Sluurpy
Reset

There are 2 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best New York Style Pizza in Colorado Springs

There are 2 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Leon Gessi New York Pizza
85/100 (2951 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
New York Style Pizza
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Takeout
Television
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"This is literally the best place in town to get pizza. If you have not been to Leon Jesse's I highly suggested just take a look at these. Most..."
Madi “Madi Night” Night
"Quick spot that has a fantastic lunch special. Decent sized salad, lightly seasoned bread, pizza slice and a drink for $8.99. I spoiled myself and..."
Quinton Bodry
"Imagine baby Jesus grew to the age of 23 and opened his own pizzeria. He then utilizes the frankincense, mir and gold gifted to him by the 3 wise men..."
Eric Forbes
"Best salads in town!!! You know the salad is clean, not out of a bag and always very, very fresh, no limp pieces!! My husband and I go here often,..."
Candee
"Ok, do not drive this place without stopping. Little funky on the outside and also funky on the inside, BUT the people are so sweet, and the food is..."
Vincent Hoss
"My wife and I really like to eat here! On a normal outing, we'll have the Baked Italian sub and a slice of Pepperoni Pizza! The Italian sandwiches..."
Matt P
"Great hole in the wall pizza parlor atmosphere. Definitely a NY thin crust type of pizza. Love the butcher block pizza with sliced meatballs and tons..."
David Dornbrack
"There’s just something about this pizza that is amazing. Maybe it’s the balance of the crust, sauce and toppings with the perfect baking time and..."
Buck Montoya
"Hands down the best pizza in the Springs. My family has been enjoying this place for several generations. I've experienced only one order mess-up..."
Jennifer Siordia
"absolutely amazing pizza place tbh XD the music is a bit loud sometimes, but other than that the atmosphere is awesome..."
Percey Ichorre
"I was invited here for lunch after helping a buddy move. I'm not super used to the area, but it's a great, low key spot that is exactly what I would..."
woodmster 353
"I've been eating pizza here for approximately 45 years and I will continue enjoying them for the next 45..."
Bonnie Lamkins
"Incredible place! My family and i have been getting their pizza since i was a kid and it is by far the best in the springs and their cheese calzone..."
Elena Dunz
"I can’t believe I hadn’t been here before! It seems like a Springs classic through and through. On Tuesdays they have an incredible special where..."
Veronica Baldock
"Stopped in here on a busy Saturday evening while in town on vacation. Ordered at the counter and took a seat. Piping hot pizza arrived at our table..."
Denai C
"We arrived about 12:15pm just before it got real busy for lunch. Ordered two lunch specials with a slice, salad, and drink for $7.59. One slice..."
R Jr
"The staff were friendly and the food came out in less than 10 minutes. I liked that they added the ricotta cheese to the calzones definitely..."
Alex Matula
"Really good pizza made very fast. Had a 10” pepperoni and the buffalo bread with some ranch, both of which were great. Very reasonably priced for..."
Brian Carter
Joey's Pizza
71/100 (2355 ratings)
Quick Bites
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
New York Style Pizza
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Free off-street parking
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Takeout
Television
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Great to find a place like this in Colorado Springs, even better when we have the same name! 🤣 I love when places have their pies on display and..."
Joey Knapp
"Nolan was fabulous. He was kind and curteous when we told him it was our first time in. We ordered way too much food to try different things out and..."
Sharon Sablan
"Chill place with pretty good pizza, and a variety of alcohol (flavored vodka). Got the Fugedabodit pizza and would recommend it. Looking forward to..."
Michael Moran
"I am a former NYC boy who considers himself a “Pizza Snob”. This is one of the best NY Style pizza I have had in Colorado. Sauce is amazing!..."
Scott Rieger
"The flavor of the day pizza, green chili, was so good! We were some of the only people there and we both chose slices that they had up front because..."
Karianne K
"I just want to say this is our favorite pizza place is COS. The grandma Sadie is my favorite while my husband loves the pepperoni pizza rolls, with..."
Arra Alexander
"The slices here are HUGE!!! As far as NY Style pizza goes, this is some of the best in town. The prices are great for the size of the slices they..."
Tyler Grundvig
"Fantastic customer service and delicious pizza! Joey’s Pizza is our go-to family pizza place so I was excited to partner with them for a company..."
Jamie&Kayla Cyr
"I can’t even express how happy I am! I ordered from Joey’s and saw Zeppole on the menu.. but I expected them to be yucky.. they were amazing!!!..."
TeslaDiva 99
"We really enjoyed the NY style pizza, tasted good. Staff was friendly, place was clean. Very worth the price! TBH I would not know if the pizza is..."
John Martin
"Pizza we ordered was a NY hand tossed with sausage, pepperoni, meatballs and red onion. It was really good. We also ordered some BBQ chicken wings..."
Jennifer Krueger
"I usually only review places that I physically visit, not delivery. It was so good had to review. Got a 24 inch pepperoni. Absolutely HUGE pizza. Fed..."
Josh Homer
"This is my favorite local spot for a NY Slice! Preprepared pizza is always top notch quality and freshness when I get it. Service is always great...."
Bobby Jones (JS Marketer)
"The food is great, friendly service, good prices. I'll definitely be back. Make sure you go there with an appetite because the slices are huge! I..."
Patrick Buhay
"I grew up in NY so it's hard to impress me with wings or pizza and I have been disappointed 99.9% of the time in Colorado. My visit to Joey's..."
Rosalie Rodriguez
"Had a plain slice which was full of flavor! I asked if I could possibly sample one of their garlic knots since I had never tried them before. The..."
Christie DeGraw
"Best gluten free pizza that I’ve ever had! I live in Oklahoma and this pizza makes me think about moving to Colorado. Not joking, kinda. The..."
Triniti Porter
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use