1st time here and was SO GOOD! I wanted to try the "ice cream sandwich" and ask the guy for recommendation. He said his favorite was sugar cookies with the moose tracks ice cream, and he was right! It was fabulous and will definitely get it again ❤️🤗 Great recommendation, great cookies and will definitely go back!
The first time I ordered 12 different cookies they were packed in the larger box to accommodate the order. The second time I ordered 12 cookies I got a smaller box with only 7 cookies. After placing a call to the store, the order was corrected to my satisfaction immediately. I like the cookies. Especially the vegan chocolate chip cookies. They taste like the original chocolate chip cookies. I would recommend this location because the cookies are tasty and they will correct your order if they make a mistake.
The chocolate chunk cookies (regular, vegan, and double chocolate chunk) were all fantastic. They were soft but still had a satisfying crunch, and the chocolate was gooey and delicious. The m&m cookies were obviously older, crumbly, and a little stale. Overall this Insomnia is great, but it's getting very expensive.
These cookies are so dank u gotta wait in line and the line goes outside the door. My favorite is the chocolate mint cookie. They have good choices to pick from and its awesome how long these things stay warm for. These cookies are baked to perfection and its awesome how late you can get them.
Listen and listen good. These are the best cookies ever. I dont care which city you find insomnia in they'll be the best in the city. I just dont understand how they get so much peanut butter packed in one cookie. They are the softest, warmest most peanut buttery cookies ive had. Oh and if you really want to take it up a notch heat then up.a little and add a scoop of vanilla ice-cream in top. YOU'RE WELCOME 😊
Been there multiple times at midnight.
My top 3 cookies in Insomnia:
1. Double Chocolate chip cookie
2. Classic Chocolate chip cookie
3. White Macadamia Chip cookie
The place is small and popular so we were crammed in making our order but it was well worth the wait. The cookies are warm and gooey and they sell milk which hits just the right spot. The wait time was not unreasonable given when we came in. They are open late which makes it really nice. Parking can be a pain so bring a ride along to go in while you wait in the car and make life easier for yourself. I will be going back next cheat day.
Love this location! The cookies are yummy, the staff is nice, and they get your order together fast.
The ice cream was too sweet for me. But I love the quick order and hot cookie after night classes. The chocolate chunk is my favorite one.
Got a mixture of cookies, twelve in a box. Each was very good. I love this late night snack!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Columbus
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes