The best Tiramisu in Cape Coral | Sluurpy updated in May

Sicily Trattoria

87/100 (1066 ratings)

Restaurants

Gluten Free Options

Pizza

Italian

Vegan Options

Vegetarian Friendly

Gluten Free Options

Vegan Options

Vegetarian Friendly

Dinner

Lunch

Drinks

Chicken Parmesan

Calamari

Tortelloni

Risotto

Minestrone

Calamares

Arancini

Pesto

Sandwiches

Shrimp

Alfredo

Tiramisu

Eggplant

Meatballs

Bolognese

Lasagne

Pasta

Cannoli

Salad

Tortellini

Clams

Sit down

Italian

Pizza

Serves Alcohol

Parking Available

Highchairs Available

Takeout

BYOB

Seating

Table Service

Wheelchair Accessible

Drinks

Dinner

Lunch

Mid-range

"Sicily Trattoria, Cape Coral Pkwy., Cape Coral, Fl., Here is my 2 cents on the food and chatter.Finally after book marking this a few years..."

Ricky HOLLAND

"Lovely little Italian hole in the wall. Although there was a mixup and they lost our reservation, the staff was very apologetic and went the extra..."

Kelsey Bates

"Out of townera. Came into town for the weekend, first time in the area. The staff was very polite and helpful, you could feel the family run..."

C.larkin86

"Yum. Fabulous dinner with friends. Service top-notch! And food was fabulous!Do make a reservation. The whole place only holds 40 people, and..."

Anned

"WONDERFULL!!!!!. I disagree with the previous review about the staff being rude! I ate at Little Sicily that same Saturday night!! It was..."

Rrmunson

"Mature couple. Love this place esp. the pizza. Great to be able to BYOB. The staff is the best!Outdoor seating coming..."

Mikelson

"Like my nonnas kitchen!. Celebrated our anniversary with a terrific dining experience! The arancini rice balls were perfect just like I remember..."

John Kapusta

"Decent.. Good pizza - not as good as Papa Joes, but decent. Lasagna - so-so. I'm a New Yorker and we lived for a while in Italy - great flavor to the..."

Jim Condon

"Fabulous meal with 6 friends. Food was delicious. Service was outstanding. Michelle, our server was excellent. Please check this restaurant out. It..."

Pat Zeidman

"Great. Was introduced to it in spring of 2012, then it was closed , Rob and Rose introduced us to the place...Awesome! Now that it has reopened in a..."

Bill Browning

"They moved to 1211 E Cape Coral Pkwy. Ordered Gnocchi and Spaghetti Bolognese and food was great. glad to see this place is still around. Pizza has..."

G

"A little pricy, but the owners mom is right in the back cooking all of the meals just like she did in italy. The bolognese is delicious, and I..."

JMM

"So we were looking in the wrong place for the best pizza. You have to go off island to find it. great pizza nice clean place good friendly..."

Joann

"Authentic Italian. You know a place is authentic when the first thing you see when you walk in is an entire table of people who are speaking Italian..."

Bertoni.nick

"Great homemade entrees. Take your own bottle of wine if you..."

Christi Pritchett Sarlo

"Great!. A friend and I went this past weekend (1/22/11) for dinner and it was delicious! We heard you could bring your own drinks, so we brought a..."

Ann

"Our Go To Restaurant. What a treat finding this little restaurant. It's like returning to our favorite restaurant that we enjoyed so much when..."

Orion Anderson

"Wow! Great food!. My family and I recently vacationed in Fort Myers and drove to Cape Coral to try this restaurant, a 25 minute trip. It was worth..."

Tim Reed

"Tom. Wonderful food cooked by two sisters who love to cook and are definitely Sicilian. Arrancini is to die for and the home made pasta is great...."

Tom Logio

"Great People, Great Food. Being of Sicilian origin, I took one look at this place and had to check it out. I have to say it's the first..."

Paul Rausch

"So cute inside, great wine choices and beer on tap, homemade pastas, sauces and desserts, professional wait staff, and the veal..."like budda"!!..."

Dehlia “deal-ya” Garrity

"Simple Italian food with lots of pasta and pizza and they do have beers here too. Mom had the eggplant parm with penne and I chose the spaghetti..."

Bruce K.

"This is our favorite pizza in Cape Coral, we highly recommend it! It's a great NY style pizza with thin crispy crust! On top of the great quality..."

Lillian Day

"Really a excellent pleasure very great service this pizza is..."

Daron Orzech

"Always great service and good food. We've enjoyed many meals here. I highly recommend the linguini with white clam sauce. Their pizzas are great..."

Doug A

"Great atmosphere, excellent service, food is to die for. Their vodka sauce is the absolute BEST! I haven't found any other restaurant in the entire..."

Sandra Lejasbunde

"First time visiting this restaurant. Service was very good and always checking our drinks. Family had a pasta craving and decided to come here. Cesar..."

Alfredo Gibbs

"First visit to this small eatery on Cape Coral Pkwy. Good selection and tasted terrific. Sounds like expansion is in the plans. Highly recommend with..."

Yates Greer

"Excellent food in a small restaurant. Sicilian family from NYC runs it. Perroni beer on tap and deep dish Sicilian pizza is very good. And reasonably..."

Sean Spoonts

"Best pizza ever. Dessert was delicious and very great personal service. There were nine of us and we were all happy with our meals and we enjoyed..."

Caroline Sweet

"One of our favorite places in all of Cape Coral. Vinnie and Manny and their mom and aunt are amazing. Just went last night and had the fettuccine..."

Mary Kalabokis

"A little pizza/Italian place that was exceptionally good. I loved the staff and family based environment here. My husband and I had their pizza..."

Christine Colpaert

"This is the spot. I ordered for take out went to pick up my 2 pizzas, I was pleasantly surprised by the decor. I was greeted by a man behind the..."

Brian Thomson

"Tracie was a wonderful waitress... friendly and attentive. The arancini appetizer was good. Baked ziti with eggplant and ricotta with a side of..."

Kathy Kilgo

"Dinner is very delicious. Cheesy bread is Amazing. Salad’s are Extremely small. Everyone there is very nice. Our favorite place in Cape Coral🍝..."

Tina Dillon

"We had a lovely dinner. The staff was friendly and we ordered Chicken Marcella and Chicken Parmesan and that one needed more sauce. They have a..."

Theresa C

"Finally found a place that serves real Italian foods. The food was plentiful and delicious. Homemade Italian bread was made in house. I had..."

Dave Briere

"Sicily Trattoria, Cape Coral Pkwy., Cape Coral, Fl., Here is my 2 cents on the food and chatter. Finally after book marking this a few years ago I..."

Reset

There are 9 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Tiramisu in Cape Coral

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

Timothy Conley

J K

Kathy Owens

Isabella Mayo

Agnes Logozzo

Michael Howard

Christian Phillippi

Cathy Dawson

Karen Sellner

Maroushka Jo

jackie c

Shad Russell

J Hendrickson

Catherine Fermin Jimenez

Tony Cash

Juanita Howard

Jennifer Bixler

Melissa Alzamora

Liza D’Armas