Gumby's Pizza

Hate to leave a bad review for you guys, but the last couple of times I’ve gotten pizza from this location it has been undercooked. I love all the toppings, the menu, the vibe and the staff but man you gotta be able to actually cook the pizza. I just ended up taking the toppings off and eating them because the entire pizza was half cooked. I am not into biting into raw dough, not my forte. Sorry, maybe it has to do with y’all’s employee turnover. Probably won’t be trying again unfortunately. Good luck.

The girl who answered the phone an took my order on June 13th... You are so awesome. It was late an I had a bad day and you were so patient with me and you did exactly what I was asking for. You made my night so much better.. this is the kind of employees we want working in this field. I would def recommend this restaurant to everyone.. thank you so much the food was so damn good.

I called in for a pickup and ordered the Pokey Sticks! They were actually very good and the inside of this little pizza place was super cute and Gumby themed. Definitely hooked on these cheese sticks already. I’ll have to try the pizza next time! I also purchased a Gumby souvenir T-Shirt. Open until 3 am on Fridays & Saturday’s!

The food tastes good, but their integrity is questionable. Placed an order today, the pizza was supposed to be a large and the pokie stix, a medium. Both were the same size. I called them to let them know so that I could get reimbursed, they asked for a picture, so I sent them a picture of the two side by side. The owner seen the pic and said that the pizza was a large. Not sure how one is a 14 inch and one is a 12 inch when they're the same size, but they definitely lost my business. Here is the pic I sent them, so you all can be the judge.

Pizza is decent for Columbia (that in itself would get 5 stars from me). However I just went and saw people in the window, working on making pizza. Unfortunately they have the doors locked and no sign indicating the dining room is closed. Literally if they did, I would be cool cool with it. After checking their FB it says they don't open until 4 PM, but the sign on the door says different. My only suggestion would be to ensure your information is accurate across all platforms.