Andrew Negron
What an amazing vibe. I feel like I in a different world here. This might not be the most important thing to everyone, but the over medium egg sandwich is one of a kind. The bacon? Prefect! The roll? Like it came right out of the oven. And an over medium egg is a hard cook to get perfect. But every time I get one it's on the money. Thank you guy.
Kenny Tax (Long Island Foodies)
Had the opportunity to have dinner setauket diner. As diners go this has got to be my new favorite.
They had a special spanakopita. It tasted homemade and absolutely delicious. It came with a side of rice and grilled. It was large enough for a meal.
I ordered a sicilian panini, which was grilled chicken, red roasted peppers and mozzarella. Sometimes when places will grill chicken they tend to dry them out but this one was perfectly moist.
Kenny got a chicken quesadilla. He asked for a buffalo and they gladly accommodated his request.
Gabby got a turkey sandwich. It was huuuge. It was enough for 2 meals and this girl can eat.
The owner came over a few times to check to make sure it was ok, and he was so personable and nice. I will be back this week. It was great!
Paul L
Went at 6pm on a Tuesday. Really was delicious. Pastrami Reuben, and chicken marsala plus tasty extras. We’re going to come back regularly.
VANESSA SOVIERO
This absolutely is my favorite place to eat with my family. The owner Gus is just the nicest. He greets and sits every customer. He walks around and talks to everyone at their tables. It’s like old school service. His food is delicious and always fresh. And the chicken lemon rice soup… the best!!!! It’s clean and I love that he treats all his staff well and with respect. I highly recommend this family diner.
PJ Visconti
Love the SETAUKET DINER. Great food, great. Service and when you go, say hi to the owner Constintine
dino bot
Had breakfast for dinner. It could not be any better. Friendly service. Can not wait to go back and try dinner.
Robert Schaefer
Took grand kids to lunch. Very nice staff and service
John Mcgrath
The owner is amazing person. He takes the time to know his patrons. He makes you feel like family. The food is excellent and plenty full . I just love the place
Megan Thayer
Super clean diner.
Great food and friendly service.
Really happy with the food!
Olga Komargodski
The service was superb and the owner went above and beyond to make us feel welcome. I had the egg white omelette with vegetables that was scrumptious. The kids loved the smiley face pancakes with the side of fruit.
albert tirrito
Stopped in on a whim. While it doesn’t advertise organic or non-GMO ingredients, which is what I was really looking for, I had a nice time. The food was good, service was good and the owner was super nice. I'd come back, for sure! The burgwr wasn't perfect, but it was tasty. The fries (wavy), crunchy pickle and great coleslaw were a pleasant surprise. The burger was under seasoned and over cooked, BUT - it tasted like beef and it was sufficiently good. However, my wife has a lot of food sensitivities, but she survived without any issues! A great positive meaning the quality of their ingredients are excellent. Like I said, I will surely be back and nothing was so wrong that I can't chalk up to new staff or a bad day. I gave them 4 stars, being optimistic for the next visit.
Jim Radzom
The Dallas is the best burger in Three Villages. Great staff, great food easy to miss! It's a storefront diner between Walgreens and Starbucks. Make a visit!
Tara E Toolan
The owner greets one, immediately. Old school! Love this place! We had excellent drinks, bloody was outrageous, and my entree was AMAZING! PERFECTLY CRISPY SALMON, AND SHRIMP OVER GREENS. We had a superb server: attentive, personal, funny and a redhead. Thanks for a great dine!!! We highly recommend!!!
Peter Bukowski
Great food and friendly staff.
Gregory of the NATSARIM the elect
One of the best diners on long island... prices are very low food quality very high..service perfect...DEFINATLY EAT THERE.check it out
Anthony O'Brien
What a treat... We have seen this little here for years and have never stopped until recently!
What a gem. The service was wonderful and the owner was as friendly as could be! The food was delicious and the portion size was larger then expected and 1/2 was taken home and was dinner! It seemed slightly higher then the larger diners on the Southshore but that is to be expected for the area. We will be returning!
NoNo NoNo
Setauket Village Diner is just about my favorite reason for living in this area. I've been coming here for many decades and have found a consistently cheerful, comfortable atmosphere and superb food that's so generous, I take home enough for a second meal. The menu has items I can't find anywhere else. May they stay busy forever!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes