Review Anthony's Pizza - Casselberry

First time to try. We were surprised for the enormous pasta servings 😆 We ordered the their best pizza and you will not regret it. include this in your Must try list

A week ago I got a pasta dish and ended up sick from it. Today my company wanted to order pizza and we made a simple order of half the pizza with bacon and pepperoni light sauce and the other half with tomato, olive, and spinach. When we got the pizza the whole thing was loaded bacon and pepperoni. We called and they made a new pizza however they still didnt put the olives on and instead of giving us fresh tomatoes they put weird tomato sauce goop on top. Gave them 2 tries within an hour it seems like they were more petty than trying to give good customer service. You can tell the first pizza was fresh but the one they remade was a “screw you we dont have time for you pizza”. I was willing to give a second chance after getting sick from the pasta but after 3 chances I will never go here again.

Wish I could give 0 stars tbh. I Stopped by for some pizza and wings - pizza was okay, I’ve had better elsewhere. I ordered Buffalo wings - I was shocked to see my wings come drenched in Buffalo sauce. THICK sauce, like the ones you buy in the bottles. I was literally convinced they went to the grocery store next door for the Buffalo sauce and just threw it on top. Wasn’t even tossed .. it was TOO SALTY. I couldn’t continue past 2 wings.. then I asked for another order and that one was near burnt and still too salty. Disappointed, I asked to remove off the bill since I didn’t eat it and the rude waitress said no. Literally said NO despite me not eating it - then she said the woman in the back wouldn’t take it off either. Finally, they took it off but not before the woman yelled across the kitchen about my complaint and how “they’ve never had that before” as if I couldn’t hear them talking about me. I was baffled at their attitude and how they treat others. Terrible service, terrible food. Save your time and money and go elsewhere. My 5 year old brother could offer better customer service than that woman who serviced us. Please do better, it’s truly a shame.

Expensive for NO REASON… ordered two slices which totaled over $10. One slice was a simple regular cheese slice. I’m from Brooklyn so I’m like ok, must be dam good tasting pizza… nope! It was basic similar to school lunch pizza. Go to Russo’s in Winter Springs. Great NY taste for half the price. I should never had ventured off….

I was born in Manhattan raised in Brooklyn and Queens finally ended up on Long Island for many years before I retired and moved to Florida. I haven't had pizza this good since I left New York 7 years ago! It brought me back to when I was a kid growing up in Brooklyn so I definitely will take the half hour ride just to come back to Anthony's Pizza it is so worth it. Thank you guys for making such good food.

I’ve been a long time customer of Anthony’s pizza but have been exclusively ordering take out because the wait staff is always so rude and unprofessional. However, this weekend my family wanted to dine in so I bit the bullet. Anthony’s must have hired new staff because our waitress was fantastic and provided hands down the best dining experience I’ve had at any restaurant in a very long time. 10/10 recommend the food and ask for Jen as your waitress!

It gets my vote of best pizza in a 50-mile radius. I’m a private pilot and I would rather fly into Sanford airport and rent a crew car and drive to Casselberry for their pizza over anything other pizza places that are closer. Hands down amazing pizza. 🤤🤤

Nice lil family place to get some good new York slices. Great costumer service (thanks Jen). The price for the food that brings back memories are price less. Definitely will go again.