Cookies Cookies

I was searching for a non-fastfood, non-diner place to get a banana split after 6pm. It's not on their menu, but the frozen banana ad on their window made me think to go in ans ask. It's got a great 'mom and pop' feel, and they worked with me to get me what I wanted, letting me know that they didn't really have a legitimate dish to serve it in - which was fine with me. Best banana split I've had in a long time ( I picked the wacky animal cracker icecream and the strawberry shortcake icecream) - and they only charged me $4.25. I'm going back here again, just on principle!

Best cookies I’ve ever had! I’ve been going here since I was a child! I have worked in the baking industry before and still never had cookies as good. My favorite are the sugar cookies and chocolate chip. Not only are they delicious they are cheaper than competitors. When people tell me they like crumbl I laugh cause they are so bad compared to the cookies at Cookies Cookies!

I don’t normally write reviews but I had to. I special ordered cookies for my son’s birthday. They were terrible. I spoke on the phone with Karen twice, text and sent pictures. She knew what I wanted and assured me she could do it, it was not complicated. After calling me three times to change when the cookies would be ready just hours before the agreed upon pick up time I was told they could have them ready 30 minutes late. When I quickly looked at the cookies in the shop I told her they were not what I was expecting. She told me they took a lot of time and were close to what I wanted. Feeling guilty I paid for the preordered cookies and went to my car. After looking at them again and seeing how awful they were I went back in to talk to her. They cookies were huge squares and rectangles instead of sugar cookie cut outs she specifically said they would do and with the wrong colors. I was told it took a lot of time and was hard to do more colors. The frosting, not royal icing like agreed upon was sloppy. When I told her how unhappy I was she said she did her best and offered me $5. She also said I should be happy because she should have charged me more for the cookies. I told her that would have been fine. I would have rather paid more for cookies I wanted instead of $42 for cookies I threw in the trash. She acted as though she did me a favor instead of fulfilling an order that was being paid for. She also told me it would have been different if I came into the shop instead of calling placing the blame on me. When I questioned how that would have made a difference she didn’t have an answer. They didn’t care about my order or special occasion. They ran out of time and quickly threw together garbage for me. To top it off the cookies didn’t even taste good. Do NOT order cookies here! Biggest was of money.