Great Atmosphere
... Saturday night before Christmas and it was nice and quite...great jam music by the bartender and awesome service. We got the white pizza queen of hearts and another just pepperoni & sausage...house salad was fire...we will be back!!!
A friend took me here and I had a wonderful time! We arrived about 30 minutes before the kitchen closed and the place was pretty busy but the service and wait time wasn't bad at all.
We got the meatballs and the specialty pizza, which was some sort of pizza with garlic, artichoke, and a cream sauce. The meatballs and sauce were delicious and the pizza was perfectly crispy and tasty!
We were looking for a sit-down New York style pizza place and we were not disappointed. Very friendly atmosphere. The pizza was delicious. And I have never had prosciutto offered on a pizza before and it was amazing. They even have root beer on tap for the kids.
Great place for Italian style thin crust pizza. Great beer selection on draft. The house wine was pretty good. Our waiter was very nice and super attentive.
Food, service, and drinks were great! I’d definitely come back and enjoy some of their delicious pizza again!
Jerry The Pigeon And Mike L
+5
We stumbled on this place one evening on a walk. Glad we stayed. The pizza was great and the staff was super friendly. It was an old bar called Paddy Longs. So older reviews still talk about the bacon & the previous food. It’s now all about the pizza!! and they did an amazing job rehabbing it. The best part was the pizza chef, came out to your table with the pizza he made and would check up on you. Very special experience from such a casual spot. They have a full bar too!
I give this 5⭐️
Jerry (the pigeon) gives it 6⭐️ He loved the crust.
The Hot Honey Pepper(oni) pizza is excellent!! Nice draft beer selection. Fun place. Three stars on service because our server turned off all of the TVs even though Sunday 4pm NFL games were on and we were watching. He wasn't happy when we asked him to turn them back on and only turned on one TV even though there are several. We had to turn sideways to even see the one he did turn back on. Sports on TV are part of the atmosphere we seek when choosing a casual place for dinner. Changing it up by turning the TVs off is inconsiderate. Refusing to turn them back on when asked very nicely is ridiculous.
Had a great late lunch here. Had the Bacon Bomb again with lots of leftovers which is a good thing!! The bartender/waiter was great too! Had a fun time with him. The beer selection here is amazing!! The hummus is quite delicious also.
I randomly ordered for delivery last night and I was really blown away. I’m originally from New York so this pie was a very pleasant surprise. Only call out was it’s a tad under cooked - next time I will ask for a bit more well done
The best pizza ive had in Chicago, easily. It was slightly soupy in the center, if it held its shape better it wouldve been perfect. But i loved it regardless. Special shoutout to whatever sausage blend they use, it was DELICIOUS.
Was it worthy of the 8.1? Yes, absolutely and I’d probably go a little higher. Service was on point too. I would say the only con of this place is the lack of appetizers.
Pizza is pretty good, especially if you like NY style. Ask for a little longer oven time as my pizza was just a little soggy in the center, but still good. Be warned parking difficult to non-existent. Service was ok, but we must have hit this place at a busy time as ordering on site and seating was busy and hectic. If you like this style pizza, also try Gigio's pizzeria on Broadway as this is another great NY style Pizza in Chicago.
We visited this place last year, and the meatloaf/bacon sandwich was amazing. It was perfectly done. That's why we put it on our list when we came back. However, this time, I think it must have been a left over from the day before, it was very dried it out and the flavor was not the same. In addition, it took a while to come out even though we got there shortly after they opened and we were the only people sitting down, and there were only two people at the bar.
Please dont crucify me for saying this but....it was damn near too much bacon. Lol...but my bf thought it was PERFECT! Definitely The Go-To spot for bacon lovers. Service was fantastic! The waiter explained the different types of bacon as soon as he brought them to the table. We would absolutely return.
This is such a cozy little neighborhood place. The pizza slaps and the staff was very helpful and incredibly chill. The salad wasn’t bad either. Will def be back
Excellent thin crust pizza! Absolutely delicious. Crust was baked perfectly crisp. You can tell all of the ingredients are top quality. I just got plain cheese and I was so impressed at how good is is. Try it, you won’t be disappointed!
Super fresh ingredients makes all the difference. Great New York style pizza, got the Hot Honey Pepper pizza and the Apple Italiano pizza. It was a good sized pizza given the price point, will definitely be back when looking for that authentic NY pizza feel and experience.
Great addition to this neighborhood. Pizza was very tasty and well cooked throughout. Service was friendly and attentive. Comfortable and approachable atmosphere that welcomes all including kids.
I went to Paddy Long's with a crew of 5 guys to get the Paddy Bomb. What is it? It's 6lbs of meat wrapped in bacon, served with buns and french fries. We went around 1pm on a Sunday and the place was nearly empty (maybe 2 other tables) which was fine since the waitress/bartender was really nice and attentive anyways. The bomb looked as formidable as it sounds, and while cooked thoroughly, it was a little cold. It was good, in the sense that it's meat and bacon, but at the same time tasted a bit bland without the BBQ sauce. It's definitely a fun thing to do with a crew, but eh wouldn't have to do it again.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes