Reviews Red Tomato

5
Jessica Btesh
+5
The worst thing about this place is that. THE BREAD IS SO GOOD I CANT STOP EATING IT!!! I order pizza from here often, but even the sandwiches and salads are good enough to literally eat every day. I’ve never tasted dough like theirs. I love the staff, Irene is always there and so sweet and welcoming. The space is clean and the decor is awesome. #selfienation Definitely recommend!
5
GJ Raivel
+5
So yummy! Passed by this place on Northern millions of times and finally decided to go in. Glad we did...super good food and lovely staff. Gorgeous decor and very comfortable seating too!
5
Greg M
+5
Found this gem after a hike at Muttontown Preserve. Had an excellent wood fired margarita pizza with cauliflower crust and the tomato basil soup. The setting is more upscale than a pizzeria and the prices reflect it, but worth a little extra. Will go back to try more of the extensive menu items.
5
Kevin Michalski
+5
I actually really loved the pizza I got here. Delicious sauce and the pizza dough was on point (not too crunchy, not too chewy). For dessert we tried the nutella + marshmallow pizza, which tasted so good but is big enough to serve 8 people! Prices are okay, ~$14-16 for a personal 12'' pizza.
4
Arbër Shehu
+4
Cozy place and it feels warmly. They have a lot of variety of food to chose from. Mostly Italian dishes. Picked a pizza for myself. The pizza itself was good, however it felt a little bit too much crust and not that much toppings. The staff was a bit confused, not sure who was taking orders, who was cooking and who was serving. With a little bit of improvements this place can be 5 star restaurant for pizza and comfort food.
5
Nicky Mazz
+5
This pizzeria is world class. True brick oven pizza. Try them all, u can’t go wrong. This place is a must if ur a pizza fan. Worth the trip.
5
Joe Finger
+5
Was craving pizza and always wanted to try this place and boy it did not disappoint. The ambiance, friendly staff and cleanliness was more than I expected. The dough was so fluffy and perfectly baked. Our waitress was so sweet and patient, especially with us having 3 kids. Everything was made fresh and I will definitely be coming back and making this part of my weekly pizza Fridays. Cant wait to try more stuff on the menu.
4
taylor banasiak
+4
Place is pretty good. The owner or whoever he is thinks he's better than everyone else. News flash don't act you're better because at the end of the day you need us.
5
jyoti lekhi
+5
Cozy ambience with the most delicious garlic bread with ricotta cheese to start our experience. We tried 2 of the pizzas and one salad, everything was tasting just so good. Had to compliment the chef and found that their pizza dough gets imported from Italy. No wonder the flavor was so rich and so worthy.
5
Brooke Vetter
+5
Really enjoyed the special attention and quality of our entrees tonight! Pizza was super Neapolitan authentic and the staff was really nice to our table. (awesome salads too! 😊)
5
Mike Morrison
+5
Fantastic experience! If you want excellent food, this is definitely the place to find it. Watching the chef use the wood fired oven while enjoying a glass of wine is beyond delightful. If you like authentic italian cuisine served in the atmosphere of a modern Italian bistro, you will not be disappointed. If I could give this place 6 stars, I would. The Saturday afternoon lunch was even better than the weekday. The atmosphere is so warm and comfortable you might not want to leave.
5
Wendy Cespedes
+5
Went here for the first time yesterday for dinner. The food and service was absolutely phenomenal. Legitimately the best brick oven pizza restaurant around, with a variety of options! The tartufo pizza is by far my absolute favorite!
5
Kyle Ponsiek
+5
Awesome food, very clean looking now. Before it was just a mess. John the new owner is doing a fantastic job, Keep up the good work!
5
Jim Tamburino
+5
A hidden upscale gem under new ownership with the best pizza on Long Island. Great staff & service! Great food! Our new spot!
4
Serenity Hart
+4
Came here for a double date night a few months ago! The music selection was a little weird and customer service wasn’t the best but we loved the food and left happy overall. Food is fresh and prices are decent.