Review Tim's Pizza East - Fayetteville

You've had New York, Chicago, Detroit but this is Fayetteville style pizza. Big slices and a unique yeast crackery crust that left me smiling. I wish they had more of a beer selection, but the mugs are frosty

Very well priced. Good ingredients, a large is really a large size. The thick and the thin crust were both excellent. Loved the cheesy bread sticks.

Slow service... Waitresses are busy chit-chatting, instead of serving, but they like tips!! Great pizza, but you may have to go get your drinks... My opinion

Had the personal pizza and salad combo, very good, good ingredients, attention to detail and great wait staff.

Tim's is always great. My go to is the beer cheese dip and Pizzazz pizza. Never disappointed.

Staff was friendly. Food wasn’t anything special. I’m having difficulty wrapping my brain around the other reviews. Not worth $48 before tax for 2 pizzas and an app. Ordered and paid online, got confirmation email, received the second confirmation email saying our order will take just under 1hr for 2 pizzas. That info would have been nice upfront. Sauce was scarce. More scarce than an average pizza. Crust is a dry crisp on the outside with a little fluff inside. Most crust parts are cracker dry/hard. All in all everything lacked deep flavor. Pretzel cheese dip was good, pretzel was plain with a hard outer layer. Not worth the price in our personal opinion. We decided this pizza lies just above quality/flavor of Little Cesar’s. First time customer but we won’t be repurchasing again due to our preference.

Great pizza. Great service. Convenient location (for us Eastsiders). Crust is not fried in grease or butter, fresh ingredients, love the cheese and sauce. Comfortable environment. Wasn’t sure it was family friendly at first (with a bit of a bar feeling and motief), but it’s definitely for families and fun. Great service for kids (kid’s coloring materials and such). We’ll be back. Just sad we waited three + years to try it.

A friend of ours took us here while we were in NWA, because he said it was his favorite pizza. I've never had BBQ Chicken pizza that had pineapple on it, but it was amazing!!

Tim's is my absolute favorite pizza place. Every year for my birthday, anniversary, family outings - we go to Tim's. Normally, we have a great experience. My husband told me it was MY choice for Valentine's Day this year - I said I want pizza and I want Tim's. Unfortunately, our experience was not even close to a good experience. After waiting for nearly 15 minutes to catch our waitress, I got up and borrowed salt/pepper/cheese from another table as ours was missing (the other guests were very nice to let us do that). Our drinks ran out and I finally was able to flag down anther server who seemed very put out to have to help us since we were not their table. A third server stood behind me and twice loudly told another set of guests that as soon as our table was done they would add it to another table to seat their group. We had just received our pizza when he said this the first time. My husband needed an extra plate and after getting tired of waiting on anyone to bring it, I got up and got it myself. I did the same thing for our to-go boxes. I understand that they were very busy. I am in food service. For holidays and special events I staff EXTRA servers - always. Again, normally I love Tim's. They are normally my favorite - my husband and I even had our rehearsal dinner for our wedding there years ago. I dare say it will be some time before we return. Such a bad experience on a special night kind of ruined it for us.

The best pizza around cant find no better pizza, the staff is great

This is the best pizza in Fayetteville, friendly employees and a Fun place to have lunch. :-)

This has been my favorite pizza since 1972! My favorite is Tim's meathead and add Canadian bacon. The way they shred the Canadian bacon and sprinkle it everywhere makes it wonderful!

we actually have been here once before an it was awful but they were extremely busy so i chalked it up to that..ummm no...this was the second an the LAST time i will ever eat here..they were not busy at all an the pizza was cold in the center an so salty u couldn't even taste the actual pizza,thank god i have good teeth the crust was so hard an had a frozen taste to it...gross...i've had better pizza's from walmart..an let me just say the waitress took our order an then we didn't see her again till she brought the check...wow!!! so disappointed :/

Perfect family place to eat! Delicious salads, sandwiches, pizza. Great wait staff.

Best pizza in nwa period ,made with real cheese, fresh,Nice people ;)

Drive from Bentonville to Fayetteville for Tims on a regular basis. Sorry but the 1 Star Review and reccomendation of Pizza Hut is just sad - Tims gets busy yes - but for a good reason. Best in NW Arkansas - 🍕👍🏽

The pizza was great...Service was exceptional....I always stop in when in the Fayetteville area....

Great pizza and a great atmosphere. We come here often and we will always return.

Love Super Salad!! Hadn't had one in a while...didn't disappoint!

I love their salads, sandwiches and pizzas! The staff is always helpful with a smile!

Loved the salad. Pizza was okay for me but my son loved it. I don't like sausage on my pizza, I let him made the choice. Service was good.��

They have the best pizzas and sandwiches in town!!!!!

Tim's Pizza was great! The food was wonderful and the service was excellent!

Best salads and pizza EVER! We really enjoyed it. Wish we could have Tim's Pizza in Oklahoma!

We just left after they refused to apologize, comp, or even hurry after dropping out child's pizza all over the floor. The guy who dropped it just laughed. After the owner had the same terrible attitude as the the waitress we made the decision to leave. As we were gathering our things the owner cursed out my husband. Ok pizza but I will spend my money somewhere else.

This place is always packed, and there is a reason why!. Ordered a cheese pizza (because its national cheese pizza day!) and it was absolutely delicious. The amount of cars in the parking lot makes it obvious that this is Eastern Fayetteville's go-to pizza place. Next time you want pizza give it a try!

Always consistent ..... Tim's is a great neighborhood pizza and beer place that has been doing it right for many, many years. You always know what you are going to get with the food and the service is always friendly. Thanks to Tim's East for being a staple on the eastside for so many years.  But be warned, this is a family favorite for the neighborhood.  If you are looking for a place where it is quiet and there are not many kids, this is not the place for you.

Heaviest pizza in Fayetteville. And I mean that in a good way, Tims will give you a 6lb pizza. Their International and their Fools Gold will fill you up and be delicious everytime. Two slices will fill a normal appetite. Their ranch is delicious as well if you're looking for a good easy salad try the turkey! Simple but yet good everytime.

Great Pizza. This is great Pizza, I ordered the Tim's International and it was very very good, The salads are great also especially the super salad. Very cold beer. Never been disappointed with any menu item, service is good and personable.

What Happened?. The crust is not what it used to be or mine had turned before it was cooked and I know they are too busy for that to happen. It was as if it was freezer burned and then cooked. Instead of being nice and crispy with a classic pizza crust yeast taste it hard and chewy with a translucent look.

Favorite pizza. I've been going to Tim's for about 20 years and it is always consistent and fresh. I used to lived on Mission real close to Tim's East and it always felt like home when I walked in there....best pizza in my opinion.

Favorite local Pizza. Pizza is my favorite food and Tim's is my favorite place to eat pizza. The price is very reasonable, especially when compared to places like Mellow Mushroom and Gusano's. Tiny Tim's on the square has a nice atmosphere, with many good beers on tap. Tim's east has great service and consistently exceptional quality. The wait time can sometimes be a little long but definitely worth it

Premium Pizza worth every penny!. I'm a man who loves Pizza, and I LOVE Tim's! Hands down the best local pizza in town! Although I personally prefer Mellow Mushroom, I can get them in Atlanta whenever i'm home. Tim's East is my favorite of the bunch: friendly cooking staff, friendly service and, of course, the best pizza in town! Generous on the toppings, always cook my special orders perfectly. The crust is great when crispy, and it is stable without being hard to bite (like frozen pie crusts can be). The cheese they use is excellent, and I love their sauce!<br/><br/>Cannot stress the deliciousness of the pizza! If you haven't tried Tim's yet, do it soon!

This food is good, but the service is absolutely AWFUL. The waitresses are out of their way to be rude.. Would like the restaurant if not for that!

Nice local neighborhood pizza place. we drive thirty miles to visit this family friendly place. the crust is great along with the toppings. the service is prompt and friendly. wish they would open a place in benton county.

Classic family place, great pizza, and friendly faces.

Good subs. This location is very consistent in quality of service and taste of food. We are fans of the Super Salad and the Tim's Sub. You can split even the small salad between 2 people because the bowl is packed full. Nice salad dressings, too. I have been told that they make their own but can't verify that.

Great local pizza joint, I like all of their locations

By far the best pizza in NW Arkansas. My wife doesn't even like pizza and she loves Tim's. We get pepperoni and sausage (tell them to go light on the sausage if you value your arteries). The pepperoni and mushroom is also great.