My page
Exit
×
×
Reset
There are 124 restaurants
Cuisine
Dietary restrictions
Meals
Structure
Dishes
Home
Restaurants in United States
Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Columbus
There are 124 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Mama's Pasta N Brew
97
/100 (130 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
American
Dinner
Lunch
B & B Pizza & Spaghetti
95
/100 (601 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
"We love this neighborhood pizza shop--delicious pizza and friendly..."
Amanda Powell
"I grew up on this pizza! My family has always loved B&B, when I was in high school my family moved right down the road from B&B- my friend and I..."
Elizabeth Rohrbaugh
"LOVE THIS PLACE MY KIDS WOULD EAT IT EVERYDAY… THE CUSTOMER SERVICE IS GREAT NEVER HAD TO RAISE MY VOICE TO THEM UNLIKE (OHIO STATE PIZZA) ALL I..."
jessica robinson
"We tried this place tonight. It was very good! We had a 16" pizza sub, a 16" garlic bread, and a 16" pizza that was half pepperoni, extra cheese,..."
Shane J
"I have zero complaints and that is a rarity for today’s restaurants and my standards. They do a great job! A tad pricey but in this case you get..."
Dawn Young
"Stopped by a couple days ago at lunch time and tried the Philly roast beef sub.... OUTSTANDING!! The roast beef was so tender, sub bun was toasted..."
Brian B
"Food was really good. Not a sit down establishment, so no atmosphere. Friendly staff, and order was completed quickly for a busy time of the..."
Eric Zimerla
"This new location is much smaller, but the food is just as good as it was at the old Weber Road location!!! THANK YOU FOR NOT COMPROMISING ON THE..."
V L Brown
"My mouf to stomach connection is coated with happiness. I strayed away from Ol Susie for a while... But today I was drawn back in...for pepperoni......"
missbree
"Always great service and food they treat you like old friends even if they don't know..."
Raymond Gochenouer
"These people are great- food “ THE BOMB… keep up the great work and keep serving great food- that bbq chicken pizza… make you want to “SLAP..."
Frankie Legg
"LOVE this mom & pop pizza & sub shop. Pizzas are amazing & love the pot roast style Philly cheesesteak subs. Always consistent quality &..."
Hannah M
"The best subs in Columbus, Ohio. It's the only place I get my subs. The pizza is great, too. If you don't like your crust crispy, I suggest ordering..."
Karen Brantley
"Great people, and the food is of great quality. My family has been using them for 2 years now, we quit using big company pizza places because their..."
Frost Jack
"Great subs for a great price! It's very popular with a lot of regulars..."
Joseph Dykes
"Great place for take out or delivery. They are really nice and friendly people. Also the prices are very..."
Charles Gilley
"Quick hook up and phat sandwich's! The kids love their pizza as..."
Rayna Williams
La Tavola
94
/100 (1445 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Shrimp
Pasta
Salad
Risotto
Polenta
Tiramisu
Meatballs
Pesto
Pork
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Takeout
Dinner
Mid-range
"One of the best restaurants I have ever visited. The food is universally next-level amazing, the staff is friendly, professional, and attentive, and..."
Brendan Kelley
"We loved everything. The food is fresh and choices are unique. We loved the menu choices. The homemade pasta was the best ever. The soup was..."
Darla Kaikis
"Cannot get over this place. Considering previous restaurants that I have given five stars to, La Tavola deserves 6. Everything was INCREDIBLE from..."
Megan Marie
"Lovingly made Italian food, no short cuts taken, no cheap ingredients. Easily one of the best restaurants in Columbus and one that could compete in..."
Johnny DiLoretto
"I cannot say enough good things about La Tavola. The food is absolutely amazing, and everyone who works there is super cool. Be sure to make..."
Scott Treadwell
"Great meal tonight. Love watching the staff work together like an intricate dance that is flawless. Warm greeting, sincere service and a delicious..."
Katie Rich
"This place is the bomb. Amazing food, wonderful owners. So lucky to have this gem in our..."
Megan McDermott Stanley
"La Tavola (spell check got the best of me the first time) is like traveling to Italy to eat at your grandma’s home (I imagine....). Any time we..."
Jessica Raye Kocak
"I was very enthused to go and celebrate the upcoming birthday of my brother's wife with he and my mother and of course the the guest of honor, my..."
Joseph Ryan
"Wonderful experience sitting at bar that overlooks kitchen! Food was delicious and service was outstanding! Especially the host who got us great..."
Chris Sypult Stach
"The best Italian Restaurant in Columbus from the service to the quality and originality of their menu and..."
Jim Price
"My husband and I went to celebrate our 3 "years since I said yes,engaged Anniversary". A wonderful excuse to try a great restaurant. It was charming..."
Leslie Lowe Faw
"I had many times Italian restaurants in north end(Italian district)—Boston and loved it. Now I have to admit, this Italian restaurant is even..."
Zhe Deng
"Absolutely amazing! Simple. Fresh. Delicious Walk-in diners wound up on patio bc the restaurant was at capacity. Best decision ever - the weather was..."
Summa Simmons
"THE ONLY ITALIAN PLACE I'VE EVER WANTED TO GO BACK TO. ✔️ Delicious seasonal specials ✔️ Fantastic service ✔️ Nice ambiance ✔️..."
H Y Wong
"It was my 59 birthday I really wanted fish but none without shrimp so where else ,I Always enjoy good Italian food .. the waiter so much energy and..."
A W
"We were looking for a local Italian restaurant and lucked out finding this gem. Service was great, recommendations were spot on and we will be coming..."
Stephan Karp
"I went to La Tavola with my partner and had an amazing experience. We split an app, two mains, and two desserts, and along with two drinks each and a..."
Naseem Dillman-Hasso
"Service was excellent. Food was delicious. You can watch them make food in the kitchen from your dining room..."
Jon Lotut
"Came here for husbands birthday dinner because he wanted chicken parm and this place filled his dream! A great Italian restaurant with delicious in..."
Victoria Tucker
"We have been going to La Tavola consistently for the past few years. The food is fantastic, which goes without saying. By far the best Italian food..."
John Snyder
"We normally try a different Italian place every month and this is one of my favorites. The service is always wonderful and the wine is fantastic. The..."
K Samana
Elby's At The Elks
94
/100 (55 ratings)
Restaurants
French
Italian
Steakhouse
American
Dinner
"We had the joy of capturing a wedding day here in 2021 and were very happy with the venue! The couple got married at a nearby church and had the..."
Clay House Photography
"Daughter had her wedding and wedding reception here excellent place. The workers were very friendly and helpful the place is..."
Donna Feraro heibel
"Just fine an..."
brenda grabill
"Finally had our wedding after several postponements and it was 100% amazing, loved working with the staff, Hillary, and the building itself was..."
Ashley Richardson
"Nice old time atmosphere. One of only three or four large meeting spaces in Columbus. Good Windows and an elevator for upper level location...."
Kenneth Kaiser
"Went to a wedding reception here, and I would absolutely host an event here in the future. This place is clean, and the brick combined with the..."
Samuel Gross
"A very nice facility. The acoustics are not great though. I think the air handler is noisy, making it difficult to hear..."
Scott McAfee
Lola & Giuseppe's Trattoria
93
/100 (1556 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Alfredo
Shrimp
Tiramisu
Beef
Meatballs
Cheesecakes
Lasagne
Lobster
Cannoli
Eggplant
Chicken Parmesan
Pasta
Carrot Cake
Salad
Bread Pudding
Risotto
Bruschette
Salmon
Pesto
Fish
Cheesecake
Sit down
Italian
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Takeout
Dinner
Mid-range
"Very nice! Give it a try. Decor is early Spartan, but that’s not important, look past it. Chef is owner. Had Caesar Salad w/anchovies! Croutons..."
Mark Salesses
"Went to L & G on the recommendation of my hotel receptionist and couldn't have been more happy. Small menu, but that's because everything is..."
Kirti Malhotra
" Need a reason to go to Gahanna? This is it. Lola, Joe and staff prepare home cooked Italian meals from their little kitchen. Many had to wait for a..."
Fennel Aspic
"Best Italian food in Columbus. Period.. I am a sauce snob. I admit it. I grew up in a family where my Italian immigrant grandparents made their own..."
Christinamzimmer
"Found this gem thanks to great reviews. Fabulous quaint Italian food. I had the lolas crepes. Mmmm mmmm!!! SauceWas creamy and I loved the..."
BDUB
"Excellenti Magnifico. Had a great dinner. Service was extremely friendly and food was yummy. Family of servers are very sweet and..."
Usfbullsfan
"Love Love Love this place! The food is amazing! The owners and staff are wonderful! Can't wait to go..."
Jessica
"I finally made it to Lola and "Joe's!" It was perfect. Lola takes you into her restaurant, a warm and inviting home with 42 chairs. The food is..."
It's Just Food
"Delicious Food & Great Service. My wife and I loved this place! The food is made fresh to order and it was delicious. Tonight, Lola made her extra..."
Bajmmyers111
"Amazing. Hands down the best spinach & artichoke dip I've ever tasted. Simply..."
FeedMyInnerFatKid
"Hidden Gem. The food and service here were excellent! Some of the best Italian I've ever had. The seating is very limited and I can imagine the wait..."
Paul
"Tiny restaurant with heaps of charm. I discovered this restaurant as a participating member of the AAdvantage Dining rewards program. I checked out..."
Leo Polak III
"What a wonderful date night!!!. This location is quaint, homey, and trendy!! It is eclectic, sweet, and just soo much more! My fiance and I truly..."
Phil
"Real Italian. Lola's is a very quaint, wonderful place to enjoy an incredible meal that truly reminded me of the meals we had when we were Italy a..."
Cupcake Queen
"Divine! Every bite was delicious! If you are looking for Authentic, homemade taste, this is it! Anna &..."
Aldo
"Small but Mighty. I travel a lot for work, and had been staying in the Columbus Area for awhile before I stumbled upon this place. The first time we..."
Julie
"Excellent food and service.. Authentic home style Italian meals with prompt friendly service. From the baked rogatoni to the bread pudding... truly..."
Carolyn
"Cozy mom and pop joint with traditional homestyle Italian done right. The shrimp fra diavolo delivered on heat...."
Travis
"I went to Lolas tonight with my mom for a quick dinner. And all I have to say is "wow". I honestly can say the spicy clam linguinie (made tonight..."
Jenna
"Love. This. Place. An Italian restaurant loud an proud! Not scared of flavor and a little heat! Great food and..."
Amart80
"Fresh food, lovely owner and atmosphere. Charming and..."
Jen
"Just ate here. Fantastic local restaurant, authentic fresh Italian fare. Great service and reasonably priced. Interesting menu and great specials...."
Jill Johnson
"Lola's has heart. Delicious, delicious, go here if you like food at all. I have never tasted anything from a restaurant that was prepared with..."
Amy
"Great food, nice cozy atmosphere. Food was some of the best Italian in Columbus. Everything appeared to be homemade and authentic down to the owners...."
Megan
"We were looking for a quality restaurant for our family at 8 at night and could only find fast food restaurants and chain bars that were far from..."
Anna Goddi
"Gahanna's Little Secret. Four of us had dinner to-night at Guiseppe and Lola's.We had a great meal, the staff couldn't have been nicer and we..."
Bartletc
"Oh my! Just like eating at my zias house. This place is like eating with your family . Quaint, pleasant atmosphere. Great Great Great! Don't tell..."
Paul W. Hogan II
"Good job!. Loved the old school decor. It felt cozy and like I was in my grandma's house. Good service and yummy dessert (best bread pudding I've..."
Kauf101
"This place is one of Gahanna's best kept secrets! Food is amazing and their carrot cake is the best I've had. Lola is an awesome hostess and Giuseppe..."
Crayzcray
"After living in big cities across the country, we moved to Columbus about 6 years ago, and have not had such a great quality meal for a reasonable..."
Andi Hollander Malinger
"Employee. From an insider's perspective with over 25 years of experience, I love working at Lola's. Her food, her attitude, and the atomsphere are..."
Concetta Whittington
"OMW!!!! We were in Ohio visiting friends, and wanted to go out for a nice dinner on our Anniversary. They suggested Lola's. WHAT A WONDERFUL..."
Schnitzel's Mom
"Everything was so good. Service was great and the food ..... If you don't go you're missing..."
Bill
"Love It!!. Best food ever!!! The owners are there every time we go. They are always very friendly and recommend what to try on the menu. You can tell..."
Mike
"You can't go wrong!. My friends and I decided to try a new restaurant tonight and we had a great time. The restaurant is very small, so there was a..."
Katharinemyers
"Fantastic meal. Crab cake appetizer was very good - almost all crab, very little filler. Creamy onion soup was excellent. Amazing spinach salad. The..."
Ben
"Hometown Favorite. Whether it's the pasta or pastries, everything from Lola's is made from scratch. You can't compare the fresh-tasting noodles from..."
Madcrazy916
"Wish I lived in Columbus. If I lived here I'd be a regular. Great creamy onion soup, ciopino, crabmeat crepes, and the garlic bread they bring to the..."
Jack Koff
"Exceptional!!!!. This is a must try restaurant!! Lola and Giuseppe make it a point of coming to say hello to their customers after making all of..."
Mdt73070
"I hope it stays a hidden gem. I love this place. The food is always fresh. It is so little and quaint and the owners are right there, walking around..."
Love To Eat
"Phenomenal. If you love onion soup, be forewarned: Once you try Lola's, you will never want another's again. Really. Creamy onion soup? Yes. I even..."
Gottaloveitornot
"The onion soup was "to die for" and the rest of our dinner was delicious (including the peanut butter creme brûlée). The atmosphere was quaint, the..."
Jennifer Freshwater Krohn
"Quaint atmosphere, nearly all the food is homemade and delicious. Lola herself came out and asked "how was my..."
Sarah
"Orgasm in a Bowl! The onion soup is AMAZING! It is THE Best! We are having dinner with our best friends and Lola's is wonderful! She's making a..."
Monica Neiderman
"Fantastic Food. I have tried this place on several occasions and the owners are so adorable. This is a small format restaurant with great..."
Charlie
"The first time I sampled the wedding soup it was the best version I have ever had. Afterwards, while I liked it each time, I could not reestablish..."
Jim Ellison
"Lola & Giuseppe’s is always a delight. The staff cares about their work and the establishment. The food always exceed expectations. For this visit,..."
Guillermo Taylor
"I’ve always wanted to try this Italian Place and my heart was overjoyed when I did. The service and staff was 10/10 the food was simply amazing...."
George Bolden
"Absolutely the best Italian food I have ever had. Highly HIGHLY recommend. They constantly refilled our drinks. Friendly staff. Manager came out and..."
Danielle Ayres
"I have never, and I mean never, been this impressed with a restaurant. My friend and I went in without knowing it was pretty much reservation only...."
Gina Gomez
"The location caught me off guard, but the food was insane! I'm only on my appetizers and Its already one of my favorite places!!! You must try this..."
Jap Family
"Visiting from out of state, came across this on google reviews…SO glad we tried it! Wonderful family dinner starting off with garlic bread and..."
Steven Butler
"We sat on the patio which was nice. I got the onion soup which was decadent. The shrimp & lobster ravioli was also fantastic. I don’t normally go..."
Sam Knight
"First time to eat here, as we have heard great things about it from others and came highly recommended. It definitely did not disappoint. Atmosphere..."
Jeff Janis
"Our first trip to Lola & Giuseppe's only left me wondering what took us so long to get here??! There are things that will turn people away but that..."
Steve Smyers
"First time visiting after years of wishing. The food was excellent! I ordered chicken marsala. Staff friendly and attentive. Will definitely return..."
J Caldwell
Martini Modern Italian
93
/100 (5329 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Asian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Late Night
Dinner
Bread Pudding
Salmon
Arancini
Panzanella
Lamb
Ribs
Noodle
Bruschette
Shrimp
Pesto
Fish
Beef
Polenta
Tiramisu
Torte
Pasta
Lasagne
Salad
Carbonara
Scallops
Tortellini
Calamari
Chicken Parmesan
Risotto
Tortelloni
Tuna
Prosciutto
Calamares
Sit down
Italian
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Television
Private Dining
Valet Parking
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Late Night
Dinner
Fine Dining
"Drinks are not watered down, the pasta is fresh and well seasoned. The bartenders are nice and know their drinks! The waitresses are pleasant and..."
Tiana Wallace
"If you're seeking a nice,upscale environment, this is it. It was a tad busy due to a large party of birthday guest, but,otherwise, timely service...."
Crystal Keller
"Went for our wedding anniversary celebration. Very nice decor. Our server was great, very friendly, and attentive. We had the Tenderloin and the..."
Jesus Hernandez
"The ambiance here gets an A+, and it's definitely suited for a special occasion. I've visited twice and had all positive experiences. Service is..."
Kessashun Arthur
"Atmosphere was really nice, food was really good too. I came by myself to grab a quick, nice dinner and I waited almost twice longer than I ate. For..."
Mateusz Bratko
"We took my MIL here for Mothers Day Brunch. The drinks were great and the food was great as well. Our server was super sweet and our order was..."
Cheryl Evans
"Martini was a fantastic place to dine and have drinks! I was in Ohio for 10 days and we ate here for 4 of them it was so great! Their lasagna was to..."
James Taylor
"Where can I start? Let's start with some honesty. I come from a restaurant family. I love trying new places with new or old ideas. I'll keep it..."
Richard Basini
"First time at Martini for my birthday, and it definitely lives up to the hype! HIGHLY recommend tuna tartare for the appetizer- wow. Food was..."
Zara A
"Favorite meal ever. Server was knowledgeable and friendly. Wonderful ambiance. Unique Italian..."
Jeffrey OConnell
Meister's Bar & Pizza Kitchen
92
/100 (668 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Mid-range
"One of the best bars & pizza spots I've ever been to in Columbus. Amazing tap beer selection. By far the best cheesy bread & deep dish pizza I've..."
Craig Bringman
"Great bar, amazing bar food. Pool, darts. Excellent bar service and the deep dish pizza may be the best in..."
Brandon Ritze
"This hidden gem you don't wanna miss out on. Thursday's are the best and the pizza is always amazing..."
Tyler Andrew Rich
"The best! Great people and great food and drinks! Love this..."
Don Harper
"Good times good service great pizza! Everyone should have the deep dish at least..."
Steven Stiewe
"Amazing is all I can say.... My wife and I our from Texas we ordered a purple motherf****er, they knew exactly what it was.. Fast service and amazing..."
ScrpionKng Adam
"Best bar / pizza / bar owner in town "bar" none..."
Dimitri N Mak
"Deep dish and cheesy bread are amazing!! People are much less pretentious than other bars in the..."
Justin King
"Love this place! Anytime I am in Columbus it's a must-stop. Love those..."
Phil Clark
"Best Pizza, pool tables and Patio. Bartenders are the best..."
Michelle Turner
"Such a great place! Always feel welcomed and not like most..."
Kalee Zaragoza
"Great place to hang out with friends. Good..."
Jenny Rhoades Millikin
"Beer. Pizza. TV. Within walking distance. What's not to..."
Karl Schosek
"This was our first time, and had great experience. We went for the deep dish pizza, which was every good. The bartender was very friendly. I would..."
Stuart Poe
"Are you looking for the classic bar atmosphere with pool and darts? How about a late night slice? What about that late night slice being the best..."
Kyle Ames
"The dive-iest of dive bars. Accidentally stumbled into this place while trying to kill some time before an errand, and I’m glad I did. The parking..."
Christopher Lackey
"I've been here several times. This last time was the busiest I've ever seen it! Found out at the time of this review that Thursdays are $1 beer..."
Josh Arnold
"I love the deep dish pizza here. There will be a bit of a wait, usually 30 to 45 minutes but it's worth it. They have some zesty sauce too, a little..."
Cory Morris
"You wouldn't think you'd find deep dish pizza at the back of a german-themed bar, but here we are. The pictures don't really do it justice, it's..."
Alex Broshious
"As divey of a bar as you can find. This hidden gem offers draft beer, canned seltzers, and any cocktail you can think of at a reasonable price. They..."
Ryan Garcia
"Huge fan of the deep dish pizza and the dive bar vibes that this place has. Been ordering pizza from here for years and it’s very..."
Benjamin Freeman
"A true dive bar on the edge of Grandview a few blocks from Lane Ave. Filled with day drinking 20 something year olds, getting hammered playing pool..."
Colin Flack
"OMG... Best damn deep dish pizza in all of Ohio! Seriously the best. ...and the cheesy garlic bread n marinara - to die for! Servers were very..."
Nathan Downing
Vino Vino
92
/100 (94 ratings)
Restaurants
Wine Bar
Italian
Italian
Dinner
Crab
Sit down
Italian
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Takeout
Dinner
Mid-range
"Loved the feel of the place. The food was great, the wine selection was very well done and the staff could not have been more friendly. A great place..."
Tod Bowen
"One of my favorite places in the city, a nice, typically quiet place for carefully selected food. It's good all days of the week although I prefer..."
Payton Seats
"This is not your average neighborhood bistro, Vino Vino is magnificent! We drove in from Cincinnati, for a 6PM reservation, on a Saturday night, and..."
Massage Hoi Polloi
"Was here for a post wedding dinner and our service for the small group was excellent. Staff were accommodating and did a great job making sure we..."
Joe
"The menu is to die for. I've probably eaten here 20 times and never eaten anything I didn't love. The people are typically very friendly and the..."
Megan Phelps
"This place without question deserves 5 stars. I'll give you 5 reasons: Good food, good wine, excellent service, nice atmosphere, and... uhhh... did I..."
Michael Emerick
"A quiet, cozy space to enjoy a great glass of wine or a light meal. Vino Vino allows the diner to enjoy all the fruits of the Figlio kitchen in a..."
Andrew P. Smith
"Get the scallop entree! Hands down the best scallops I have ever had. And a steal on the price! We love vino vino! Great wine, great food, great..."
Andrew Schmitt
"The food is excellent and reasonably priced. I always get good service. The restaurant is small and a little tight so I am often a little..."
Miller Cathy
"Food was very good. Left stuffed. Old time favorite from college. Could use some higher end wine options and flights. Great place for an affordable..."
Justin MCDONALD
"Great wine selection. Wonderful food. Great place to hang out for a special occasion or with some..."
April Ross
"The best fish tacos! They have this corn chowder dish that's..."
Jermaine Davis
"Small menu but great food. Nice wine..."
Zachary Huston
"Great food for the price. Awesome friendly service. Get the mushroom..."
Taylor Oberst
"Good wine list and great..."
Jane Heydinger
"I love it Quiet Clean Great food Great..."
Antonio Robertson
Forno Short North
92
/100 (3903 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Bar
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Vegan Options
Bar
American
Pizza
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Brunch
Drinks
Cheesecakes
Calamares
Salmon
Arancini
Pesto
Cheesecake
Tapas
Tacos
Shrimp
Toasts
Pasta
Chicken And Waffles
Salad
Waffles
Calamari
Meatballs
Risotto
Waffles & Crepes
Tuna
Sit down
Italian
Bar
Pizza
American
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Takeout
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Reservations
Accepts American Express
Accepts Discover
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Late Night
Drinks
Brunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"Great food and atmosphere. We had two pizzas and the goat cheese and red beet salad it was delicious! Nice beer and wine menu. Love the atmosphere..."
Jane Dean
"By far the best service I have ever had! Our waitress Bethany was phenomenal and made for the best birthday brunch I could've asked for. I will..."
Kara Savernik
"The food was great and the service was excellent. We had 4 different pizzas and each was good. The Brussel sprouts and root veggies were yummy! I..."
Missy Kabealo Lackey
"I had the Forno Pasta with the Homemade Meatballs and it was absolutely divine. This was my first experience here at this establish while visiting..."
Donté J. Young
"We go here all the time and it's the best brunch spot in columbus! Thy are super friendly and accommodating!..."
Stephanie Sciabarrasi
"Delicious!! Spiked strawberries were my favorite. Also, had calamari, chicken Alfredo pizza & strawberry rose cocktail. All were absolutely amazing...."
Nicole Legge
"Everything was great! Our server Bethany was awesome! Great place to..."
Tracey Freeman
"Great food, atmosphere, and fast, friendly service like usual...The arancini, calamari, and pizzas are top notch. One of our..."
Dennis Farkas
"Amazing food! Great atmosphere and outstanding customer service. Andrew is an outstanding server. Best arugula salad I have had in my life and the..."
Richard Avery
"One of my favorite spots to frequent! I love finding any reason to go and just enjoy the atmosphere. The goal is to become a regular and try their..."
Felishia “Fe Soleil” Morgan
"We got a bit of everything for my wife and son. We came at happy hour and it was awesome! The price of everything was phenomenal, had great happy..."
Cesar Santamaria
"Great birthday brunch in the private room! I had the chicken and waffles, shrimp and grits and some pizza! The music was great too just wish they had..."
Ambershaun Byrd
"We went here on a Monday night and it was surprisingly busy! Our group had different pizzas and salads. They were all delicious. The prosciutto was..."
Chelsea Evans
"Visited on a Sunday night with a reservation but probably didn’t need one. The wait staff was very kind and the atmosphere was definitely radiant..."
Brianna Ridenour
"Forno easily makes the list for having one of the best happy hours in Columbus. They have such a wide selection of drinks and food choose from for..."
MyMy Huynh
"Found this place while walking around downtown Columbus. It was the only place with available patio seating on a beautiful day, so we quickly grabbed..."
Lauren LaPinta
"Gear relaxed atmosphere. Friendly service with great recommendations. The burrata was so good that my picky son even enjoyed..."
Colt Hall
"Early Mother's Day brunch with my family. I got the Cajun shrimp and grits. Shrimp was cooked perfectly. I wish it had a little more heat to it since..."
SAVY CHAN
"First time visiting and I’m impressed. Food, drinks, and service was excellent. I highly recommend the..."
Auriel Melson
"Ummmm, this place was quite literally delicious and we had the absolute best service from the bartending staff! Every single food item was delicious..."
De’Andrea Cherry
"Great local spot with a fun vibe good food, decent bar selection. Portions are healthy and priced well. Salmon was..."
jonah sigel
"Had a reservation room with family and friends for an event during brunch. The service was very good from our waitress and my Cajun shrimp and grits..."
Eric Watts Jr.
"Excellent food, atmosphere and service. The pizza and drinks we ordered were excellent, came out at a decent time, and the women serving us was..."
Owen Kabelitz
"There must be a reason that Forno is always packed. I figured it out because Forno is one of the best restaurants in Columbus. Their pizzas are..."
Vincent Lam
"Delicious food, both the pizza and pasta were very tasty and neither was toooo expensive, we also loved the atmosphere and the design of the place...."
Robbie Austin
"I recently visited Forno during happy hour on a Monday and was impressed by the lively atmosphere and accommodating service. We decided to try the..."
Trisha Mae
"Great vibe, great service great food. Great spot for a business dinner on the Short North, the service was on point as was the food. Never felt..."
Corey Amaya
Zwanzigz Pizza & Brewing
91
/100 (1155 ratings)
Quick Bites
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Lunch
Late Night
Dinner
Sandwiches
Salad
Lasagne
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"This is a pretty cool little spot. The atmosphere is dark and chill, with wood everywhere. Started with the breadsticks, which were amazing! Very..."
Chris Frost
"This is the best pizza in Columbus. I highly recommend the spinach ricotta calzone! Their breadsticks are the best ever, and pizza is fantastic as..."
Eliza Thompson
"Had the best time! The food was amazing and Carissa was such a delight to talk to! She was always on the go. I’m pretty sure she named every beer..."
Abby Hall
"Any lover of beer, wine, and/or pizza should run here immediately!! The atmosphere is a nice mix of modern brewery with a local pizza joint. Their..."
Jess Hughes (saxyjess)
"Pizza is good. They make a pretty big one. They also have liquor they make right there on site. You can see the big containers that they use to brew..."
Charles Grissom
"Good pies, good pints. I've been there several times now & like eating in the restaurant rather than taking them to go. Everything is so much..."
John Hopkins
"We were in town for a competition and stopped in for a quick lunch. Nice atmosphere, quick service even though they were busy. Friendly staff,..."
K- OHS
"Friendly staff, Clean Tables. We came at a busy time but the staff was still able to get our order out in a timely manner. Pizza and breadsticks were..."
Derek N.
Adriatico's New York Style
91
/100 (1728 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Pizza
Italian
Italian
Deli
Vegetarian Friendly
Lunch
Late Night
Dinner
Salad
Fast food
Italian
Pizza
Serves Alcohol
Delivery
Takeout
Television
Seating
Table Service
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Since I live in the 'burbs now, I hadn't actually had Adriatico's Pizza since my time at OSU. Awesome pizza, just as I remembered! Two of my..."
K N
"Despite it being a busy weekend Downtown and move in time at OSU, we got great service and our food was perfect and on time. My husband prefers the..."
MaryBeth Brown
"Came here with a really high expectation. The toppings tasted juicy but the crust was mediocre. There are a few big screens filling up the dining..."
Vincent Lam
"This slice of New York Pizza goes above and beyond. The staff are unbelievably friendly and professional. It felt like fine dining. The pizza choices..."
Mateo Rosa
"Great food, great prices, great staff of which I was a member ás well as a customer. I love eating here they have the best food! My managers and..."
Heather “JerseyGrl”
"Although the food was amazing, the service was even better. Our waitress was Carla (with a C!) and she was amazing. She was very helpful and very on..."
Madison
"Pizza perfection. Average size wings but spicy garlic is full of flavor. Amazing service from the moment we walked in the door. This will be my go-to..."
Jason Waddell
"The Inflation Buster... It's good. Sauce is a little spicy, and not sweet at all. It's not overly sauced. Crust is pretty good, the beef needs more..."
Brother Myers
"We had a great meal! We came at dinner time so 7:20 waited a little over an hour to get seated. They were very busy. That was a good sign to me! We..."
Jim Weaver
"This was our 1st time here. We went for lunch had the thick crust and it was excellent as was the jalapeno egg rolls. Definitely go again! Our server..."
Stuart Poe
"One of the best pizzas I've ever had. An individual pizza was less than $10... and it was fantastic! Well worth it. I had the buffalo chicken and my..."
J. Justin Boggs
"Adriaticos has been a favorite of mine since college; the pizza is filling, fresh and delicious! We had a large delivered for our team retreat and..."
Carver Ealy
"We stopped in while waiting for Uber prices to decrease after a show at the Ohio stadium. We sat at the bar. Bailey was our server and she was very..."
Brittany Wasmus
"I ordered from this place because it had a ton of good reviews , but I wasn’t a big fan. I’ve had better pizza at other places in Columbus...."
Charlotte Kruse
"Affordable, fresh, & locally owned ... oh, and ... fresh gelato you can take home by the pint 🤤 birthday cake flavor was delicious 👌 Great..."
Anthany Krebs
"The best pizza I’ve found in CBUS. Order the Sicilian (thick crust) and you definitely won’t be..."
E Smith
"Great, cozy and friendly atmosphere! a friendly smile was at the door to greet us with an amazing scent of pizza embracing our nostrils. Pizza was..."
Hayley Simone
Rubino's Pizza
91
/100 (2079 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Lunch
Dinner
Pasta
Salad
Pesto
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Dinner
Cheap Eats
"Excellent family owned traditional style pizza diner with excellent service amazing pizza. We'd heard so many good things about the place for a long..."
Kevin Mahaffey
"A family favorite for many years. It's always good and always consistent, which is the key to success. They have the thinest crust you will find and..."
Toni Hill
"The best pizza anywhere. Thin, crispy crust, spicey sauce. Used to get pepperoni, sliced crossways in squares. Grew up going there in the late..."
Susan Schneider
"My best friend and I go here every time I am in town. It is our spot. The pizza is fantastic and the service is always top of the line. I love this..."
Darienne Kaiya Elaine
"Update: we decided eat at the place on friday and man it was crazy busy. The definitely could use at least 2 more people, one server and someone else..."
Jacob Golick
"The food was great. We sampled a bit of everything and weren't disappointed. A couple of odd points though. They do not have ice water. It's bottled..."
John Dorries
"Go get a large pie. As someone from the East Coast, I stand by the opinion that this pizza is better than a New York slice. Crispy pepperonis,..."
Molly Waldeck
"Great local mom and pop style pizza joint. Very reasonable and inexpensive prices. A large pepperoni pizza and two large salads were $25. Very thin..."
Kaleena Gross
"Tonight was our first time trying Rubino’s and it’s an instant classic! Delicious Columbus style pizza with a thin cracker crust! There was no..."
Kim Robertson
"Had the best Italian food in a long time. Being from New York it is hard to find Italian food that is not Spanish style. It was better than Olive..."
Gloria Soto
"This place is a family run shop, open for dinner only. The pizza is unbelievable 🤤 I'm a thin crust aficionado & this is HEAVEN 🍕 Thin crunchy..."
Karen Landry
"Thin and very delicious pizza. It reminded me of a slice when I visited Italy a few years ago. The large pizza with extra cheese was so good I ate..."
Miguel Hernandez
"Excellent thin, crispy crust. Delicious sauce and cheese not too thick. Good selection of toppings (including anchovies). Good prices. Sausage was..."
Ann J.M.S. Harlan
"Old skool pizza. Good pizza, place is a throw back to the 60s and 70s. Go in with low expectations and then enjoy the food and experience. It..."
Brad Henry
"Excellent pizza (pepperoni is outstanding) at a low price. No credit cards, call-in orders almost impossible. Worth the..."
Robert OConnor
"Absolutely amazing pizza. Best in Bexley for sure, maybe best in Columbus. CASH ONLY, and extremely crowded. Yes, there's parking. Plenty of it -..."
Yitz Jordan
"Simply put, an icon. I've been going to Rubino's for as long as I can remember. It's an absolute institution in Bexley and all of Columbus (and..."
Jeff Janis
"Rubinos. This ol place is kinda cool. Prices are high though, and they only take cash. I walked in the rain to an atm because people rage about..."
Leavy Peretto
"A must try if you like thin crust pizza! Very unique and absolutely delicious. Carryout and dine-in only. No online ordering or delivery. Also, cash..."
D F
"Pizza was very tasty I liked the Columbus style cracker thin crust. One thing to be aware of the restaurant is cash only. I had to go nextdoor and..."
J C
"Pizza was good. Ravioli was ok. Pizza comes in a paper bag. Have help to carry your order if more than one item. Nice to see a long standing..."
Jeremy Chapin
"Delicious and filling! But location is VERY DATED. Carry-out is probably best. Cash only!! The taste is unique and worth it. Parking is in lot or..."
Clayton Giovanni M.
"Fantastic pizza that proves to b much better hot so don't plan on a cold pizza snack. Otherwise the food is great. Cans of pop not fountain add to..."
Stephanie Kelley
Trevioli Italian Kitchen
90
/100 (908 ratings)
Restaurants
American
French
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Alfredo
Meatballs
Cheesecakes
Shrimp
Lasagne
Tortellini
Tortelloni
Lobster
Osso Buco
Pasta
Creme Brulee
Salad
Shrimp and Grits
Crab
Chicken Alfredo
Scallops
Lamb
Duck
Bruschette
Risotto
Pesto
Ossobuco
Cheesecake
Crème Brulée
Café
Italian
American
French
Wine and Beer
Gift Cards Available
Free off-street parking
Family style
Non-smoking restaurants
Dog Friendly
Takeout
Reservations
Dinner
Mid-range
"While visiting Columbus my husband and I decided to stop by and try the pasta I got the Cajun pasta and he got the crab macaroni. First let me say..."
TiJuana Jackson
"The restaurant has a nice atmosphere and friendly staff. The entrées were very tasty (Manicotti and Chicken Parmesan) but the Chicken Parmesan..."
Nick Dudzinski
"The service was great..... and the food was really good. The atmosphere is very romantic, perfect date night experience. The hostess was super..."
Marteka Cox
"Surprisingly delicious Italian cuisine is a hallmark of this quaint local eatery. With entrees averaging $25 it does come at a bit of a cost, but if..."
Matt Lamb
"The food and vibe is always amazing at this location! You get well over enough food for the price. Trevor is phenomenal in the kitchen. Our server..."
Cassidy Jackson
"Our server/bartender was awesome,very knowledgeable about the menu and..."
Teresa R
Figlio
90
/100 (380 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Pizza
Italian
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Dinner
Pasta
Salad
Pesto
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Reservations
Dinner
Mid-range
"I went to Figlio for the first time on a Saturday. The food was good, but portion sizes are on the small end. I will say be ready to wait for a..."
Darian Louke
"My husband and I wanted to take our kids here for dinner. We had our first date here almost 19 years ago. Food is always flavorful and servers are..."
Jen Heimann
"Its very nice. Food was tasty... pizza and pasta very tasty...people must..."
T S
"Reminds me of the food in Italy. Everything is delicious, but if all they had was the bread, it would be worth the..."
Cris Letourneau
"Nice meal. Next time I get the spaghetti sauce on the side. I like my noodles not in soupy sauce. But the sauce was so delicious. Even the garlic..."
Carole Klaue
"My experience overall good. The restaurant itself is nice. My problem: we were seated next to a large window and initially it was ok, but as we sat..."
Jean Green
"My family & I have been enjoying the food, service, and atmosphere of this restaurant for many years. It’s also a favorite spot to take friends. I..."
Katie Flowers
"One of our favorites! However, I wish you'd bring back the crab stuffed ravioli! Service is always exceptional, food comes out timely & hot, with..."
Phil H.
"Haven't been for a while but food is great. It is a limited menu but that just means all are done well. Great service from..."
Robert Kurth
"What a great eating experience. Great food, service was excellent. So fun to sit & watch the oven with actual fire inside it. Scallops n shrimp every..."
K A (Kaki)
"Consistently great food and service. Cannot go wrong with any menu options. Always start w/copious amounts of bread, red wine and the balsamic salad...."
Jenna Davis
"Caesar salad and their pizza was on point and great. Pricey but good. I used to live in NY and their pizza was thin crust, good sauce and baked..."
Viktor Boyko
"The wine not the best but the food is..."
Toria Tyree
"I consider myself an intermediate foodie and home chef. The Lemon Chicken pasta is one of the best things I’ve ever eaten. Absolutely perfect...."
Rebecca Bass
"Pizza crust wasn't as crispy as I expected for a wood oven. Restaurant was full and very noisy. Hard to carry on a conversation. Service and food..."
Sandy Schlaudecker
"The food was great!!! The issue we had was the long wait to get the food and the waitress never offered us more drinks. The old fashioned I ordered..."
jason marks
Angottis Italian Restaurant
90
/100 (211 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Italian
American
American
Dinner
Salad
Alfredo
Lasagne
Italian
American
Reservations
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Dinner
Johnny's New York Style Pizza
90
/100 (1235 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Lunch
Dinner
Salad
New York Style Pizza
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Takeout
Television
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Johnny’s never disappoints! Fez was great! The Meat deluxe was on point And my daughter tore up the spaghetti! I’ll definitely recommend to..."
Jennifer Biggers
"It’s just the best pizza in town. Great service. Fast. A little treasure that’s hidden but oh so delicious..."
Linda Dillard
"I'm from NY and this is by-far the closest thing to NY pizza I have ever found outside of the Tri-State area. Awesome and I will be back for..."
Charles Comfort Jr
"The place by far some of the best pizza in..."
Trevor Kibler
"We ordered online, they said pick it up in 30 minutes. We did just that! It was pizza perfection, hot and ready to go. I love ordering online ,pay..."
Kathy Leeper
"Loved my Stromboli! They have a good selection on the menu. I look forward to going back and trying the..."
Sharon Pollock
"Been going to Johnny's for some time now. Greatest and best tasting pizza in the City of..."
David Phillips
"Our favorite go to place for Italian & pizza - on a weekly..."
Melinda Friesen Fuller
"My husband and I stopped by traveling through town today for the first time. The Stromboli we ordered was fantastic! What impressed us most, however,..."
Jennifer Williams
"Food is always delicious. The Johnny's special calzone and meatballs are to die..."
Lisa Parsons Smith
"Been going there since they opened! Favorite garlic knots and large pepperoni pizza � fresh hot all the time and they rock! Great people great..."
Joy Marchbanks
"Best pizza and calzones around, so fresh and delicious. Wait staff is great too. Worth the wait for a freshly made..."
Donna Goodwin Dickson
"We chose this randomly. And we did not regret it. The food and the service were..."
Angela Cross
"Very best pizza around! Great service, atmosphere, you will not be disasppointed! Real Italian dishes that are..."
Linda C Luttrell
"One of the few places my whole family can agree to eat at! It's always an enjoyable..."
Bobby Ratliff
"Great staff, awesome pizza! Give it a shot. Live..."
Justin Jodo Creed
"Good Pizza and EXCELLENT Calzone. Pretty cool atmosphere. Check it..."
Chris Fluharty
"My husband and I went for our 20 year anniversary! We enjoyed our slices! Server was great! We will definitely go..."
April Wofford
"As usual the slice was fresh and delicious. The salad was fresh and hit the..."
Ed Fuller
"Thank you for letting us celebrate my daughter's 4th birthday today! Pizza is her fave, and Johnny's has become her place of choice to endulge! Tori..."
Tamara Reyes
"Delicious as usual. Great..."
Audrey Hall Bergeron
"Closest thing to my hometown as you can get for pizza..NYC would be..."
Anthony Rolon Ortiz
"Great pizza and fantastic service. Caitlin is highly recommended by..."
Kyle Romine
"Very professional, great service, best pizza in Columbus,..."
John Bookout
"Reminded me of being home in NYC....delicious pizza and cannoli! Happy Italian woman and the server was awesome! Very sweet and..."
Catherine Stephanie Bagarella
"Love their Lasagne! It's sooooo cheesy and..."
Bea Glenn
"Awesome Food, Great Staff, and the best lunch special in..."
Nathan Thompson III
"This was our first time eating from this restaurant. We ordered our pizzas to-go. These pizzas were amazing!!! They were so delicious and so fresh..."
Kristin Colburn
"Excellent food and the service was great…the best pizza I have had in a while…thumbs up and 5 stars for Johnny’s definitely..."
Nelson Jaramillo
"Pizza it very good pastas not too good calzone excelente totally recommended for pizza and..."
Jonyisa SAN
"My first time eating here at Johnny's New York Style Pizza, and I enjoyed it. The food and atmosphere was very nice. And our server really was..."
Mary Davis
"When our Grandsons visit, Jonny's pizza is one our favorite places to meet papa for lunch! The one slice 🍕 is perfect for us! Sweet service and..."
Lisa Summerlin
"Stopped in for a late lunch and we each ordered the Italian Special. Cooked to order and was very good. Clean and accommodating with plenty of seats...."
Kevin Lee Jackson
Berwick Manor Restaurant
90
/100 (748 ratings)
Restaurants
Steakhouse
American
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Italian
Steakhouse
American
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Brunch
Sit down
Italian
American
Steakhouse
Reservations
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Brunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"Berwick catered our wedding on June 17, and I cannot think of enough wonderful things to say. The food was by far the best catered food I have ever..."
Katherine Manning
"If you think the food served by The Berwick is great, wait until you experience their customer service and attention to detail…truly OUTSTANDING. ..."
Rick Amos
"Great traditional Italian food, Nice place for events and catering. Highly..."
Scott Humphrey
"The best place to have Thanksgiving ! Great food... Awesome..."
James K. Mathis
"Great place for a meeting... Great food and especially good waitress who took really good care of..."
John W Zanewych
"Love, love, love The Berwick! Wide range of menu items include homemade pastas, breads, excellent seafood and mouth-watering..."
LuAnne Russell
"I have to say their food is very impressive! This is the second time the zoo union has had its party there and it has had great food both times. The..."
Kelly Pyles
"Berwick Manor catered my daughter's and son-in-law's wedding. The food was absolutely fabulous. Chicken piccata, flounder stuffed with crab,..."
Lynn M. Folk
"Initially this was a one star review. We ordered Thanksgiving dinner and when it was picked up my husband was there for over two hours waiting. I..."
Jessica Peters Harris
"Berwick Manor is my families favorite place. The food and service is always great. And if you have an event there they will make sure your experience..."
Tonya Ransom
"This place is great for events. I have probably had their catering dozens of times throughout my life. The food is above average italian food, and I..."
Trained Creeper
"We were lucky to have the Berwick team cater our wedding at Swan Lake Event Center, they did an amazing job! The food was delicious and one of our..."
Jessica Zuritis
"We were fortunate to have the Berwick team cater our recent wedding at Darby House, and they truly exceeded our expectations. The food is amazing and..."
Abigail Anacki
"We booked Berwick for our wedding in December 2023. Not only does Berwick provide incredible food, but they also provided first-class service &..."
Sam Bernardo
"Best service ever! MR. Anthony and Ms. Liz are amazing! So professional and kind! Always had food and a drink! They are the beat at catering. The..."
Amanda Davis
"The Berwick catered my wedding on 9/2 at Combustion Brewery. Leading all the way up to the wedding the communication was fantastic, and they let us..."
Iron Sam
"This is a seriously amazing team. Not only were they able to work around our many changes, but the food was incredible! I highly recommend their..."
Makenzi M
"The catering experience provided by The Berwick for our wedding was nothing short of extraordinary. We were referred to The Berwick from both our..."
Kendra Smaldino
"We have attended several special occasions at Berwick, and the food was always good. However, the Thanksgiving Buffet was excellent ! The food,..."
Rebecca lloyd
"Came here for a elevation celebration dinner back in July. This food was AMAZING!!!! The service was very kind. Building was clean and put..."
MaidenSweetRae
"Spectacular takeaway meal of mushroom risotto, tortellini in vodka sauce, amazing green beans, delicious lasagna, perfect prime rib, started with an..."
Lorence Sing
"The Berwick catered our wedding and we were absolutely blown away! They were so helpful during the planning process, and even during the week leading..."
Zack & Yaz Valdman
"Berwick catered our Christmas party! OMG! Meatballs are amazing! Chicken picatta is out of this..."
Deb Gelpi
"Liz was super kind and Anthony was so personable! The dynamic duo I didn’t know I..."
Madison Orduna
"Ordered a ahead online. Went to pick up the order. Plenty of parking and the employees were..."
Susan's Jewelry Boutique
"This is the perfect place to host a..."
Dee Baldridge
"A great place to have a company party food is really..."
Adam Pitts
"Food was fresh and home made. Made Thanksgiving & Christmas dinner for 6 so easy. Got to pick up day of holiday, was hot & ready to..."
Nicole Su
Trevioli Italian Kitchen
90
/100 (1069 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Shrimp
Pasta
"While visiting Columbus my husband and I decided to stop by and try the pasta I got the Cajun pasta and he got the crab macaroni. First let me say..."
TiJuana Jackson
"The restaurant has a nice atmosphere and friendly staff. The entrées were very tasty (Manicotti and Chicken Parmesan) but the Chicken Parmesan..."
Nick Dudzinski
"The service was great..... and the food was really good. The atmosphere is very romantic, perfect date night experience. The hostess was super..."
Marteka Cox
"Surprisingly delicious Italian cuisine is a hallmark of this quaint local eatery. With entrees averaging $25 it does come at a bit of a cost, but if..."
Matt Lamb
"The food and vibe is always amazing at this location! You get well over enough food for the price. Trevor is phenomenal in the kitchen. Our server..."
Cassidy Jackson
"Our server/bartender was awesome,very knowledgeable about the menu and..."
Teresa R
Sbarro
90
/100 (2 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
"Fabulous NY pizza! Crust is perfect, sauce luxe, toppings primo. I first had this pizza back in Brooklyn in the 1950's. The quality taste and aroma..."
Tim Carlin
Auddino's Italian Bakery
90
/100 (961 ratings)
Dessert
Bakeries
Italian
Italian
Breakfast
Italian
Breakfast
Cheap Eats
"I can remember my Dad taking me and my siblings here when we were kids. Brought back so many memories. I truly love the Auddinos. Family..."
Chevonne R.
"Stopped by Auddino’s Bakery to grab some donuts. And the guy who helped me was pleasant. I grabbed 3 donuts and that was about it. The donuts were..."
George Bolden
"GREAT BAKERY 👍! TRY THE BLACK N WHITE COOKIES!!! WE WILL 1000% BE BACK. 🩷🩷Mrs Herb here....This is the best Italian bakery I've been in a..."
Herb Butson
"This is a great mom and pop shop. The owners are so kind. Great pastries and cannolis fresh buns made everyday. They also will deliver large..."
M Earles
"We used Auddinos for our wedding reception's dessert table and we couldn't have been more pleased. Everyone L O V E D the dessert tray and..."
Nicole Trexler
"The best place to go in Columbus if you want to make your own Italian meal. You can get sauces, pizza dough and a variety of breads. And everybody on..."
Brad Fruchey
"Great bakery with great prices! Cannoli was amazing as was the doughnut I ordered. Lots of other options as well. Would highly recommend checking out..."
Reed Schick
"Auddino’s Italian bread is the best Italian bread I have ever had. Ever. It’s light, fluffy, and soft on the inside, and the crust is likewise..."
Kelli Hughes
"The best cannoli I've ever had & wonderful folks working here. 11/10. Good flavor, crunchy texture, not too sweet, nice smooth consistency in the..."
Phil
"My Dad loves to stop here every chance he gets. It's sad that they're doing away with the fryers cause I love Stix donuts. I left with a canolli..."
Veronica Flemister
"This place came highly recommended in multiple local Facebook groups. It did NOT disappoint!! Everything tasted so fresh, the guy working in their..."
Randi Classen
"Best bakery in Columbus. Everything they make is outstanding but the glazed croissants are my..."
Eric Clark
"We love Auddinos! The owners and people that work there are so kind and their cronuts, lobster tails, and cannolis are..."
Sarah Gordon
"THE best Italian rolls & buns you will ever have. Any restaurant in Columbus that has a note worthy Italian sub uses Auddino’s rolls & sub buns. I..."
Hannah M
"Ordered a few biscotti and cannoli and I already have plans to go back! Everyone was so friendly and the pastries were so..."
Emily Gummere
"Best donuts in Columbus. Possibly Ohio? They are always fresh and so soft and flaky. They also have a great selection of subs rolls and other..."
Shelby Booker
"Delicious and authentic Italian pastries and breads made as if right from the old..."
Michael Reed
"Giovanni and His sons are the reason I am a chef excellent Italian bread less the inflated prices... able eatting there bread since I was a Child..."
Empress Pepe
"The BEST donuts in Columbus, OHIO !!! The bread and buns are AMAZING. Biscotti is in ANOTHER LEAGUE. My..."
stevie c
Carfagna's Kitchen
89
/100 (2246 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Lunch
Dinner
Cannoli
Pesto
Sandwiches
Pasta
Salad
Alfredo
Tiramisu
Meatballs
Bolognese
Lasagne
Sit down
Italian
Television
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"My wife and I ate a late lunch here on Black Friday, 2023, around 135pm. Service: The hostess wasn't really friendly. No smile and didn't greet us...."
Luke Varner
"Carfagna's had the best Italian food in Columbus! I love all of their pastas, and they also have very good appetizers. The atmosphere is great, the..."
V Rock
"We go several times a month for the meat and wine tastings. Always top notch quality and experiences! The restaurant is so lively and friendly staff...."
Chrisi Hagan (Realtor and Tech Trainer)
"Carfagna’s restaurant is clean. The employees are nice the weight staff is great, Dani took good care of our party of three people for a late..."
Jim Ray
"We went for a late birthday lunch and it was very good service. They do have gluten free pasta (penne) and gluten free pizza. Both are great but I..."
Rochelle Stapp
"Really good food, kitchen was a little slow. Server was great but seemed to be stretched thin so visits were few. Very basic decor, lots of hard..."
LifeOutdoors 2day
"First time eating in the restaurant and the service was fast and the food was hot and yummy! Good selection of appetizers. We chose the half pan..."
Heather Neil
"Mixed feelings on this. I buy their sauce in the store all the time. Our waiter was superb. Food was okay. Ordered the eggplant parmesan and just..."
Cori W
"I ordered the Stromboli and my wife ordered a salad with dressing on the side. After a long wait, the salad came out with the wrong dressing already..."
Gordon Shumway
"I had a chance to stop by for a after work outing and boy was I amazed. The smoked cocktail was delicious and the food was very different and..."
Scotch With E
"Loved it! We came here after a golf lesson and had a great time. The food was awesome and the service was so fast. And the wine selection was..."
Candice Boelter
"The food here was very delicious. The noodles and cheese and sauce are all hand made. The presentation was beautiful also. The waiter delivered the..."
Christine Malott
"Stopped in here on a whim. This restaurant put a lot of thought into the atmosphere. We bought some wine from the shop but the market was closed. We..."
Sara Davis
"Great food then I picked up all the things for lasagna and some frozen ravioli in the marketplace. Heirloom tomatoes, candy onions, all the good..."
Monica Bower
Basi Italia
89
/100 (1418 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Shrimp
Ribs
Lobster
Creme Brulee
Eggplant
Crème Brulée
Lamb
Pasta
Pesto
Salad
Fish
Scallops
Pork
Oyster
Calamari
Risotto
Mussels
Calamares
Salmon
Sit down
Italian
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Valet Parking
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Dinner
Mid-range
"This place is always fantastic. Enjoyed mussels and the halibut and my partner got spaghetti and meatballs (off menu), all great. Not pictured is the..."
Grant Donnelly
"Every single dish was delicious. We had an excellent server who was helpful and knew the menu. Parking is basically non-existent but $10 valet was..."
Gary Mabrey
"If you're looking for a fantastic Italian restaurant within walking distance, with great servers and excellent food, I highly recommend Basi Italia...."
Scott Jebbia
"Absolutely delicious food that is unique and tasty. Less than perfect valet and atmosphere. The wait staff is friendly and super knowledgeable but..."
Christy Campbell
"My friend made a reservation after reading the reviews, and I was not disappointed. Although the interior was small, it created a cozy atmosphere..."
M Lee
"A small intimate restaurant, food is solid and serve great. Wish for a little more extensive me u but the rigorini and Caesar salad were fantastic...."
chad tassin
"Absolutely incredible night! The atmosphere is amazing and our server Jessie knew the menu like the back of her hand. She was super personable and..."
Mikah Pransky
"Pretty good meals! Discovered this little gem about a year ago. I've been a handful of times and have never been disappointed. Both indoor and..."
Abby Humphrey
"My husband and I went for a date night and loved our experience. Loved the ambience of the restaurant. We chose to sit inside. We got the pistachio..."
Sarah Wawerek
"Excellent meal, service and ambiance! Our daughter brought us for dinner. She couldn’t get a reservation, so we just went at 7pm on a Friday. We..."
Amy Barricklow
"The ambiance was perfect the food was fresh and delicious. You can not go wrong in any way. Our server was wonder pairing the perfect wine to both..."
Lea Lawler
"Absolutely the best Italian in Columbus. I can’t rave about Basi Italia enough! The food never disappoints. All the appetizers, entrees and..."
Brooke P
"One of the best meals I've ever had. Small, intimate space with attentive and friendly staff. The most delicious mussels, which is saying a lot for..."
Chelsea Ritchey
"We loved the atmosphere and the food was amazing! I had the eggplant parmesan and their homemade tiramisu. I've never had better! The service was..."
Chavon Wilson
"Italian gem tucked away in Victorian Village. The flavor profiles and wine selection are on point and best enjoyed on the private patio. Intimate,..."
Toni Sacco Lee
"You will so hate it here. Knowing I keep this world class small restaurant and wonderfully engaging staff as my secret paradise on Neil. The food..."
Kevin Boyne
"I came across this place by accident because I was looking for a place for restaurant week and everything was booked; except this place. I was very..."
Shamelle Nikita
"Absolutely delicious meal. Drinks were tasty. Service was..."
Laurie Fair
"This truly was an amazing experience. We've been trying to get in for almost a year but never seem to plan far enough in advance. For Valentine day I..."
Phillip Simpson
Pizza House
89
/100 (3741 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Lunch
Dinner
Pasta
Salad
Meatballs
Pesto
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Takeout
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"We tried pizza house for the first time last week and it was great! The line to pick up on a Saturday night was long, but they got to everyone..."
Randi Classen
"ATTENTION ALL PIZZA CONNOISSEURS!!!!!! This place gets my MUST TRY PIE AWARD!! I tried the old world pepperoni and sausage with extra cheese and..."
Mark
"It was another Italian night for dinner. Tristan was my waiter and did an excellent job tonight. Decided I would have Lasagna. Salad and bread came..."
MRBARBQ 1
"Ok first time trying it read reviews said it was good. So I drove 45 min to try it It was good but I think it needs a little more garlic flavor but..."
K Bowers
"Exquisite Service from ANGEL - with a smile and a "very nice style"! Linda and I visited with our friends, we call "family". "Friends are family you..."
Keith Carey84
"This place had a 30 minute wait to get seated so, I was very excited and really expected some great food! The antipasto salad was very good and the..."
Jim Weaver
"Yup, this place really is that good. Pizza House has been in business since 1961 and has a very loyal local following. At the time of this writing,..."
Tool Man
"Staff was very nice and friendly!! This is a must have pizza 🍕. Never had a bad pizza from Pizza..."
Damon Reynolds
"Old world pepperoni was great. Asked for well done and it was perfect for my liking. The sauce is not overly sweet or acidic. Chicken Parm was pretty..."
Jacob Rorabaugh
"We used to eat here all the time when we were much younger. We had lunch there today with an old friend and the pizza was even better than we..."
Marita
Marcella's
88
/100 (5288 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Lunch
Dinner
Sandwiches
Alfredo
Shrimp
Meatballs
Bolognese
Lasagne
Eggplant
Tortellini
Pasta
Chicken Parmesan
Salad
Tortelloni
Clams
Bruschette
Calamari
Pesto
Risotto
Paninis
Calamares
Sit down
Italian
Television
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Outdoor Seating
Reservations
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Nice atmosphere and the food is terrific. My wife and I went for lunch and she had the Spaghetti Carbonara and I had the gnocchi both were..."
Bill
"Architect. Food was above average and at a great..."
Cwolniewicz
"Entrees were fantastic - I would come back again for the food. We wanted to try the melted peccorino appetizer but the server forgot it...not..."
Skydvrn
"My husband and I LOVED this restaurant! We are from out of town, and this is some of the best Italian food either of us has had in a while. The penne..."
Becca M
"Fantastic food and service. Had great drinks too! Was extremely impressed with atmosphere, food selections, professional, fast service and friendly..."
Chen Lee
"I ate at Marcella's about 6 months ago and was decidedly underwhelmed. However, we went there tonight, and it was wonderful! Everything was..."
Amanda D Gamble
"I love Marcella's for happy hour! Even though it gets a little noisy and busy I've always had great service and great food. Nick is the best server,..."
Steph
"We went to Marcella's Polaris location for a family occasion, there were 10 of us. We loved everything about our experience. I loved my gluten free..."
Candy C
"Great Value!. Polaris Grill had limited service for Sunday limited to a buffet so, we decided to try this Marcella location. It's as good and as..."
Bob Weir
"Good!. Fettucine Alfredo with marinara meatball! The meatball will fall apart, so moist! Warm olive..."
Jennifer
"Love it. Gluten free pasta made my day. My dinner companion was not impressed, then again he can eat pasta anywhere. He still complains about how..."
Maureen M.
"Probably our favorite restaurant. Cameron Mitchell has a knack for knowing what people like as far as the food is concerned, but the experience, too...."
Ryan Squire
"Love the Food. I am a big fan of Marcella's. I have been several times to both locations and really enjoy the style of the restaurant and the food. I..."
Bd03
"With such an upscale décor, Marcella’s should be on the short list as possible date night restaurants. But you’d be better going there for an..."
Rick Ives
"To start it all off, we ordered a Sicilian Caponata which is a Roasted Eggplant Salad with Olives, Capers, Roasted Red and Green Peppers. This is..."
FoodieInDisguise
"Marcella Italian Kitchen offers a truly creative and delightful dining experience. I was pleasantly surprised by the innovative presentation of their..."
Jisu D
"I could not have asked for a better gluten-free experience. Jamie was a fantastic server with her enthusiasm and love of the dishes we picked. The..."
Liz Love
"I left a previous review on a previous reservation for this Restaurant and The general manager Austin reached out to me. Spoke to me via not only..."
Ann Cooper
"Wife and I had reservations for dinner and we were excited because we hadn't been to Marcella's for a few years. She still recalls the first time she..."
Doug B
"You come across GF restaurant reviews and it's always a shot in the dark..maybe its good, average or just mediocre. Not today! Today was the..."
Malissa Swigart-Park
"My straight up go to when in Columbus. Wait staff is top notch and food is the real..."
Thomas Joseph
"We stopped by mid afternoon on a Sunday, were pleasantly surprised to find out there was a lunch special. It was 12.99 for a half portion of pasta..."
Donna Arnold
"We had a great lunch experience at Marcellus. Our waiter was wonderful, and especially good with my six-year-old and eight-year-old granddaughter...."
Chris Sayler
"It’s Cameron Mitchell so the food is typically edible. We waited WAY too long for our drinks. Granted, it was a Friday night but 15 minutes for 2..."
Mitchall Metcalfe
"Really good food and very celiac friendly! The waitress was very helpful in answering questions about allergens and gave great..."
Kelsey Bowers
"Great service and Italian food with GF options for their pizza and pastas which is nice. The Salmon Al fresco is amazing and a must..."
Caitlin Phillips
"Loved the "pasta your way". Got Alfredo, with sausage. Best sauce I've tasted yet. To the point I was pushing myself to eat more past full cause it..."
Za Rand
"I can see why this is a popular place. Recent visit was ok, most of the time it we get good food and great service. Can't recommend the pizza, but..."
Rob Asher
"Amazing! The arancini is my most favorite ever! And I love that they serve linguini Alfredo with their chicken parm. I will be back..."
B LG
Tommy's Pizza
88
/100 (5414 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Lunch
Dinner
Salad
Pizza
Italian
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Last night, I had the pleasure of dining at Tommy's Pizza, and it was an experience I won't soon forget. As a pizza aficionado, I'm always on the..."
Turisvivenda Turisvivenda
"Still the BEST pizza and subs in town! Their fried cauliflower is also delicious. A true institution!! Call ahead for dine-in times or order take..."
Keri Mihalco
"Tommy’s was a household staple growing up and now there’s not a location close by, so when we were near campus, I couldn’t pass up the..."
Miranda O'Dell
"Yummy omg idk there was pizza out there so good and reminds me of my childhood pizza.... So so..."
Jules Holland-coy
"Where to start with Tommy's Pizza? Well I've lived in the Columbus area for over 18 years and have never eaten at any of their locations - I know..."
Colin Flack
"There's only ever going to be ONE Tommy's Pizza and when it's gone, there will never be another. I'm still sad the Tommy's I grew up with on the far..."
All About My Art
"Best pizza ever. Consistent flavor for decades. I live in a different state so I am lucky to get it once a year and it is deliciously..."
Selene G
"My client and agreed to have Tommy's Pizza two days ago. She has years of experience with them and just raved over them. Now I can rave! The crust..."
Mtcklsd
"Literally the BEST and biggest meatball sub I've ever had. The pizza was so, so, so mouth watering delicious. I can't believe it was my first time...."
Nicole Magee
"A Columbus staple from way back. Tommy's is on everyone's list of places to eat pizza and for good reason, Columbus thin crust at its finest. Family..."
toby simon
"Had to comeback from Florida to get great..."
Mike Keating
"One of my childhood favorites. The place is old, the decor is dated, and the pizza is timeless! The staff are fantastic and really capture that great..."
Daniel B
"Best pizza ever. So thin and flaky, crisp and delicious. I ate a large by myself. Didn't even have time to take a..."
Mateo Rosa
"Went here on a date and the pizza was the bomb. Great salad and I love the ranch dressing too. Great..."
Lori C
Caffe Amici
88
/100 (732 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Lunch
Dinner
Pesto
Shrimp
Eggplant
Pasta
Salad
Calamari
Calamares
Alfredo
Tiramisu
Lasagne
Carbonara
Sit down
Italian
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Full Bar
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"My husband and I went in tonight for dinner, and I think this was hands down one of the BEST eat-out meals we have ever had! We started with the..."
Gabby Young
"Excellent service, waitress was great and enjoyed the food and the Peach Martinis, delicious! And when we finished our meal we were not rushed to..."
Debbie Rae Wangle
"Absolutely delicious, service was excellent! By far the best calamari in town! I highly recommend Caffe..."
Max Corona
"Food was excellent. Stuff to the gills and I ordered the small plate. Of course we had the scallops appetizer salads entree and..."
Susan Quinn
"This is the hole in the wall italian restaurant that I have been lookin for our anniversary dinner. Excellent food and service! Cannot wait to go..."
Stephanie Glover Holloway
"They get 5 stars from me! Love the atmosphere, food always on point, hot and delicious!!!!..."
Dee Dee Lester Williams
"No longer living in Columbus, sure will miss this place. Small, family-owned, place. Loved the food and the..."
Gary Lawhon
"Me and my Wife had dinner here last night and really enjoyed it. Did not have a long wait and the drinks and food were out in above average time. Our..."
Mike Norris
"Always had a Great Birthday there they did get back with me and I appreciate that..."
Tony Anthony Marano III
"Love the food!!! You must try!! Everything is fresh & made to..."
Charkara Abron
"Had this for the First time today!!! Boy have I been missing out!!! It was..."
Terri Kelley
"Absolutely great Italian food with tons of options for several dishes. Try the desserts too, but some of the pictures on Google Maps were prior to..."
Lance Ruis
"Always delicious!!! If your looking for authentic Italian food you've come to the right place!! Excellent service and hospitality as..."
Famous Nate
"Went here for the wife's birthday dinner. Never been 1st time. The staff was super friendly and helpful. The dinning are was clean and spacious. We..."
James Whitten
"Second time going since we came to Columbus and unfortunately that’s only because every time we go we spend almost up to $200 on food. But it’s..."
savanna stiefel (sasasavanna)
"First time here, but definitely will not be the last! Server (Noel) was awesome!! Fast, knowledgeable and super friendly!! Food was AMAZING!! Like..."
Sean&Tj Wiggins
"We really enjoyed our meal there. The mushroom soup was awesome and I loved the Shrimp Rosa! My husband had the veal Marsala and enjoyed it as..."
Ronald Burton
Big Tony's Pizza And Pasta
88
/100 (2126 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Lunch
Dinner
Fast food
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Ordered 13 pizzas and salad for a large lunch meeting and Big Tony’s came through in a big way! They were on time and I got rave reviews from..."
Kim Garavuso
"Stopped by this place today after reading some reviews about it. Chatted with the owner for a little bit. Been in this spot for around 5 years. He is..."
MRBARBQ 1
"Stopped here for the first time this evening. I ordered an Italian sub. It was the best tasting sub I’ve had in a long time. Better than..."
Dog Lover
"Great food, friendly staff, and quick service. No frills dine-in experience, but anything you need or want they will get. It's about the food. While..."
Brennan Plummer
"So happy with my order from this restaurant! I was so pleased with help retrieving a receipt, weeks after the order, because I needed it for work!..."
Brittany Sinzinger
"A friend recommended this place and I love this spot! I called in and they told me they don’t do any pork products!! Which is a slam dunk if you..."
Deanna Dawson
"Wow! This pizza at this place is fantastic! The crust has a good flavor and isn’t too salty, it’s just the right thickness, thin but not so thin..."
Jeffrey Bryan
"Big Tony's is a strip mall pizza place off of Worthington Galena Rd, north of Columbus. You might not think much by looking at itsince it's..."
Colin Flack
"I got one cheese and one veggie pizza. Both made fresh and quickly. Everything was delicious. Service was great and friendly..."
Rowan Trotter
"Pretty good pizza. The only con was the crust, I thought it was a little too hard and dry. I would definitely come..."
Mark B.
"Stayed in columbus for the weekend. First time ever eating here. Will definitely go back. Great..."
ernie malec
"I love this place. I've had quite a few things from their menu and everything is always amazing! Tonight we had cheese ravioli and meatball pasta..."
Kelly Lynn Hill
"I moved to an apartment nearby around 3 years ago. I got their pamphlet menu, and had an exploratory whim, so I tried them out. I don't know what it..."
Jacob Nickel
"Pizza is pretty good but the Italian subs are off the charts. Sooooo good. Bread is nicely toasted and has a great chew, good meat and cheese ratio,..."
Elizabeth Ball
"Checked out this local pizza spot for the first time the other day. The pizza was good and they were very friendly and..."
Tod Bowen
Nicola Restaurant
88
/100 (1826 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Tuscan
Central-Italian
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Drinks
Dinner
Bass
Shrimp
Lasagne
Lamb
Pesto
Fish
Pasta
Salad
Scallops
Duck
Calamari
Risotto
Calamares
Sit down
Central-Italian
Tuscan
Italian
Serves Alcohol
Accepts American Express
Wine and Beer
Gift Cards Available
Accepts Discover
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Outdoor Seating
Reservations
Seating
Takeout
Table Service
Television
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Private Dining
Drinks
Dinner
Mid-range
"This was my second visit to Nicola. I had the same waiter and he remembered me. For an appetizer, I had the grilled polenta. The menu description..."
Thomas Vasale
"It's the best restaurant in Columbus. And Italian. Everything is made from scratch (based on my taste buds, which are pretty sensitive). My wife and..."
James J Worby
"Perfect evening dining outside. The food was perfect, the waiters timing was on point. Literally the best timed plate clearing and next course..."
Christopher Hastings
"La nostra cena era magnifico! This was my first time visiting and I cannot wait to come back. I had the Sgroppino rosso to begin, a refreshing drink..."
Anna Maurya
"From beginning to end- it was perfect. Service, wine, entrees and dessert! Honestly the best Italian food we’ve had outside of..."
Nikki Campagna
"What a great meal! From the moment I walked in till we closed the place down, I felt like part of the family! What Incredible food--I had the lasagna..."
Meredith Jones Frey
"We came to this restaurant with a party of 20 people. We were treated wonderfully and the food was amazing!!! People in our group were passing..."
Shelley Frey Drobnick
"Fantastic food and great outdoor patio. Love the outdoor gardens..."
Kate Scott
"Every time I've come here the service is wonderful, the food is always delicious, the cocktails lovely, and the ambiance warm and inviting. Both..."
Jessica Ricci
"Great place. Service and food excellent. Had the meatballs and fish..."
Bob Averitt
"Food is delicious and there is a great selection of Italian wines. I strongly..."
Tiziana Forni
"The food was excellent. Service was prompt, and the waiter was attentive without being intrusive. Even the cappuccino was nicely done. Definitely..."
Paula S. Moreland
"Best Italian in Columbus! Convenient to us and eat there often. Really nice patio,..."
Eric Boardsen
"I really loved the ambience and the Christmas Eve menu had some nice choices. Was a little disappointed with desssert options - but I didn’t need..."
Michelle Adrienna
"Best lasagna I've ever had!!!! Service was exceptional- wine list extensive! Great experience to be..."
Patricia Doyle Borg
"We sat at the bar and ordered off the bar menu. Everything was excellent. We always have to have the lemoncello cake! We love the food and the..."
Dedra Turner Lloyd
"My wife and I recently just came back from Italy and Nicola reminded us of Italy so much. The home made pasta is amazing and the Lemonchello dessert..."
Michael Boyd
"Visiting Columbus for the weekend, I was looking for something quaint with a nice outdoor patio. I’m so glad I came across this restaurant. The..."
Amy Leffler (Thetravelroamad)
"Decent place for Italian. Went for happy hour, and everything was pretty competent and very well priced. The server behind the bar seemed less than..."
Luis Delos Santos
"Nicola is the best restaurant. All pasta is homemade, every dish is delicious, service is amazing, the restaurant itself is beautiful. They have a..."
Mary Snead
"Absolutely wonderful experience. We celebrated our 18th wedding anniversary here and everything was wonderful. The service was A+ and the food was..."
Shannon Hoelscher
"They did such a great job creating the atmosphere, you can’t tell you’re right next to a busy road or that the parking lot is right next to their..."
Lana Brady
"Chef Nicola's place is the best dinner experience we have had in years. We went to the coursed wine dinner and it was such a fun experience from..."
Andrew Studenic
"This was our anniversary and we wanted to celebrate with fine tasting Italian food. This was it! Outside on their patio, sipping a tasty, tart..."
bruce hutson
"I was worried that after traveling to Italy, I wouldn't be able to find anything that would taste like Italy back home in Columbus. After doing some..."
Doug Wensink
"Came here originally on my birthday last year . The food is just amazing. The chef / owner is from Italy and knows how to cook. The homemade pastas..."
K “This is KP” P
"Excellent food and service highlight this wonderful restaurant on the north side of Columbus! I was recently visiting family and we decided to go to..."
C. Eric Scott
"I was in town for business. A little research led me to having dinner. Everything from my appetizer through dessert was right there at the top with..."
Kevin Clifford
"Meatballs were why I came in for dinner but the lasagna will bring me back time after time. Lasagna is fabulous. Great wine list with wide..."
Laura Watson
"One of the best Italian restaurants I’ve ever been too! The atmosphere was so cozy and nice. Our server, Igor, was very attentive and did an..."
Jessica Dillon
"Very good food. We saw our server going outside into the garden to get fresh herbs for our drinks, which is about as close to farm to table as you..."
Jonathan Zuhosky
"Wonderful food, beautiful garden setting, knowledgeable staff. Chef Nicola and wife Esperanza greet you. The patio makes you think you're in..."
marguerite wachunas
"Wonderful food and wine! Best Italian food I’ve had in the US. Looking forward to coming..."
Jeniffer Brubaker
"A place to feel like a special guest, or family member. Food is outstanding, wait staff excellent, & pleasant table settings, with appropriate..."
Shar Vaz
"I was in Columbus for 4 weeks for work and of course I find this restaurant on my last night in town! If I would’ve known about this place my..."
Deena Ward
Marcella's
87
/100 (2991 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Lunch
Late Night
Dinner
Tortelloni
Prosciutto
Arancini
Crostini
Noodle
Lamb
Polenta
Beef
Bruschette
Pesto
Alfredo
Antipasti
Tiramisu
Torte
Eggplant
Meatballs
Pasta
Bolognese
Salad
Lasagne
Crostino
Clams
Cannoli
Calamari
Carbonara
Risotto
Tortellini
Calamares
Chicken Parmesan
Salmon
Sit down
Italian
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Television
Valet Parking
Reservations
Seating
Lunch
Late Night
Dinner
Mid-range
"Great place! I ordered the carbonara and loved it, very satisfied with my choice. Others at my table ordered the chicken Parmesan, meatball with..."
Mackenzie Balle
"Outstanding service. We had a large party to work with. The staff was so helpful and made it a wonderful experience. The food was excellent. ..."
Gina F
"This place was great! It was fun for a nice birthday dinner date, and our server was super fun and kinda. The baked rigatoni was delicious I highly..."
Robbie Austin
"You know when a restaurant is going to be great when you walk in and you see stacks of freshly baked breads upon entry. Every single item that we..."
Warren S
"I don't know if i should be sharing this but I believe I saw the best service I've ever seen in my life here. Also... every single thing that was..."
CHRIS NIX
"Great meal, service, and atmosphere. They were nice enough to hold our reservation as we were stuck in OSU traffic. Our waitress Jasmine was..."
Kenneth Patterson
"I was in town for work and this place was absolutely fantastic. Every portion of the meal was delicious. The server was also one of the most..."
Sean Gage
"Great food, got the Chicken Parmesan with Marinara, really good - cocktails were also very good. Waitress was a little slow getting back to us, but..."
lane zay
"Went with a group. Super crowded but didn’t see many people waiting to be seated! Had a tortellini mix, not sure of name. Acaricini?Perfect..."
Linda Kruse
"Had a reservation for happy hour 4-6pm, got seated right away at 5:30! Staff was very friendly and quick. Half off apps so we got the meatball,..."
Austin Yochus
"A little pricey for what amount you are served, however, we were stuffed full because the food is so very rich. Thoroughly enjoyed the fresh taste of..."
Hannah Moore
"I just recently hosted a luncheon for 25 guests at Marcella's in the Short North. Luke, the manager, went out of his way to accommodate our party,..."
D Sadiq
"I am here right now. Great atmosphere. Friendly service at the bar, even as it gets busy. But the food shines. I ordered the zucchini friti amd and..."
Martin Fox
"If you're looking for a great happy hour with abundant choices, this is it! Their half off happy hour includes cocktails, small bites, soups, salads,..."
Morgan Rudell
"Fantastic service and a really great menu with some traditional Italian dishes. Delicious cocktails to go with the good food too! Can't wait to come..."
Allen Kinzalow
"AMAZING! Highly highly recommend. People with Celiac - you’re definitely safe here! They take it extremely serious and the gluten free food was..."
Meredith Governor
"Carson was fantastic. Definitely get the meatball for an appetizer! Amazing food, great drinks, excellent..."
leslie linn
"Amazing service and amazing food. By far the best Alfredo sauce I've ever had. I had my husband order the meatball and pasta thinking I didn't like..."
Valerie Pulver
Mabella's Italian Steakhouse
87
/100 (920 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Vegan Options
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Ossobuco
Cheesecake
Shrimp
Halibut
Beef
Lamb chops
Pasta
Tiramisu
Salad
Meatballs
Crab
Cheesecakes
Calamari
Lasagne
Risotto
Lamb
Mussels
Bruschette
Steak Frites
Pesto
Calamares
Fish
Salmon
Sit down
Italian
Accepts Visa
Private Dining
Reservations
Accepts American Express
Street Parking
Seating
Table Service
Accepts Discover
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Dinner
Fine Dining
"This is absolutely the best restaurant in Columbus. Let me start with the welcoming, knowledgable, professional, and all around wonderful staff. We..."
Emily Gray
"OMG, this was the best Italian restaurant that I have ever been, our server Kevin was on point with his knowledge of all of the different menu items...."
Bonita Macklin
"Amazing! Best steak I've ever had. We had a good experience with our waitress. I was very surprised how fast our food come out. Our experience and..."
Jaime-Crystal Villegas
"We had a wonderful first experience at Mabella's! We had the pleasure of sitting in the upstairs dining area and had the most wonderful waiter..."
Danielle Charlonne
"This place is warm & welcoming. 2 story dining and Food & Service was very impressive. Filet is so delicate you could pull apart so tender, marinated..."
Melanie Friesen
"Wow! Just Amazing. The food was great, service was happy and friendly! The cheesecake is hands down the best thing in Columbus. So impressed by this..."
Caitlyn Back
"It is a rare occasion I stumble upon a restaurant that I would be proud to rate five stars. Mabellas is one of those. I have been BLOWN away by each..."
Maddie Olson
"My first time. Our server, Kevin and the others, that came by our table were friendly, caring, masked and respectful and knowledgeable about the..."
Wanice Blackshear
"It was a top of the line experience. The waitress was a joy to have as she served with the upmost professionalism and kindness. The food was very..."
Yolanda Upshaw
"The rib eye and the mushroom stuffed ravioli were good but the mussels were excellent. The small wedge salad was with gorgonzola not Bleu cheese..."
Michael Cutro
"Make reservations or plan on eating at the bar because this little hole in the wall is a popular eatery in the community. The staff was extremely..."
Alyssa Moody
1
2
3
4
5
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred!
Please try again in a few minutes
Sign in with Facebook
Sign in with Google
Sign in with Apple
By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
-
Privacy policy
-
Terms of use
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes