Reviews of The Eldred Preserve

My friends and I went out for some holiday celebratory drinks and apps. We had heard amazing things about this place and they were all true. Big shoutout to Melissa who was our server last night! She was so attentive and wonderful; made our very first experience there fantastic. The chef that evening was amazing as well. The food was to die for. Highly highly recommend this place. 5 stars all the way.

The is the absolute best place to stay in Sullivan County. We did not have one complaint about our stay. The rooms are cozy, clean, and beautifully decorated. The property is stunning with an amazing trail around the lake. The staff is friendly and very accommodating, especially Albrusha who went out of her way to help us book the perfect room for us. Will definitely be staying here again!

The Eldred Preserve is a beautiful location. I have attended private events as well as dinners here on my own part. I have always been impressed with the cleanliness and the great attitudes of staff. The dining room is a grand location while the grounds are expansive. I have seen the hotel rooms which are beautiful but I have not stayed here yet. Good team in Scott, Katie and Irvin.

Had dinner at the homestead restaurant. MARCIA was a great waitress. Very attentive. The food was delicious, well prepared, tasty and fresh. The chef came out to see how we were doing! The pastry chef made a delicious cake for my birthday. The grounds are beautiful and we had a double rainbow appear to make the evening perfect!

Gorgeous establishment and beautiful grounds. Definitely has a lot of wow factor on the look. Excellent service with a beautiful bar. The live piano is a fantastic touch. I wish I could have had my wedding here! Lovely menu. Giving it 4 stars as we felt dishes were a bit under seasoned but they were otherwise beautifully cooked. I’ve now had the duck, the farm to table trout, the tuna steak, sliders, clam dip or something similar, fries, and fantastic coconut shrimp. Will be back a third time and more because there’s nothing like it in the area for a romantic and beautiful night out.

This past Thursday, August 25,2022 we visited Eldred for the first time in 25 years. What a pleasant surprise! The place was completely redone, the grounds are beautiful and elegant. We had dinner at the Homestead restaurant: delicious and beautifully prepared. The best part was our waitress Jackie, a warm and wonderful young lady who made us welcome with a great smile on her face. The whole thing was a great experience especially because Eldred is a big part of many pleasant memories from the past. ❤️👍

Accommodations were excellent. This was our second time there staying in a Junior Suite. We visit the Catskills every year and were thrilled when The Bradstan opened. Wonderful breakfast as well, everything made in house. We’d like to give a shout out to our housekeeper, Martin, for keeping our room clean and well stocked. The restaurant (Homestead) was very good, great steaks and duck. Excited to go back next summer when the pool is open.

I absolutely love this hotel and restaurant. We have been here three times now and I have yet to be disappointed. This weekend we celebrated our five year wedding anniversary and the staff did a wonderful job setting up our room with all kind of goodies. The only thing that is a negative in my eyes is the price. We just can't afford to stay in the hotel. The rooms are $500 a night sometimes more...that just doesn't work for us, especially during the winter the rooms are still $400+. That is a shame because we would definitely stay more often if the prices were lower . I not really sure why the cost is so high but it is what it is. Eldred thank you ...maybe we will stay again in another year or so.

We didn't stay at the hotel, we only went to eat at the restaurant for my husband's birthday. We sat outside, it was beautiful and peaceful. The staff was incredibly friendly and professional, and the food was delicious. We dealt with a number of staff during our visit, due to the occasion, and everyone was so genuinely pleasant and courteous. They went out of their way to make sure our visit was an exceptional experience. Our first time at Eldred was incredible and we are looking forward to going back again!

My wife and I were looking for a place where we could just disconnect for a while. We just wanted somewhere that we can drive to and just relax. About 2 1/2 away we stumbled on The Eldred Preserve and the Bradstsn Boutique Hotel. We were absolutely blown away with this property. Our cabin was perfect and the staff was amazing. Our breakfasts were made special by Louba who was aware that my wife had a gluten free sensitivity. She went high and above to please her. The Restaurant was beautiful with amazing views of the preserve All I can say is if your looking for a place away from the hustle and bustle this is the place. Look no further. 20 minutes from the historic Woodstock site this is nestled in the middle of a beautifully maintained Preserve. I would give it more than 5 stars if I could. We have stayed in some beautiful places. This stacks up with the best of them.

Food is always delicious and service is usually incredible. However last night we Called for reservations, and when we arrived we were informed only the lounge is open due to the winter hours. However we weren’t advised of that on the phone. We sat in the lounge and didn’t receive service for over 20 minutes even though there were only two other tables taken. However once we were served the wine was great and the food was delicious. I believe last night was a mishap as they seemed to be short staff and confused but I highly recommend the Eldred preserve to everyone!