Best Restaurants in Eagle Bay

⭐ Top

★ 93 /100

View →

The Donut Shop

American

💬 374 reviews

📍 5474 County Route 28

📋 Menu ⭐ Top

★ 91 /100

View →

Big Moose Station

American Bar Pub

💬 363 reviews

📍 2138 Big Moose Rd

🍴

⭐ Top

★ 90 /100

View →

The Eagle Bay House

💬 3 reviews

📍 5521 NY-28

★ 90 /100

View →

The Little Fox

American

💬 318 reviews

📍 1910 Big Moose Rd

🍴

★ 87 /100

View →

The Tavern

💬 93 reviews

📍 5520 Rt-28

📋 Menu

★ 86 /100

View →

Big Moose Inn And Restaurant

American Bar Seafood

💬 345 reviews

📍 1510 Big Moose Rd

★ 86 /100

View →

Toboggan Inn

American Bar Pub

💬 187 reviews

📍 5521 State Route 28

★ 82 /100

View →

The Bay Cafe

Cafe

💬 49 reviews

📍 5560 County Route 28

🍴

★ 70 /100

View →

Twister's Ice Cream

📍 5560 State Route 28