Sluurpy
Reset

There are 2 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Lobster Roll in Cincinnati

There are 2 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Keegan's Seafood
88/100 (89 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
Lobster Roll
"Serendipitous stroll downtown...only to find Keegan’s on Hyde Park, a hidden gem! Lobster Roll, New England Clam Chowder and Dr Browns Root..."
Daniel Bishop
"I've spent a long time looking for a place that carries sushi fish and I've finally found..."
Amanda Hollinger
"Love Keegan's! The fish is always fresh and delicious. The owner, Tom, is wonderful and always goes out of his way to help his customers. Can't say..."
Sarah Palackdharry
"Keegan's on Hyde Park Square has become a go-to for me for fresh seafood. A great place for a lunch as well. Enjoying a blackened tuna salad on..."
Eric J. Allen
"Best seafood in Cincinnati. High quality, fresh, and really great customer service. They take great care of their..."
Challis Hodge
"Great place to grab a lobster roll or salmon & cream cheese bagel. Very nice decor and seating area as well. Great take out food..."
Nicki Slattery
"First time purchase from Keegan's and I am very impressed with the quality of the Blue Crabs that we purchased. Tom was very friendly and..."
Larry Crooks
"The best , freshest seafood in town period. Always unique selections as well. You walk in and cannot smell a bit of fishy, because this place is..."
Dustin Wallace
"Wonderful fresh fish offered daily. Tom Keegan and family know what they are talking about. They will also explain how to prepare your..."
Ginger Brown
"Delicious. Fantastic. Fresh. Tom is an excellent proprietor--his knowledge and passion for food is..."
Lauren Kluge
"Phenomenal sushi-grade fish and helpful, friendly..."
Chris Sternal-Johnson
"Been wanting a Lobster Roll for quite some time. Finally got one from Keegan's and I am in foodie paradise... nom nom..."
Kiki Adams
"Keegan's is amazing! Just made some insanely fresh sashimi with their Hawaiian Nairagi (Striped Marlin) - WOW. Definitely the best seafood in town..."
Matt Krehbiel
"Fabulous!!!! The lobster & crab bisque is amazing!!!! If you love crab cakes...you will be hooked on this one for..."
Nancy Campbell Hingson
"Fantastic fresh seafood. Great friendly..."
Molly Brunton Doyle
"The fresh seafood is quality but the lobster roll and the crab cake sandwich were not at all..."
Tutto Bene
"The freshest fish I've found in town. Just bought some sashimi grade tuna for a poke dish. It was amazingly..."
Pig Fqr
"Nice place great View of Hyde Park Square delicious food small portions if you eat in... owner is very nice and extremely helpful and is very excited..."
Kevin Cornett
"The lobster roll wasn't smothered in mayo and was incredibly fresh. Also had literally the best crab cake I've ever eaten in my life. You can tell..."
Mark Bricker
"We love the fresh, high quality ingredients at Keegan’s Specialty Seafood restraint and market. The gazpacho exhibits hints of fresh basil,..."
Matthew Eshleman
"Keegan's never disappoints. We count on Keegan's for crayfish every year for our Fat Tuesday party. Not only are the incredibly helpful, but it's..."
Leighanna Sims
"I love this little hole in the wall! The resturants was clean, visually appealing, and offered a variety of fresh products. I came here for lunch. I..."
Katie Glazier
"What an awesome experience! I called shortly before 4 PM on Sunday to verify their hours because I found conflicting information online-The owner Tom..."
Campbeke2
"I stopped here for the first time today specifically because I was craving a lobster roll. I typically prefer a hot, Connecticut style, lobster roll,..."
Nathaniel Hott
"Excellent seafood as you'd hope. The Clam chowder is very different then you'd expect but wonderful in its own right. Also, there is an oil..."
My Experimental Life (MEL)
"Best fish monger in all of Cincy. Recently picked up two pounds of AMAZING sashimi grade tuna. Followed Tom Keegans grilling instructions and it was..."
Justin Carabello
"Amazing! So fresh! Lobster rolls, bagels with lox and cream cheese and lobster & shrimp mango salad. Service was terrific and very friendly! Laid..."
Andy Stout
"Popped in for a lobster roll by myself during the Hyde Park Art Show. Very delicious! Plenty of lobster, not greasy and not swimming in mayo. Will..."
Eileen Jenkins
"Just had a lobster roll for lunch. Amazingly delicious Maine style lobster roll. Impressively fresh for this region. Casual and open atmosphere. Very..."
Renidea
"Brooklyn transplant loving this lobstah roll! They use tarragon which is a delicious twist! One suggestion.... give the people of Cincinnati free..."
Marlene R
"Really good seafood. The crab cakes are a little small,but everything is fresh and it's a great..."
Amanda Schwallie
"I wanted to try something new and stumbled upon a delicious surprise! Very cute decor and great service. I definitely will be..."
Lanise Ware
"Hooray! It's time for Mussels and Keegan's has the..."
Shelly Jarrett Bromberg
"Thank you Tom for the grand tour! What a wonderful fresh market! The sculptures are also..."
brett palmer
"Loved the lobster roll and bought other goodies. A bit pricey..."
Christine Bissmeyer
Court Street Lobster Bar
84/100 (1639 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
Seafood
American
American
Dinner
Lunch
Lobster
Salad
Clam Chowder
Crab
Lobster Roll
Poutine
American
Seafood
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Overall, this restaurant scores high on all the major categories in my book. Categories such as food menu, bar selection, ambiance and service. We..."
Andrew Javosky
"****Update/Edit*** After an unpleasant experience last weekend Dan and his staff made it up to my wife and I today. Service was top notch and more in..."
Ted Belt
"First off, I'm allergic to seafood and shellfish. I always want to try out new restaurants when they open. I never thought I'd set foot here, but as..."
Ria Matlib
"We tried lobster poutine fries, lobster Mac n cheese and the Maine and Connecticut style lobster rolls. Everything was delicious and we had great..."
Beth Bergfeld
"I've been to this place twice now and it's my favorite seafood place. The food is always amazing and melts in your mouth. It's a must when you want..."
Alyssa Kay
"Lobster bisque was the best I’ve had in Cincy. I had the Maine Lobster roll & it also was fresh with lots of great flavor. This may be my new..."
Catherine Lanier
"Food was great! Fingerlings cooked in duck fat took a while but worth the wait. Lots of lobster on my sandwich. I will be back. Sucks my husband is..."
Jacqueline Bond Good
"It wasn’t what I expected. Totally casual for a lobster place. It was great food and great..."
Jennifer Hutcherson
"Finally made it to this place! OUTSTANDING lobster rolls, lobster bisque and drinks! You can’t go wrong with the Maine roll or Connecticut roll so..."
Melissa Engelhard
"Long-narrow restaurant, ample seating, beautiful bar, friendly staff who took the time to share their story with my daughter and I while we waited...."
Shawn Dafoe
"Great, authentic Maine lobster rolls, plus so many other yummy sides. The lobster poutine and lobster Mac & cheese were amazing. The chowder was good..."
Colleen Holt Thompson
"Everything was delicious! Maine lobster roll, lobster mac n cheese and caramelized Brussels sprouts. Will definitely be..."
Jackie Jewell
"Everything was wonderful! We had lobster roll and lobster pops with lobster Mac n cheese! Clam chowder was the super yummy..."
Kim Krefting Hardy
"Recommended by a friend...excellent food and service. The cole slaw was wonderful! The lobster roll-amazing and we talked to our Massachusetts..."
Sherry Lynn Morgan
"Lobster bisque was to die for. Lobster roll was Exceptional!! Will be back..."
BrentDenise Morris
"Stopped in here on a whim several months ago when I had a lobster craving and fell in love! We’ve been back several times since and have not been..."
Jennifer Haas
"Was in Cincinnati for a whole month, once I found this place I frequented a few times per week. Stellar food, great..."
Travis Cleary
"One of the best smoked fish dips I’ve ever had; I order 2 at a time. The Shrimp Bánh mì is surprisingly juicy & refreshing. Worth a visit just..."
Ian C. Mathews
"Amazing lobster roll!!! Best outside of New England!!! I'll be back!!! p.s...."
Andrea Anusbigian
"We were a hard group to satisfy because 3 of 4 grew up on the East Coast. We LOVE all the food we ate. From our appetizer of poutine and crab cakes..."
Marla Gitelson O'Brian
"Delicious! We cannot wait to come back and try the other lobster roll..."
Angie Riou Meister
"The Lobster roll and Lobster Bisque soup was amazing. If you are traveling to Cincinnati.... must make a lunch stop at the Court Street Lobster..."
Debi Koncsics Zeren
"Awesome food and drinks! The summer salad with cantaloupe and prosciutto was so tasty and the lobster rolls are stuffed with big chunks of..."
Karen Stuart Gelety
"Great lobster Mac and cheese 🧀 and the Brussels sprouts and bacon 🥓..."
Eileen Maloney Blades
"Had an amazing scallop/lamb/lobster/wine pairing event this evening. Impeccable service, perfect drink pairings(large pours), all entrees cooked to..."
Matt McLean
"Second visit. As great as the first. You wouldn’t expect lobster this good anywhere outside New England but it really is. Lobster rolls and..."
Robert Warren
"This place is pretty nice. The staff is friendly, prompt and notice you upon arrival. There is construction going on outside and at first it appears..."
Sallie McFarlin
"Lobster Roll was fantastic! Lobster was very well seasoned and cooked. The chips on the side were overly seasoned. I enjoyed the Lobster Mac and..."
Victor Martinez
"This little place has been on court street for a few years but I hadn't tried it until today. We ended up getting a shrimp roll and a cod sandwich..."
Dale Yu
"Great place and yummy food! Nice atmosphere! As per the previous review on large lobster pieces, tho I would recommend that the big pieces of lobster..."
SuN MoSs
"Delicious lobster roll! 🦞 I tried the Connecticut style lobster roll tonight. The meat was very tender and perfectly prepared! I really liked the..."
Debbie Fackey
"Tastes just like new england. Really sweet waitress and the chef was nice as well. Definitely want to go back. Happy hour oysters were very..."
K. R.
"This was my first time having a lobster roll and Court Street Lobster Bar really loved up to the hype. I was also impressed with the Lobster Poutine...."
Christopher Meriwether
"Visited with my kids on a Saturday early evening before 6p. Not too crowded and we were seated at a booth right away. We ordered the Poutine Fries,..."
Jacinta Spinola
"We have been coming here for a few years now - best lobster rolls (and lobster pot pie and lobster mac n cheese) around! Our server, Ray, this past..."
Chelsea Milligan
"Quaint restaurant/bar in OTR. Fantastic overall experience, good ambiance, service, and music. Ordered lobster bisque, lobster roll, crab roll, hush..."
London Huenefeld
"Small tucked away but comfy restaurant. Has some very good food. Like really good stuff. Lobster rolls in Lemon mayo sauce and vinegar salt chips. My..."
Amado Hernandez
"Updating and editing review, the surf and turf was amazing, as of about 8months ago it is no longer offered as i was told tonight by Chef on 9-29-20...."
Gary M
"Delicious food served fast. Was very loud, but I'm also older than their normal clientele and we visited early in the evening. Maybe later when it's..."
Kara Monroe
"Great spot for some wine and good snacks. A combo of an appetizer or a soup and a roll was good enough for me to feel full and yet not feel bloated...."
Sohum Misra
"Excellent place to grab a lobster roll or salmon burger. You can tell that the owners have made sure every part of every dish is made to compliment..."
Brian Horrocks
"Food was excellent. Got the surf and turf. Steak was cooked perfectly. Lobster was wonderful. Cocktails were extremely fresh. Only reason it was not..."
Robert
"The lobster in the lobster roll felt cold from the inside - I suspect it was frozen which makes sense since we do live in Ohio but a little..."
Lina Kaval
"First time at the Court Street Lobster Bar, we enjoyed the clam chowder. My husband and I split a cup as an appetizer, I can't imagine having a bowl..."
Deb Haas
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use