Best Restaurants in East Islip

Discover 67 restaurants with browsable menus, verified reviews and prices. Complete guide updated December 2025.

⭐

79/100

Avg Rating

🍴

15

Cuisine Types

20 of 67 restaurants

Sort: ⭐ Top Rated 💬 Popular 💰 ↑ 💰 ↓

Lennons

Lennons

💬 387 reviews

📍 148 Carleton Ave

7-eleven

7-eleven

💬 16 reviews

📍 197 Montauk Hwy

Ralph's Italian Ices

💬 213 reviews

📍 54 W Main St

Francesco's Trattoria

Francesco's Trattoria

💬 499 reviews

📍 234 E Main St

Buttermilk's Chicken

Buttermilk's Chicken

💬 300 reviews

📍 93 E Main St

Shandon Court

American Irish Bar

💬 1057 reviews

📍 115 E Main St

Starbucks

💬 460 reviews

📍 2550 Sunrise Hwy

Gio's Pizzeria

Gio's Pizzeria

💬 441 reviews

📍 213 Carleton Ave

Pat's Marketplace

Pat's Marketplace

💬 290 reviews

📍 300 E Main St

East Islip Deli

East Islip Deli

💬 38 reviews

📍 217 Carleton Ave

Vinnie's Mulberry Street

Vinnie's Mulberry Street

💬 1092 reviews

📍 15 W Main St

Bagel Brunch Cafe

Bagel Brunch Cafe

💬 47 reviews

📍 217 Carleton Ave

Blue Line Deli & Bagels

Blue Line Deli & Bagels

💬 30 reviews

📍 217 Carleton Ave

Isabella's Pizza

Isabella's Pizza

💬 211 reviews

📍 142 Connetquot Ave

Fatty Mc Gees

Fatty Mc Gees

💬 504 reviews

📍 138 Connetquot Ave

Renzos Pizza Restaurant

Renzos Pizza Restaurant

💬 221 reviews

📍 314 E Main St

Yan Min Kitchen

Yan Min Kitchen

💬 134 reviews

📍 97 E Main St

Pudgie's Famous Chicken

💬 16 reviews

📍 126 Montauk Highway

Jackson Hall

💬 1611 reviews

📍 335 E Main St

Sun Rise Kitchen

Sun Rise Kitchen

💬 97 reviews

📍 207 Carleton Ave

🍴

Explore by Cuisine Type

American 10 Italian 7 Pizza 7 Bar 5 Pub 4 Deli 3 Chinese 2 Irish 2 Seafood 2 Asian 1 Cafe 1 Campania 1 European 1 Neapolitan 1 Southern-Italian 1

Why Trust Sluurpy

Aggregated and verified data from multiple sources

📊

0 Reviews Analyzed

🏆

0 Top Restaurants

📋

26 Browsable Menus

📅

Dec 2025 Last Updated