Sluurpy > Restaurants in Cincinnati > Goodfellas Pizzeria - Otr
Goodfellas Pizzeria - Otr - Cincinnati - Photo album
This southern girl fell in love!!! I flew to Cincinnati from New Orleans for the weekend to visit my mom and we had dinner here tonight. Im absolutely obsessed with this place! The pizza is phenomenal, the breadsticks are literally longer than deer legs and the service is top tier. I loved the outba
Didn't know you can get legit NY style pizza in Cincinnati. Crispy crust and delicious sauce.
Great pizza, chewy crust and fresh ingredients! Took the pizza to go but want to go back and check out the speakeasy.
Great dinner prior to Ensemble Theater! Friendly service, reasonable prices, nice atmosphere.
The staff here was really nice and personable! We came in right before the crowd got there. They were very friendly. We ordered a whole pizza and it took about 20 minutes to make give or take a bit. It was basic, half cheese, and half pepperoni. The crust was soft and melted in your mouth. The signa
This is a weekly lunch spot for myself and my office mates . Great NY style slices and the breadstick with dipping sauce could be a meal by itself. The lunch deal is an absolutely insane value! Staff there is AMAZING. We have patronized this place dozens upon dozens of times, and the folks behind
Fun multi-story pizza joint. They have wiseguy lounge on the second floor with loft seating as well. Great seasonal and full cocktail menu, lots on draft as well. Everything we tried was delicious. Everyone is very friendly and the atmosphere is chill with a cool vibe. There is also a two story outd
Really great pizza and bread. Drinks up stairs were top notch as well. Service was excellent. Price was really good too.
recommend!! throughly enjoyed our time here and the food was super tasty! loved that we could order by the slice and the options they had. would definitely come back again!
Excellent pizza and breadsticks, great drink variety, reasonable prices, a fine choice for a night out!
An absolute must when in Cincy. We stopped in during our last night in the city and it was perfection. You can choose from ready made pizza by the slice and breadsticks or order from the menu. We went with slices of a veggie, a plain cheese, a pepperoni & sausage, and breadsticks. The sticks come wi
This place has delicious pizza and good vibes. It has an old fashioned speakeasy feel mixed with an pizzeria. We ordered the goodfellas pizza and it was an awesome choice. They also had a really nice selection on the bar with some really neat looking and tasty drinks.
Great speakeasy in Cincinnati. Must try if you like bourbon.
Great place for single slice or whole pizza. The atmosphere is great treated very well by staff and they were very helpful on our selections, being new customers to them. The bourbon bar upstairs is the bomb, very knowledgeable staff. Last time I was there we walked in and right back out not seats.
Excellent pizza! But if it's your first time, I very highly recommend that you go with only Pepperoni (my preference) or plain Cheese. I would never order that way from any other pizza place, but the sauce, cheese, and crust at Goodfellas has just a really great flavor all by itself. Pepperoni ad
Tried Goodfellas for the first time last night and the pizza was delicious! When we went to pick up the pizza, the person at the counter was very nice, too. Also great price for the size of the pizza.
Everyone welcomed me with a cheer. Could be halloween fever, but it was nice. The pizza is really good. The crust was cooked perfectly. I had Cabernet Sauvignon with the tomato and basil pizza. Paired well. If you want to have drinks and pizza, this is a very good choice compared with other pizza to
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes