped in for a slice once in a great while, like every 2 years, and ordered it if they had it pre-made. Never disappointed. So last night, the power goes out just before dinner, decided to order 2 pizzas, a white broccoli pie and the Chicken Marsala. Both were great, but I gotta say they have evolved the Chicken Marsala pizza to a higher-level art form. If you live in the area, and the idea of a chicken marsala pizza sounds good, you HAVE to try this.

They seriously need to update their prices online and on the paper menu! I called earlier today and placed an order for delivery based on the prices listed online. Then when my order finally got delivered to me almost an hour later when I literally live right around the corner, the delivery guy who wasn't nice AT ALL gives me my stuff and I gave him a small tip. I told him I'm sorry but that's all the money I have. He just mumbled and walked away. No have a good day or anything! When I saw the amount on the reciept I was blown completely away! I called them right away and told them I was over charged. They looked my order up and repeated everything back to me with the prices and they were completely different then what I saw online. The girl on the phone said that the prices did go up. I told her that their website has to be updated as well as their paper menu because it's very deceiving to the customers. She said with a bit of an attitude that everything in this world is going up in price. I definitely will NOT be ordering from there again until the prices have been updated online AND on the menu and some of their employees get rid of there attitudes!

Guy who answered the phone was impressively rude & apparently way too busy to take a phone order. With an attitude, kept aksing, “anything else, anything else, anything else”. Just confirm my simple order like I asked 3 times, you pathetic old goof. Pizza was ok, nothing tremendous. But overall the totality of the experience was just unnecessarily aggravating. If not for the d*ck on the phone I’d give a 3~4.

Gabby's Pizza is tucked into a busy strip mall that is adjacent to one of Flemington's many circles. The parking situation can be a bit dicey at peak hours. There aren't very many spots. Inside is a bit cramped, but the staff is friendly and service is quick. I decided to go with a plain slice and a margherita slice. The slices were average. The sauce and cheese taste great, but the base of the slices was fairly soft and didn't have great structure. The cheese slid around a lot too when taking a bite. Overall, the pizza wasn't bad.

They lie to you about delivery time, and the driver does more than just deliver. I was told he left the store to straight to my house- took an hour extra to show up (I love 5 mins away so he clearly went to a friends house or something) then I called back and was told “sorry he’ll be there soon” after no one talked to him😂 food was cold and bad by the time he got there