Sammy's Bbq & Catering
1709 5th St - Eureka
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2025
2024
2021
#72 of 120 restaurants in Eureka
Updated on
€€
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
65/100
Data Completeness
67/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
🚚
Delivery
🥡
Takeout
🍽️
Dine-in
🍺
Alcohol
📅
Reservations
♿
Wheelchair accessible
♿
Accessible restroom
😊
Casual
👥
Good for groups
📊 Popular Times
Not busy
Moderate
Very busy
📷 Photos (8)
Photo 1 / 8
100%
Google Reviews
368
Google reviews
Always good and very prompt service and fair price
Google
The Tri Tip sandwich and fries were quite filling. The TriTip was extremely tasty it's melts in your mouth literally! I'm a weirdo though I don't like meat with fat so I had to cut the fat off the edges of the meat. I was really craving a fountain drink (Dr. PEPPER) I don't drink soda often but when I go to a restaurant for lunch I typically do especially when taking a break from yard work, so that was a little disappointing they had a odd drink selection. The dining area is very basic with a few pictures of Eureka High Football teams that were successful. Along with a few pictures of relatives who played college football and even NFL football! I'm curious where they BBQ at? Another BBQ restaurant in town Grills the meat right outside and the smell is INCREDIBLE! I don't recall ever smelling BBQ or seeing the smoke coming from Sammy's. They also provide catering services too! They have a restaurant in Arcata as well.
Read more
Google
It was so empty the both times I went but the portions they give you for the price is worth it.
Google
Amazing chicken teriyaki and pineapple coleslaw!!! My husband had the pineapple meatballs and potato salad and was also impressed. Good sized portions that filled us up.
Google
I love Sammy's. I have been going there since they opened. The BBQ is excellent.. love the flavors at Sammy's.
I'm a real fan of the Pulled Pork and the pineapple slaw. So good. Sammy's is wonderful for the community. We love him and all he does. Sports theme inside. I very Happy to see him open after the pandemic.
Thank God he stayed..
Thank you Sammy.
Read more
Google
Oh. My. GOSH!!!!
This place has, hands down, the best macaroni salad I have ever had. And their rangoons are so creamy, light, and perfectly crispy. A pleasant surprise from the menu. The chicken is always melt-in-your-mouth tender. My only complaint, perhaps, is that my tri-tip is usually cold. But delicious anyways!
Dont forget their bbq sauce too. Super sweet, tangy, and delicious!
Read more
Google
OMG!! My husband I have been stuck home for days so as you can imagine we've ordered alot of takeout.we had lost faith between the high prices and the mediocre food (long wait, not hot). And then today we got SAMMY'S!! What a HUGE difference. Thank you for the awesome food.
Google
Excellent food, helpful staff and I love the sweet chili sauce. My go to options are Combo #1 with tri-tip or teriyaki chicken. Pineapple meatballs are excellent as well. Coleslaw is delicious!
Google
The ribs were almost fall off the bone tender. The Kalua pork was juicy and tender. The tri-tip was done medium and tender. All three meats had a light smoke flavor. The Teriyaki Chicken was the best of show, tender and the most flavor. The potato salad was good but on the eggy side. The pineapple coleslaw is different and I liked it, it's not made with mayo but is more tropical with just the pineapple juice. The french fries are the frozen variety, barely ok. The price was good, and we would definitely come back.
Read more
Google
Amazing entrees, sides, service is awesome and food so fresh and fast. I love the potato salad! Tri tip and kahlua pork are juicy and tender, perfect. My dad loves the pineapple meatballs, and whole family was stoked about the chicken teriyaki and coleslaw with pineapple juice.
Google
Explore more in Eureka
Help improve this page: