The best Cakes in East Islip | Sluurpy updated in June

Stanley's Bakery

89/100 (745 ratings)

Quick Bites

Dessert

Bakeries

Breakfast

Bagels

Cakes

Wheelchair Accessible

Takeout

Breakfast

Mid-range

"75 Years old and not a day over 21 😉 Delicious treats, wonderful service and worth the trip. Their prices are also still based on reality, not..."

NYCEllieMonster

"I went to this bakery for the first time on Sunday. The best pastries I have ever tasted. I will be going there very soon. So much variety too. Never..."

Dianne Dileo

"This was our first time trying this bakery for a cake order. I was so pleased that we were able to get the cake order in for July 3rd. A lot of..."

Brittany Espinosa

"My Wedding Cake was made from here 41 years ago and still amazing after all this time, my personal favorite is there cinnamon raisin bread besides..."

Joyce S

"Their staff is very helpful an some are very New ,i asked for one of their superior jelly donut an to my suprise it turned out to be a Boston Cream,..."

Karl Snyder

"I always get cakes for my kids birthdays here and other family events. They make delicious cakes, and when I had to cancel an order they honored my..."

Sabrina Goss

"Absolutely love this place. Many different options, a great breakfast sandwich, and the best jelly donuts I have tasted. Beyond that the staff was..."

Angel Rodriguez

"A fantastic, aromatic bakery. Open as early as 6am. Perfect for a quick cup of coffee and hot bread. They have delicious pastries, bread and..."

Michael Harold

"It's 3 blocks from my sister's house. Always great stuff there. The apple crumb horseshoe is..."

Michael Horowitz

"Excellent bakery, assorted cookies, pastries, donuts and breads. I loved their canolis and Italian cookies. Highly..."

adrian monette

"Excellent place to pick up desserts for any occasion, and they are always a..."

Peter Devlin

"What’s not to love about a great bakery.... fresh baked goods, delicious fragrances and wonderful treats! Been going to Stanley’s for years and..."

Glenn

"I called ahead for a rainbow cake for a friend's bd. It was all ready when I arrived to pay and pick up. Social distancing measures are in place to..."

Jacki Barnum

"Amazing old school Bakery! The tastes of my youth abound. Simply the best jelly donuts and French crullers available. The baked goods are only..."

Ford Trojanowski

"It can get a bit busy inside. Otherwise, they have great..."

Billy Fornaro

"GREAT Bakery, the cheesecake is some of the best I've ever had. The breakfast sandwiches are excellent and the cake and cookie selection at this..."

Sam Viemeister

"Best pastries and amazing people that worked..."

Reset

There is only one restaurant

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Cakes in East Islip

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters