Reviews Pizzaiolo Gourmet Eatery

4
Joe Lucchesi
+4
I travel regularly to try pizza as its one of my favorite foods to get. This place was a solid 4.0 out of 5 for me. A 5 being Johns of Bleeker, and Lucali in my opinion. I found their pizza to have a great crust, little flop and made with good tomatoes and cheese. Fairly priced and very friendly staff. I will definitely return, Came back few days later and got served a cold specialty slice and a barley cooked regular slice. So I guess this place is just hit or miss or depends on who serves you. Such a shame because it can be very good.
5
lawrence kauffman
+5
Fantastic people, food, and setice--and great ambient music playing at all times!! You have something for everybody here, from pasta and chicken or veal to seafood. Just great, classy service and atmosphere. Today was only my first visit--but certainly not my last!!!
5
Marianne Oliva-Pavlat
+5
Thank you for participating in “Pizza Strong”, by donating to help Those affected by the Farmingdale bus tragedy. Your food and pizza are delicious .. your staff is always so kind and you are an incredible community business . You are always ready to help . Thank you
5
Rich Rettino
+5
Been there once the Sicilian slice with cheese on bottom was great, I usually go to deerpark ave pizziola I think your location has better pizza
4
Rob A
+4
Food is good, but beware of no menu prices listed other than for pizza, which is a bit dodgy. Might as well just put "Market Price" (Sarcasm). You may want to ask the price before ordering or find another establishment that has prices posted. Taking the inflation thing a little further than can be justified. Not looking to fund their early retirement. Feb 2023.
4
Bruce C
+4
One of the best round pizzas on Long Island. Loved the crust. When I went inside to pick up my pizza it was like I'm invisible. All the help was walking around or on their phones while I'm standing at the counter waiting to get my order.
5
john c
+5
Had reservations about this place because I've never heard anyone speak of it before. Turns out, I finally found a good pizza in commack. Perfectly cooked, great crust and sauce and plenty of interesting specialty pies. After years of disappointment, we've finally found a great spot. 3 stars for atmosphere because it's just a pizzaria. Wouldn't take a date here, though it's perfectly fine to take your wife. It was spotlessly clean too.
5
Joseph “JStars” Staropoli
+5
I ordered a white slice, I got a white slice. It was really, really good. The ricotta was light and seasoned, the mozzarella was perfectly proportioned and the dough was slightly crispy on the bottom with a doughy/fluffy crust. I really enjoyed this slice. Not everyone makes the white slice properly so when I find the ones that do, I have to compliment them.
5
Frank Antonelli
+5
We have been going to Pizzaiolo for years. Always tasty food and great service. This is my go to pizza place in Commack. Best garlic knots and pepperoni chips around. Highly recommend this place.
5
Carla Carvalhao
+5
Many different types of pizzas to choose from. Delicious!!!
5
Adam Holtzer
+5
I am happy to write this 5 star review. This establishment takes pride in their customer service, quality of food and most of all meeting my expectations. I have been ordering from Pizzaiolo for about a year now. Their food is delicious, my family and I love it. The prices are reasonable, their menu has many options and they are a local small business. I endorse these 5 stars. Plus my daughter loves their sauce and enjoys picking up dinner with daddy lol.
5
Robert Tanner
+5
John and the staff are great. They always have what I want and serve it with courtesy and a big smile. A pleasure to eat there or take out.****
5
Alberto Hernandez
+5
Best pizza around Commack that will cover all
5
Tom Ehlers
+5
We brought our soccer team here last night for a birthday party for one of the players. The owner and staff could not have been more accommodating. We had pizza and garlic knots and everything was delicious! It is so nice to have places like this in the community that care about the families and the community.