Cicis Pizza

Look, when it’s been a long day and your party needs a lot of food for cheap, this is the place. The amount of food for a $9 (after tax) buffet of pizza is incredible. The food comes fresh out of the oven and is constantly being replenished. The staff makes pizza to order as well for the buffet! We were able to try many different pizzas and desserts. The reason I can’t give 5 stars is as follows: The Alfredo sauce for the pasta is bad. It tastes off as if it is spoiled. The restaurant is also very messy. Floors are incredibly sticky!

oh my lord i do not believe i have ever had the pleasure of tasting pizza this amount of exquisiteness in my entire existence. If Cici’s Pizza told me to sell my house and kill my friends, I would sell my soul to experience the pleasure of eating this fine meal once again. Thank you for enlightening my life.

I think this place is going through a identity crisis when it comes to staffing. If your favorite thing is the cheese sticks. They have been burnt the last Month or so. I'm not sure what's going on if the oven is up to high or not applying enough cheese but you can definitely tell. What's so hard putting enough cheese on your pies to make them look desirable. The staff also is having a hard time keeping fresh pizza up during busy hours. So keep that in mind

Ah man it was just bad. Their commercial isn't true to the exp. I had. Online ordering went okay, upon arrival to pickup food- There were 3 workers behind counter 2 of them looked at me, 1 didn't.. Eventually all walked away. The 1 came back and just looked at me didn't ask NOTHING just stared so I said: "Umm. I have an online order to pickup." She sighs turns and says What was it? So she gets in the warmer thing and pulls out EVERY ones pizzas and opened each box till she found mine!! There were no labels or stickers to identify the orders. She was about to give me 4 boxes & I said what's all this? I only had 1 pizza & some bread. She opens them and throws em back in the warmer. I said that's not a good system y'all got there. Once home the pizza was nasty. The toppings weren't cooked with the pizza just thrown in ONE area of it on top!! And the bread was okay. Do not recommend will not return. Blegh.

I haven't ever had a bad experience at cici's until yesterday. The salad bar was a HOT mess...out of things, it was messy, pasta in the pasta salad wasn't cooked all the way. The pizza all looked old, brownies were cold in the middle, a lot of pizzas looked like plastic and were just combines together. I was pretty bummed and so were my kids. Everyone was chatting and laughing behind the bar but they probably should have spent mlre time making sure everything was completed instead. Hopefully next time won't be so bad.

Negative... Hot wings milk tasted like greasy popcorn butter was poured on it. Even when I suggested it was the wrong sauce they redid it and same taste. Cheese for salad is kept off the bar so no one knows andnyoy have to ask for it...weird. no ketchup... little kids always want ketchup. It's dirty. Positive...staff friendly and close to skyzone and the price was okay.

Lily was cashier she smiled when I walked in and was such a sweet lady. When I asked about senior discount She said she hated to ask if I was old enough for senior discount she said I didn't look that old when i told her yes I'm 57. But she gave me the meal for $3.99 buffet. I believe it is a internet coupon. I told her thank you very much. That at regular price I was short by 50cents. Pizzas all looked good. I got small Salad with banana peppers and pickles. Of course banana peppers were for pizza. I got a few thick breaded pizzas slices. And a bowl of extra sauce. Only problem is I couldn't eat all of it. I have to take most bread off pizzas due to gastric bypass and can't have that much bread. But I could bearly eat one piece even with added toppings from other slices. Just wish my stomach was as big as my eyes.. the tables were clean and when I asked Lily told me where the knives were . I don't eat out much when I go to Evansville Indiana but every now & again. Other employees that I had contact with were nice and smiling. Thank you Lily for allowing me to enjoy some good Cicis Pizza.

I had not eaten there in years, so this past week we went in for dinner. The energy of the restaurant was gone. No welcome to Cicis when you walked in. Everyone looked like robot zombies. It's not the same as I remember. Unclean, food was a mess, workers had no energy or care and the prices went up. Lesson learned we'll go to Gattitown from now on.