Review New York Butcher Shoppe - Columbia

These guys always have the best quality products. This steak I cooked was delicious and tender and juicy! My go to spot when I need a good cut of meat!

Always amazing food, whether you are buying a top-end meat for a special dinner, sides to add in, or even appetizers for tailgating. They even walk you through the best way to prepare your food. Highly recommend!

Thank you Jay and the NYBS team for the best service, hospitality, and quality beef in the midlands

Yummy meats. Very great customer service as well.

I recently moved to South Carolina. I've been looking for a butcher shop everywhere I've lived and haven't been able to find one that meets my needs. From the moment I walked in to the New York Butcher Shoppe, I could smell the amazing smoke flavor in the air. I was immediately greeted by one of the workers behind the counter which instantly gave me a welcomed feeling. As I glanced around the shoppe I noticed a variety of precooked foods, a wall of wine bottles displayed in a wooden case under ambient lighting and the showcase of meats, both cooked and uncooked. The selection of cuts was impressive and I fully intend to buy some when I get moved into my house. I spoke to Matt, one of the gentlemen behind the counter, and he answered all my questions about the establishment and what they had to offer. I was very satisfied with the customer service and friendliness of the staff. I came back later in the evening to buy dinner to take home for my family and after warming it up and eating, we quickly came to the agreement that the food had exceeded our expectations. The wings were larger than any wings we had ever eaten. Almost like mini chicken legs. Although a bit over seasoned, it wasnt unpleasant in the least bit. They were still juicy despite being precooked and refrigerated. There was a hint of spiciness to the flavor in the rub complemented with the sweetness that is bbq. We also bought a rack of their house smoked ribs which, to my satisfaction, were not overcooked and mushy like most restaurants I've gone to. Bite tender and perfectly seasoned, I felt comfortable paying the price. We also tried the mashed potatoes, which weren't disappointing but nothing special. Topping them with diced ham was a nice touch, though. The last thing we ordered was the lobster mac and cheese and it was my first time trying this dish anywhere. The tray was heavily packed with mac and cheese. I definitely got my money's worth on that. The cheese was creamy and the shredded lobster was subtle but delicious. My family of 4 couldnt finish the entire rack of ribs, 3 lbs of wings, and the 2 sides. There will be some left over for lunch tomorrow. I will definitely be returning as a regular.

My experience was beautiful. I have two boys work 12 to 16 hour days Just sometimes need a break from cooking everyday. I heard about it, so I stop by. The food is fresh and amazing ! 😉 My boys loved it. I was happy because I did not have to cook, and dinner is ready in 15 minutes tops. I even ask for help with the difference Cabernet wines he had. I was at peace. It was breath taking. I went around 2 pm. I am a black women, who is in the customer services business for over 25 years. The experience was great to me and everyone was helpful. This is my go to store now. I will be a regular! Thanks for helping a tired mom make dinner! 😍😘 P.S. I also like it because it’s fresh and keep in the refrigerator. I rather pick it up and go. Because of the heat I don’t trust food that has to be in the oven delivered .

My son in law brought us some prime filets and some wagyu ribeyes for us to grill for dinner tonight. The waygu was the best steak I’ve had in my 60 years! Just absolutely outstanding. Gotta find a way to have this more often.

Fantastic quality of meat. The prime rib they have each Friday is absolutely stunning! Couple this with the pre-made fresh food and you have yourself a 5 star meal!

We are blessed to have this butcher shop in town selling the best of the best. Makes everything other butcher shop in Columbia look like a McDonald's. The CAB prime bone- in ribeye will change your life.

I love this shop! It has the best meat and ready to bake side dishes!

Wonderful place to pick up delicious meals for a quick easy lunch or dinner. Just heat and eat. My favorites are the tomato bisque soup, chicken parmesan, and the carrot cake is to die for. Will be coming back for sure!!

The quality of food here is matched only by the friendliness and helpfulness of the staff. My favorite food store in town!

Great selection and staff The wine tasting event really gave me a great sample of the quality and preparation of there offerings

Highly recommend! Quality, delicious food and excellent service!

Great service and selection!! Had a great time there with the staff, will definitely be a regular!!

The quality of the products at New York Butcher Shop are outstanding. The staff is informative, funny and they offer something for almost anyone. The catering services are great, affordable as well as the prepared dishes for take out are easy and convenient. You do not have to spend a bunch of money here either.

Tonight we grilled salmon and steak from the Butchershop, and served the Cabernet from last week's wine tasting, with quinoa salad and grilled peaches- gourmet !! If you haven't joined the wine club, sign up tomorrow!

New York butcher shoppe has the best meat, but even better than that they have the greatest heat up meals ever!

Love this place! The prepared meals look delicious, although I haven't tried them yet. I have gotten some AMAZING steaks (had a NY strip tonight and it was perfect), Beaufort shrimp, and even plain old Chicken breasts here, and everything exceeded expectations. I won't buy a steak anywhere else. Side note - if you get a steak, get their steak seasoning. It's a dry seasoning that is the best I've ever had.

Tried something different tonight the stuffed Chicken Pesto, delicious!! Caesar salad rivals our homemade, and thanks Jay for awesome customer service! Lasagne on the menu next week!

Picked up a Prime Ribeye after a long day. Thanks to butcher Lucien Hutcherson for cutting me a steak after everything was cleaned up. The beef and service are A+!

Great product, friendly knowledgeable service! Excellence is the watchword.

Awesome place. Very good quality product. Haven't found a single item that we haven't throughly enjoyed